🎁 Need help finding a gift they'll love? That's our specialty.

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

A Little Joy Just For You!

Join the Olly-Olly crew! Cute outfits, fun toys, and zero overwhelm — delivered straight to your inbox.

By completing this form, you are signing up to receive our emails and can unsubscribe at any time

Gifts Under $25

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.

4827 Results

Clear filters
Mystery Dumpling
Mystery Dumpling

Mystery Dumpling

$15.00

5 colors
  • Metallic
  • Glow in the dark
  • Regular
  • +2 more
Slow rise butter squishy sensory toy
Slow rise butter squishy sensory toy, additional view

Slow Rise Butter Squishy (Different Colors/ Sizes)

from $10.99

5 sizes
  • Small (Original)
  • Small (Strawberry)
  • Small (Rainbow Tie Dye)
  • Large (Original)
  • Large (Rainbow)
Complimentary Gift Wrap

Complimentary Gift Wrap

$0.00

Wigglitz wiggly animal fidget toys

Wigglitz

from $2.99

2 sizes
  • Single Wigglitz
  • Fill A Bag
Fancy Mystery Streamer Collectible Dumpling Squishy
Fancy Mystery Streamer Collectible Dumpling Squishy

Fancy Mystery Streamer Collectible Dumpling Squishy

$15.00

Dough butter squishy slow-rise sensory toy

Dough Butter Squishy (Assorted Sizes)

from $12.99

2 sizes
  • Small (Original)
  • Large
Spin Copter Launchable LED Helicopter Toy
Spin Copter Launchable LED Helicopter Toy

Spin Copter Launchable LED Helicopter Toy

$6.95

6 colors
  • Pink
  • Blue
  • +3 more
Waboba Moon Ball -1Pc
Waboba Moon Ball -1Pc

Waboba Moon Ball -1Pc

$9.95

17 colors
  • Black
  • Pink
  • Green
  • +14 more
Jumbo cheese-shaped squishy sensory toy

Jumbo Cheese Squishy (Doughy Fill)

$20.00

Glo Pals 4-Pack Light Up Cubes (Assorted)
Glo Pals 4-Pack Light Up Cubes (Assorted)

Glo Pals 4-Pack Light Up Cubes (Assorted)

$12.99

7 colors
  • Red
  • Blue
  • Green
  • +4 more
Coconut Oil Squishy Ball
Coconut Oil Squishy Ball

Coconut Oil Squishy Ball

$12.00

7 colors
  • Pink
  • Orange
  • +4 more
Mini Surprise Sparkle Dumplings
Mini Surprise Sparkle Dumplings

Mini Surprise Sparkle Dumplings

$10.00

Moldable Vaseline Squishy Potato
Moldable Vaseline Squishy Potato

Moldable Vaseline Squishy Potato

$12.00

Fozzi's 18.06oz Bath Foam for Kids (Large)
Fozzi's 18.06oz Bath Foam for Kids (Large)

Fozzi's 18.06oz Bath Foam for Kids (Large)

$15.99

3 colors
Moldable Vaseline Squishy Butter

Moldable Vaseline Squishy Butter

$15.00

Teenie Funky Pup NeeDoh variety pack of mini squishy stress balls
Teenie Funky Pup NeeDoh variety pack of mini squishy stress balls, additional view

Teenie Funky Pup Needoh Variety Pack

$15.00

Big Textured Squishy Ball

Big Textured Squishy Ball

$12.00

Little Golden Books
Little Golden Books

Little Golden Books

from $4.99

Crispy Multicolored Wax Covered Handmade Ball Squishy

Crispy Multicolored Wax Covered Handmade Ball Squishy

$10.00

Mystery Squashy Pastel Dumpling

Mystery Squashy Pastel Dumpling

$10.00

Versible reversible Tap to Pray wristband bracelet
Versible reversible Tap to Pray wristband bracelet, additional view

Versible - Reversible Tap to Pray Wristband Bracelet

$18.00

4 sizes
  • Extra Small
  • Small
  • Medium
  • Large
PRE-ORDER: School Uniform Plaid Headbands
PRE-ORDER: School Uniform Plaid Headbands

PRE-ORDER: School Uniform Plaid Headbands

from $14.95

Small Cheese Squishy Toy

Small Cheese Squishy Toy

$12.99

Albert’s Candy Swirl Pops (Assorted)
Albert’s Candy Swirl Pops (Assorted)

