🎁 Need help finding a gift they'll love? That's our specialty.

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

A Little Joy Just For You!

Join the Olly-Olly crew! Cute outfits, fun toys, and zero overwhelm — delivered straight to your inbox.

By completing this form, you are signing up to receive our emails and can unsubscribe at any time

Gifts Under $25

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.

4826 Results

Clear filters
Silhouette Mia's Journey Puzzle
Silhouette Mia's Journey Puzzle

Silhouette Mia's Journey Puzzle

$25.00

Baby Club Chic River Crocs Burp Cloth Set

Baby Club Chic River Crocs Burp Cloth Set

$25.00

Janod Easel Paper Roll

Janod Easel Paper Roll

$8.99

Knitted 5" Basketball

Knitted 5" Basketball

$24.99

Lemon Lavender In the Clear Make-up Remover Rounds

Lemon Lavender In the Clear Make-up Remover Rounds

$12.00

Crush Lost Without You Jewelry Keychain

Crush Lost Without You Jewelry Keychain

$18.99

4 colors
  • Gold
  • Pink
  • +1 more
Baby's First Easter

Baby's First Easter

$9.99

Bath Time Bucket- Pour 'n Splash

Bath Time Bucket- Pour 'n Splash

$19.99

Floss & Rock Fashion Friends Hairbrush
Floss & Rock Fashion Friends Hairbrush

Floss & Rock Fashion Friends Hairbrush

$14.99

3 colors
  • Pink
  • Hot Pink
  • Lavender
Sunshine & Glitter Highlighter Shimmer Spray Oil - Sunkissed TESTER

Sunshine & Glitter Highlighter Shimmer Spray Oil - Sunkissed TESTER

$15.00

Rainbow Brite 5.5" Fashion Doll

Rainbow Brite 5.5" Fashion Doll

$12.99

Tinyly Miss Lilypink Paperdoll Stickers
Tinyly Miss Lilypink Paperdoll Stickers

Tinyly Miss Lilypink Paperdoll Stickers

$12.99

Tinyly Hortense & Fly Mini Doll Set

Tinyly Hortense & Fly Mini Doll Set

$20.00

Tinyly Neige & Nours Mini Doll Set

Tinyly Neige & Nours Mini Doll Set

$20.00

Tinyly Poppy & Nouky Mini Doll Set
Tinyly Poppy & Nouky Mini Doll Set

Tinyly Poppy & Nouky Mini Doll Set

$20.00

Tinyly Prunelle & Blanca Mini Doll Set

Tinyly Prunelle & Blanca Mini Doll Set

$20.00

Douglas Barb Bunny Muzzle

Douglas Barb Bunny Muzzle

$16.99

Douglas Emily Leaf Sheep

Douglas Emily Leaf Sheep

$22.99

GP Boutique Daisy Delight Necklace & Bracelet Set 2pc

GP Boutique Daisy Delight Necklace & Bracelet Set 2pc

$12.99

GP Boutique Boho Butterfly Necklace

GP Boutique Boho Butterfly Necklace

$10.99

Lock Journal Unicorn Blooms

Lock Journal Unicorn Blooms

$16.99

Kid Galaxy Bubble Graffiti Blaster- Blue

Kid Galaxy Bubble Graffiti Blaster- Blue

$16.99

Somewhere Over the Rainbow Rhinestone Necklace

Somewhere Over the Rainbow Rhinestone Necklace

$12.95

Great Pretenders Boutique Chic You've Got Mail Letter Locket

Great Pretenders Boutique Chic You've Got Mail Letter Locket

$16.99

Great Pretenders Bedazzled Bunny Ears Headband

Great Pretenders Bedazzled Bunny Ears Headband

$12.99

3 colors
  • Lavender
Hot Focus Glow Mask Friends - Glow Mode

Hot Focus Glow Mask Friends - Glow Mode

$24.99

Paddle Ball Game Unit Cartwheels and Cupcakes

Paddle Ball Game Unit Cartwheels and Cupcakes

$14.99

Bug Hugs - Square Bandages Cartwheels and Cupcakes

Bug Hugs - Square Bandages Cartwheels and Cupcakes

$9.99

Sweet & Magical Beauty - Happy Bunny w/ Mystery Gift

Sweet & Magical Beauty - Happy Bunny w/ Mystery Gift

$14.99

Zigolos Stacking Sheep

Zigolos Stacking Sheep

$25.00

Tiger Tribe Shape Shaker

Tiger Tribe Shape Shaker

$12.99

Very Marie Bead Tube - Perfect Peach

Very Marie Bead Tube - Perfect Peach

$22.99

Dress & Color Me- Big Elves

Dress & Color Me- Big Elves

$14.99

Panorama Sticker Book- Mermaids

Panorama Sticker Book- Mermaids

$14.99

Bari Lynn Makeup Brushes in Pouch - Color Block

Bari Lynn Makeup Brushes in Pouch - Color Block

$22.99

iScream Ribbed Racerback Tank Top - Glam Green

iScream Ribbed Racerback Tank Top - Glam Green

$24.00

2 sizes
  • Small/Medium (7-10)
  • Medium/Large (10-14)
Cubika Wooden Lacing Toy Flying Cars
Cubika Wooden Lacing Toy Flying Cars

Cubika Wooden Lacing Toy Flying Cars

$15.00

Pick A Perfect Egg - 12 inch

Pick A Perfect Egg - 12 inch

$17.99

Plan Toys Baby Car - Classic
Plan Toys Baby Car - Classic

Plan Toys Baby Car - Classic

$24.99

Plan Toys Beads Rattle - High Contrast
Plan Toys Beads Rattle - High Contrast

Plan Toys Beads Rattle - High Contrast

$22.99

Crocodile Creek Calk Gumball Machine

Crocodile Creek Calk Gumball Machine

$22.99

Beep! Dominoes
Beep! Dominoes

Beep! Dominoes

$16.99

My First Calculator Fun Book

My First Calculator Fun Book

$10.99

Pink Poppy Claris the Chicest Mouse in Paris Nail Gift Set
Pink Poppy Claris the Chicest Mouse in Paris Nail Gift Set

Pink Poppy Claris the Chicest Mouse in Paris Nail Gift Set

$22.99

Mini Mardi Gras Marching Boot Custom Claw Clip

Mini Mardi Gras Marching Boot Custom Claw Clip

$14.99

Toy Tower Fidget Bracelet

$3.00

Estella Bartlett Gold-Plated Earrings - Gold Hearts

$25.00

Estella Bartlett Gold-Plated Earrings - Heart Arrow

$25.00

Estella Bartlett Gold-Plated Earrings - Lockett

$25.00

Jane Marie Mardi Gras Earrings- 3 Pc

$21.95

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.