🎁 Need help finding a gift they'll love? That's our specialty.

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

A Little Joy Just For You!

Join the Olly-Olly crew! Cute outfits, fun toys, and zero overwhelm — delivered straight to your inbox.

By completing this form, you are signing up to receive our emails and can unsubscribe at any time

Gifts Under $25

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.

4826 Results

Clear filters
Legler Wooden Starfish Sailboat
Legler Wooden Starfish Sailboat

Legler Wooden Starfish Sailboat

$24.95

Silver Cylinder Gyroscope
Silver Cylinder Gyroscope

Silver Cylinder Gyroscope

$15.00

Keycraft: Pocket Telescope/Microscope

Keycraft: Pocket Telescope/Microscope

$12.95

Hape Wooden Bunny Stacker
Hape Wooden Bunny Stacker

Hape Wooden Bunny Stacker

$24.95

Twee Gemstones Handmade Sidewalk Chalk
Twee Gemstones Handmade Sidewalk Chalk

Twee Gemstones Handmade Sidewalk Chalk

$24.00

Tonies - Creative Pirate

Tonies - Creative Pirate

$22.00

Tonies - National Geographic Penguin

Tonies - National Geographic Penguin

$22.00

IScream Happy Face String Lights
IScream Happy Face String Lights

IScream Happy Face String Lights

$19.95

St Patty's Day Fascinator Headband

St Patty's Day Fascinator Headband

$14.99

Countdown to Easter

Countdown to Easter

$12.99

Palm Pals - Perky Pinneapple
Palm Pals - Perky Pinneapple

Palm Pals - Perky Pinneapple

$10.99

Well Kept Screen Cleansing Wipes - Better Days Canister

Well Kept Screen Cleansing Wipes - Better Days Canister

$18.95

Little Farm Wind Up and Go Playset
Little Farm Wind Up and Go Playset

Little Farm Wind Up and Go Playset

$22.95

Tonies - Creative Pink Superhero

Tonies - Creative Pink Superhero

$22.00

Lilliput Little Things Earrings - Gingerbread Man

Lilliput Little Things Earrings - Gingerbread Man

$12.00

Unicorn Mug w/ Pom Pom Socks Gift Set
Unicorn Mug w/ Pom Pom Socks Gift Set

Unicorn Mug w/ Pom Pom Socks Gift Set

$22.95

The Twelve Cats of Christmas

The Twelve Cats of Christmas

$15.99

Velvet & Fur Ornament Scrunchie Set
Velvet & Fur Ornament Scrunchie Set

Velvet & Fur Ornament Scrunchie Set

$12.95

Iscream Cookie Sheet Cosmetic Bag
Iscream Cookie Sheet Cosmetic Bag

Iscream Cookie Sheet Cosmetic Bag

$24.95

Christmas Tree Lip Balm
Christmas Tree Lip Balm

Christmas Tree Lip Balm

$8.95

TOY TOWER Sand Animal Reptiles

TOY TOWER Sand Animal Reptiles

$6.95

Great Pretenders Pretty Pastel Bracelet Sets
Great Pretenders Pretty Pastel Bracelet Sets

Great Pretenders Pretty Pastel Bracelet Sets

$10.95

2 colors
Great Pretenders Snowflake Necklace & Ring Set
Great Pretenders Snowflake Necklace & Ring Set

Great Pretenders Snowflake Necklace & Ring Set

$12.95

Holly Jolly 12 Days of Christmas Advent Calendar
Holly Jolly 12 Days of Christmas Advent Calendar

Holly Jolly 12 Days of Christmas Advent Calendar

$25.00

Li'l Cha Cha Maracas
Li'l Cha Cha Maracas

Li'l Cha Cha Maracas

$4.95

4 colors
  • Pink
  • Purple
  • Blue
  • +1 more
Kullerbu Yellow Taxi Cab
Kullerbu Yellow Taxi Cab

Kullerbu Yellow Taxi Cab

$18.95

Great Pretenders Witch Necklace with Black Cat Ring
Great Pretenders Witch Necklace with Black Cat Ring

Great Pretenders Witch Necklace with Black Cat Ring

$9.99

Great Pretenders Bat Necklace with Pumpkin Ring

Great Pretenders Bat Necklace with Pumpkin Ring

$9.99

Tonies Disney - Blues Clues and You
Tonies Disney - Blues Clues and You

Tonies Disney - Blues Clues and You

$22.00

Mudpie Everyday Assorted 2pk Hair Clips
Mudpie Everyday Assorted 2pk Hair Clips

Mudpie Everyday Assorted 2pk Hair Clips

$9.95

6 sizes
  • Ballet
  • Castle & Rainbow
  • Sweets
  • Unicorn
  • Cat
  • Dog
Pretty Perfect Kitty-Corn

Pretty Perfect Kitty-Corn

$18.99

Zoo Day - A My First Experience Book

Zoo Day - A My First Experience Book

$17.99

Iamasaurus

Iamasaurus

$15.99

Make Your Own Fairy Tale: Hansel & Gretel
Make Your Own Fairy Tale: Hansel & Gretel

Make Your Own Fairy Tale: Hansel & Gretel

$16.99

Cupcakes & Cartwheels 5Pc Llama Bracelet Set
Cupcakes & Cartwheels 5Pc Llama Bracelet Set

Cupcakes & Cartwheels 5Pc Llama Bracelet Set

$14.95

The Greatest Fairy Tales

The Greatest Fairy Tales

$19.95

Lobbie Learns... It Helps to be Different
Lobbie Learns... It Helps to be Different

Lobbie Learns... It Helps to be Different

$16.95

Angelina's Baby Sister

Angelina's Baby Sister

$17.99

Silent Night - The Wonderful Story of the Beloved Christmas Carol

Silent Night - The Wonderful Story of the Beloved Christmas Carol

$18.95

Collapsible Beach Bucket Set
Collapsible Beach Bucket Set

Collapsible Beach Bucket Set

$18.95

2 colors
  • Blue
  • Orange
Douglas Plush Gavin Doll - Galaxy

Douglas Plush Gavin Doll - Galaxy

$25.00

Green Toys Twist Teether
Green Toys Twist Teether

Green Toys Twist Teether

$16.95

Lola Dutch - When I Grow Up

Lola Dutch - When I Grow Up

$17.99

5 More Sleeps Til Christmas

5 More Sleeps Til Christmas

$18.99

The Great Santa Stakeout

The Great Santa Stakeout

$17.99

The Night Before Christmas - with Christmas Decoration

The Night Before Christmas - with Christmas Decoration

$17.95

Santa's Secret Hard Cover Book

Santa's Secret Hard Cover Book

$16.99

Get it Together Pencil Pouch - Strawberry Field

Get it Together Pencil Pouch - Strawberry Field

$16.95

Strawberry Cake Glitter Journal

Strawberry Cake Glitter Journal

$14.95

Kedzie Best Little Bag
Kedzie Best Little Bag

Kedzie Best Little Bag

$24.95

4 colors
  • Black
  • Emerald
  • Chestnut
  • +1 more

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.