🎁 Need help finding a gift they'll love? That's our specialty.

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

A Little Joy Just For You!

Join the Olly-Olly crew! Cute outfits, fun toys, and zero overwhelm — delivered straight to your inbox.

By completing this form, you are signing up to receive our emails and can unsubscribe at any time

Gifts Under $25

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.

4831 Results

Clear filters
Marvin's Mind-Blowing Magic-30 Tricks & Stunts

Marvin's Mind-Blowing Magic-30 Tricks & Stunts

$18.95

Sassy Pet Sak - Dino Love

Sassy Pet Sak - Dino Love

$24.95

Phonics Readers Rhyming Animals Books
Phonics Readers Rhyming Animals Books

Phonics Readers Rhyming Animals Books

$6.99

Creature Peeper
Creature Peeper

Creature Peeper

$14.99

Ooly Silver Linings Outline Markers-Set of 6
Ooly Silver Linings Outline Markers-Set of 6

Ooly Silver Linings Outline Markers-Set of 6

$21.99

Ooly Yummy Yummy Fruit Scented 12pc Washable Markers
Ooly Yummy Yummy Fruit Scented 12pc Washable Markers

Ooly Yummy Yummy Fruit Scented 12pc Washable Markers

$12.99

Tractor Boxed Bath Balm

Tractor Boxed Bath Balm

$12.00

Palm Pals - Jolly Green Apple

Palm Pals - Jolly Green Apple

$12.99

Well Kept Screen Cleansing Wipes
Well Kept Screen Cleansing Wipes

Well Kept Screen Cleansing Wipes

$6.95

Butterfly Wishes BFF Necklace
Butterfly Wishes BFF Necklace

Butterfly Wishes BFF Necklace

$12.95

Great Pretenders Ribbon Tiaras
Great Pretenders Ribbon Tiaras

Great Pretenders Ribbon Tiaras

$14.95

3 colors
  • Lilac
Metal kazoo

Metal Kazoo

$5.95

CoComelon JJ Plush Animal Costume Doll
CoComelon JJ Plush Animal Costume Doll

CoComelon JJ Plush Animal Costume Doll

$15.00

4 colors
  • Lion
  • Giraffe
  • Koala
  • +1 more
TOY TOWER 8" Stretchy Alligator
TOY TOWER 8" Stretchy Alligator

TOY TOWER 8" Stretchy Alligator

$7.95

TOY TOWER Squishy Snake (Assorted)

TOY TOWER Squishy Snake (Assorted)

$9.95

HAPE Pull Along Wooden Frog
HAPE Pull Along Wooden Frog

HAPE Pull Along Wooden Frog

$16.99

Janod Noah's Ark Wooden Puzzle
Janod Noah's Ark Wooden Puzzle

Janod Noah's Ark Wooden Puzzle

$22.99

Assorted Dandelion Fluffy Pens
Assorted Dandelion Fluffy Pens

Assorted Dandelion Fluffy Pens

$5.95

World's Softest Socks - Snug Infant Cozy Crew
World's Softest Socks - Snug Infant Cozy Crew

World's Softest Socks - Snug Infant Cozy Crew

$12.00

Good Night Baby Jesus Board Book

Good Night Baby Jesus Board Book

$9.95

Legends Evolved How to Train Your Dragon 3 inch figure
Legends Evolved How to Train Your Dragon 3 inch figure, additional view

Legends Evolved 3" How to Train Your Dragon Figure

$9.95

Pastel Hues Colored Pencils
Pastel Hues Colored Pencils

Pastel Hues Colored Pencils

$12.00

Plus Plus Duo Baseplate
Plus Plus Duo Baseplate

Plus Plus Duo Baseplate

$10.95

My First Bible And Prayers

My First Bible And Prayers

$16.99

Ginormous Hatch N Grow Dragon
Ginormous Hatch N Grow Dragon

Ginormous Hatch N Grow Dragon

$7.99

In My Heart - A Book of Feelings

In My Heart - A Book of Feelings

$16.95

The Night Before Christmas - The Classic Edition HC

The Night Before Christmas - The Classic Edition HC

$19.95

Mint Seersucker Lunch Box
Mint Seersucker Lunch Box

Mint Seersucker Lunch Box

$24.00

19 colors
  • Light Blue Seersucker
  • Light Pink Seersucker
  • Blue Gingham
  • +16 more
Floss & Rock Snap Card Game
Floss & Rock Snap Card Game

Floss & Rock Snap Card Game

$7.95

Petunia Ballerina Plush Mouse

Petunia Ballerina Plush Mouse

$18.99

Baby’s First Soft Book: Tiptoe Tiger
Baby’s First Soft Book: Tiptoe Tiger

Baby’s First Soft Book: Tiptoe Tiger

$16.95

The Tale of Peter Rabbit by Beatrix Potter

The Tale of Peter Rabbit by Beatrix Potter

$9.99

All Better! Board Book
All Better! Board Book

All Better! Board Book

$12.99

New First Yo! Yo-Yo (Assorted)
New First Yo! Yo-Yo (Assorted)

New First Yo! Yo-Yo (Assorted)

$9.99

Tiger Tribe Coloring Set - Dinosaur
Tiger Tribe Coloring Set - Dinosaur

Tiger Tribe Coloring Set - Dinosaur

$20.00

Mudpuppy Mix and Match Kaleidoscopes
Mudpuppy Mix and Match Kaleidoscopes

Mudpuppy Mix and Match Kaleidoscopes

$8.99

Speks Gump Loop memory gel stress toy

Gump Loop

$12.00

6 colors
  • Purple
  • Teal
  • +3 more
Sparkle Waffle Squishy
Sparkle Waffle Squishy

Sparkle Waffle Squishy

$8.99

Chill Cubez Sensory Toy 2.0 Neon
Chill Cubez Sensory Toy 2.0 Neon

Chill Cubez Sensory Toy 2.0 Neon

$10.99

Big Squij Jumbo Banana Squishy
Big Squij Jumbo Banana Squishy

Big Squij Jumbo Banana Squishy

$18.00

Sugar Swaps Sea Slug (assorted)

Sugar Swaps Sea Slug (assorted)

$10.99

Spikes Sensory Squishy
Spikes Sensory Squishy

Spikes Sensory Squishy

$8.99

Gummiez Sprinkle Bear squishy

Gummiez Sprinkle Bear

$9.99

iScream Yummy Gummy Bear Squishy

iScream Yummy Gummy Bear Squishy

$7.99

Squishy Sugar Cube

Squishy Sugar Cube

$8.99

15 Second Dance Party Keychain
15 Second Dance Party Keychain

15 Second Dance Party Keychain

$12.99

FLUFFMELLIES BANANA
FLUFFMELLIES BANANA

FLUFFMELLIES BANANA

$15.00

Endless Bubble Wrap 2Go Mystery Bag
Endless Bubble Wrap 2Go Mystery Bag

Endless Bubble Wrap 2Go Mystery Bag

$15.00

iScream Blue Pearl Lip Gloss

iScream Blue Pearl Lip Gloss

$11.00

Kickpod Footbag (hacky sack)

Kickpod Footbag (hacky sack)

$8.99

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.