Albert’s Candy Swirl Pops (Assorted)

$5.00

Master Toys Mystery Mini Glitter Dumplings

Master Toys Mystery Mini Glitter Dumplings

$10.00

Azarhia Metallic Knotted Headband
Azarhia Metallic Knotted Headband

Azarhia Metallic Knotted Headband

$16.95

9 colors
  • White
  • Lavender
  • Pink
  • +6 more
Mystery Squashy Dumpling Glitter
Mystery Squashy Dumpling Glitter

Mystery Squashy Dumpling Glitter

$15.00

Squishy Maltose Bear Squishy

Squishy Maltose Bear Squishy

$9.99

Sugar Swaps baby onesie squishy toy
Sugar Swaps baby onesie squishy toy, additional view

Sugar Swaps Baby Onesies

$15.00

Olly-Olly gift card

Olly Olly Gift Cards

from $20.00

Pony Tail Streamer-Purple/Gold Tiger Spirit
Pony Tail Streamer-Purple/Gold Tiger Spirit

Pony Tail Streamer-Purple/Gold Tiger Spirit

$16.99

ASMR Crunchy Soap Squishy

ASMR Crunchy Soap Squishy

$12.99

3 colors
  • Pink
  • Light blue
  • White
Smooshy 2.25" Stress Balls (Assorted)

Smooshy 2.25" Stress Balls (Assorted)

$7.99

Master Toys Mystery Glitter Dumplings

Master Toys Mystery Glitter Dumplings

$15.00

Soft Peanut Squishy Toy
Soft Peanut Squishy Toy

Soft Peanut Squishy Toy

$9.99

Mystery Mini Dumplinz sparkly blind-bag squishy

Mystery Mini Dumplinz

$6.99

Sugar Swaps Onesies - Ice Pops Assorted
Sugar Swaps Onesies - Ice Pops Assorted

Sugar Swaps Onesies - Ice Pops Assorted

$14.99

Ditty Bird song board books
Ditty Bird song board books, additional view

Ditty Bird Song Board Books (Assorted)

$19.99

Maltose Bubble Cube Squishy

Maltose Bubble Cube Squishy

$9.99

Lucky Bao Mini Mystery Squishy Dumpling collectible toy
Lucky Bao Mini Mystery Squishy Dumpling collectible toy, additional view

Lucky Bao Mystery Mini Dumpling (Assorted)

$10.00

Azarhia Purple/Gold Knotted Tigers Headband

Azarhia Purple/Gold Knotted Tigers Headband

$18.00

Wake Up Call Under Eye Gel Pads

Wake Up Call Under Eye Gel Pads

$7.99

7 colors
  • Purple
  • Cheetah
  • +4 more
Orb Easy Sqweezy Rainbow Layer Cake Squishy
Orb Easy Sqweezy Rainbow Layer Cake Squishy

Orb Easy Sqweezy Rainbow Layer Cake Squishy

$18.00

Squishy Steam Buns Mini Mystery Glitter Dumplings

Squishy Steam Buns Mini Mystery Glitter Dumplings

$10.00

Fozzi's 11.04oz Bath Foam for Kids (Small)
Fozzi's 11.04oz Bath Foam for Kids (Small)

Fozzi's 11.04oz Bath Foam for Kids (Small)

$12.99

3 colors
  • Punchy Purple (Grape)
  • Yippie Yellow (Tropical)
  • Outstanding Orange (Orange)
Birthday Cake Boxed Bath Balm

Birthday Cake Boxed Bath Balm

$12.00

Secret Sparkle Mini Unicorn Dumpling

Secret Sparkle Mini Unicorn Dumpling

$10.00

Spiky Orb Squishy
Spiky Orb Squishy

Spiky Orb Squishy

$12.99

5 colors
  • Blue
  • Purple
  • Pink
  • +2 more
Magna-Tiles MicroMAGS 26 Piece Travel Set: Bold Colors
Magna-Tiles MicroMAGS 26 Piece Travel Set: Bold Colors

Magna-Tiles MicroMAGS 26 Piece Travel Set: Bold Colors

$25.00

Pastry Squishies (Assorted)
Pastry Squishies (Assorted)

Pastry Squishies (Assorted)

$12.99

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.