🎁 Need help finding a gift they'll love? That's our specialty.

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

A Little Joy Just For You!

Join the Olly-Olly crew! Cute outfits, fun toys, and zero overwhelm — delivered straight to your inbox.

By completing this form, you are signing up to receive our emails and can unsubscribe at any time

Gifts Under $25

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.

4845 Results

Clear filters
Creative Knitwear LSU Gift Box Booties Boy

Creative Knitwear LSU Gift Box Booties Boy

$18.00

Creative Knitwear LSU Lace Gift Box Bootie
Creative Knitwear LSU Lace Gift Box Bootie

Creative Knitwear LSU Lace Gift Box Bootie

$18.00

Magna Tiles Hamster Ball

Magna Tiles Hamster Ball

$25.00

Pretty Woman Nail Polish - Pastel Galaxy Collection
Pretty Woman Nail Polish - Pastel Galaxy Collection

Pretty Woman Nail Polish - Pastel Galaxy Collection

$9.95

4 colors
  • I Speak French... Fries
  • Vitamin Sea
  • I'm not a ballerina
  • +1 more
EGKD Cat Cafe KidDough Play Kit
EGKD Cat Cafe KidDough Play Kit

EGKD Cat Cafe KidDough Play Kit

$24.99

EGKD Ramen KidDough Play Kit
EGKD Ramen KidDough Play Kit

EGKD Ramen KidDough Play Kit

$24.99

Sassy Pet Sak - Dancin Pups w/ Golden Retriever

Sassy Pet Sak - Dancin Pups w/ Golden Retriever

$24.95

Dope Slimes - Dinosaur Frost
Dope Slimes - Dinosaur Frost

Dope Slimes - Dinosaur Frost

$18.99

Lego Botanicals Tiny Wildflower Bouquet

Lego Botanicals Tiny Wildflower Bouquet

$19.99

Great Pretenders Berry Beautiful Necklace & Bracelet Set

Great Pretenders Berry Beautiful Necklace & Bracelet Set

$12.95

Lilliput Little Things Earrings - Pink Sprinkle Donut

Lilliput Little Things Earrings - Pink Sprinkle Donut

$12.00

My First Fun Felt Shapes
My First Fun Felt Shapes

My First Fun Felt Shapes

$18.99

Love, Cats, and Cowboy Hats: The Little Guide to Swifties

Love, Cats, and Cowboy Hats: The Little Guide to Swifties

$8.95

Janod Pure Animal Baby Looping

Janod Pure Animal Baby Looping

$19.99

Kickee Boys Boxer Briefs - Seaside blue On The Way

Kickee Boys Boxer Briefs - Seaside blue On The Way

$15.95

3 sizes
  • 2T-3T
  • 3T-4T
  • XS 5/6
Living Royal Butterfly socks
Living Royal Butterfly socks

Living Royal Butterfly socks

$12.99

MudPie Bunny Make-Up Palette - Blush

MudPie Bunny Make-Up Palette - Blush

$9.00

iScream Soft Pink Ruffled Skort

iScream Soft Pink Ruffled Skort

$25.00

3 sizes
  • XS
  • S (6/8)
  • M (10/12)
Can You Tickle A Tiger

Can You Tickle A Tiger

$14.95

Assorted Easter Bunny Pens

Assorted Easter Bunny Pens

$5.95

Bukowski Ziggy Gray Winter Rabbit Plush

Bukowski Ziggy Gray Winter Rabbit Plush

$20.00

Kickee Girl's Underwear - Cake Pop Gingham

Kickee Girl's Underwear - Cake Pop Gingham

$15.95

3 sizes
  • 2T/3T
  • 3T/4T
  • XS (5/6)
Kickee Girl's Underwear - Cake Pop with Tulip

Kickee Girl's Underwear - Cake Pop with Tulip

$15.95

3 sizes
  • 2T/3T
  • 3T/4T
  • XS (5/6)
Wee Ones Medium Jewel Satin with Grosgrain Overlay Hair Bow
Wee Ones Medium Jewel Satin with Grosgrain Overlay Hair Bow

Wee Ones Medium Jewel Satin with Grosgrain Overlay Hair Bow

$14.00

3 colors
  • Antique White
  • Light Pink
  • Shocking Pink
Sticker by Number Too Cute

Sticker by Number Too Cute

$9.99

Great Pretenders 30 Pairs Paw-some Sticker Earrings

Great Pretenders 30 Pairs Paw-some Sticker Earrings

$9.95

Hot Focus Kawaii Beauty - Critters

Hot Focus Kawaii Beauty - Critters

$18.99

Mommy's Rainbow Love Board Book
Mommy's Rainbow Love Board Book

Mommy's Rainbow Love Board Book

$7.99

Ballerina Boutique Hair Scrunchie
Ballerina Boutique Hair Scrunchie

Ballerina Boutique Hair Scrunchie

$6.99

2 colors
  • Pink
Crocodile Creek 50pc House Puzzle/Bunny House
Crocodile Creek 50pc House Puzzle/Bunny House

Crocodile Creek 50pc House Puzzle/Bunny House

$18.99

Oink! Pairs
Oink! Pairs

Oink! Pairs

$16.99

Where's My Bottom?
Where's My Bottom?

Where's My Bottom?

$16.99

Eeboo Assorted Small Valentine's Sketchbooks

Eeboo Assorted Small Valentine's Sketchbooks

$4.95

Ooly Vivid Pop Water Based Paint Metallic Markers-Set of 8
Ooly Vivid Pop Water Based Paint Metallic Markers-Set of 8

Ooly Vivid Pop Water Based Paint Metallic Markers-Set of 8

$17.95

Flower Princess Face Art

Flower Princess Face Art

$14.99

Douglas Plush Valentine Teddy Bear with Heart

Douglas Plush Valentine Teddy Bear with Heart

$24.00

Dinosaur Water Bead Squishies

Dinosaur Water Bead Squishies

$6.95

Kids Pink Graffiti Nutcracker Silky Bow

Kids Pink Graffiti Nutcracker Silky Bow

$18.00

Lucky Carpenter Christmas Wrapping Paper - Vintage Santa Blue

Lucky Carpenter Christmas Wrapping Paper - Vintage Santa Blue

$22.00

Fool’s Gold

$5.00

Big Splash Water Squirt Toy

Big Splash Water Squirt Toy

$3.50

TOY TOWER Light Up Digit Ball

TOY TOWER Light Up Digit Ball

$6.95

3 pk Teleties- Santa Paws

3 pk Teleties- Santa Paws

$9.99

Replica Furry Raccoon Skin Cap with Tail

Replica Furry Raccoon Skin Cap with Tail

$18.99

3 sizes
  • small
  • medium
  • large
Great Pretenders Boutique Chic Butterfly Bow Headband
Great Pretenders Boutique Chic Butterfly Bow Headband

Great Pretenders Boutique Chic Butterfly Bow Headband

$14.99

Clawsome Treasure Diver

Clawsome Treasure Diver

$24.99

ZhuZhu Aquarium Submarine and Dock Set
ZhuZhu Aquarium Submarine and Dock Set

ZhuZhu Aquarium Submarine and Dock Set

$19.99

King Glitter Overlay White Bow

King Glitter Overlay White Bow

$22.00

Transformers Classic Class - Scourge 03 - Rise of the Beasts
Transformers Classic Class - Scourge 03 - Rise of the Beasts

Transformers Classic Class - Scourge 03 - Rise of the Beasts

$19.99

Great Pretenders Boutique Chic 2pk Cute & Classy Clip On Earrings

Great Pretenders Boutique Chic 2pk Cute & Classy Clip On Earrings

$8.95

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.