🎁 Need help finding a gift they'll love? That's our specialty.

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

A Little Joy Just For You!

Join the Olly-Olly crew! Cute outfits, fun toys, and zero overwhelm — delivered straight to your inbox.

By completing this form, you are signing up to receive our emails and can unsubscribe at any time

Gifts Under $25

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.

4826 Results

Clear filters
Snifty Geo Sticks- Neon

Snifty Geo Sticks- Neon

$16.99

Wee Ones Medium Mirror Dot Grosgrain Overlay Bow
Wee Ones Medium Mirror Dot Grosgrain Overlay Bow

Wee Ones Medium Mirror Dot Grosgrain Overlay Bow

$17.50

4 colors
  • Light blue
  • +1 more
Tiger Tribe Color by Numbers Set - Unicorn Dreaming
Tiger Tribe Color by Numbers Set - Unicorn Dreaming

Tiger Tribe Color by Numbers Set - Unicorn Dreaming

$20.00

Tiger Tribe Coloring Set - Zoo
Tiger Tribe Coloring Set - Zoo

Tiger Tribe Coloring Set - Zoo

$20.00

Surprise Shoe Charms For Shoelaces

Surprise Shoe Charms For Shoelaces

$7.99

Tiger Tribe Scented Coloring Set - Fruity Cutie
Tiger Tribe Scented Coloring Set - Fruity Cutie

Tiger Tribe Scented Coloring Set - Fruity Cutie

$22.99

Smillow in Tote Bag
Smillow in Tote Bag

Smillow in Tote Bag

$25.00

Real Planet T-Rex Hand Puppet 12"
Real Planet T-Rex Hand Puppet 12"

Real Planet T-Rex Hand Puppet 12"

$21.95

2 colors
  • Green
  • Teal
Dope Slimes Boba Slime Trio
Dope Slimes Boba Slime Trio, additional view

Dope Slimes Boba Slime Trio

$24.99

Memory Match Game - Wild Animals
Memory Match Game - Wild Animals

Memory Match Game - Wild Animals

$16.99

Super Mario Checkers & Tic Tac Toe - Bowser
Super Mario Checkers & Tic Tac Toe - Bowser

Super Mario Checkers & Tic Tac Toe - Bowser

$24.99

iScream Sour Patch Kids Charmed Journal
iScream Sour Patch Kids Charmed Journal

iScream Sour Patch Kids Charmed Journal

$18.99

Magnolia Baby Little Sister Pink Embroidered Socks

Magnolia Baby Little Sister Pink Embroidered Socks

$12.99

1 size
  • NB
Bath Buddies Light Up Fish

Bath Buddies Light Up Fish

$6.95

4 colors
  • Orange
  • Black
  • Light blue
  • +1 more
Mudpie Toddler Cat Eye Sunglasses & Neoprene Neck Strap
Mudpie Toddler Cat Eye Sunglasses & Neoprene Neck Strap

Mudpie Toddler Cat Eye Sunglasses & Neoprene Neck Strap

$16.95

2 colors
  • Pink
  • Purple
Large Satin Long Bow- Rainbows by paulette
Large Satin Long Bow- Rainbows by paulette

Large Satin Long Bow- Rainbows by paulette

$16.99

3 colors
  • Cream
Kickee Girl's Underwear - Latte Butterflies

Kickee Girl's Underwear - Latte Butterflies

$15.95

3 sizes
  • 2T/3T
  • 3T/4T
  • XS (5/6)
Azarhia Knotted Headband - Leopard Chic
Azarhia Knotted Headband - Leopard Chic

Azarhia Knotted Headband - Leopard Chic

$16.95

Jane Marie Easter 3Pk Earring Set
Jane Marie Easter 3Pk Earring Set

Jane Marie Easter 3Pk Earring Set

$24.95

Creativity for Kids Sensory Pack - Axolotl
Creativity for Kids Sensory Pack - Axolotl

Creativity for Kids Sensory Pack - Axolotl

$14.99

Eat Your Words Card Game
Eat Your Words Card Game

Eat Your Words Card Game

$22.00

Zip String Psycho String Pack
Zip String Psycho String Pack

Zip String Psycho String Pack

$10.99

Where is Claris at Easter: A Look and Find Book
Where is Claris at Easter: A Look and Find Book

Where is Claris at Easter: A Look and Find Book

$14.99

Gold Cross Stud Earrings
Gold Cross Stud Earrings

Gold Cross Stud Earrings

from $22.00

2 sizes
  • Small
  • Medium
Azarhia Knotted Headband - Starburst

Azarhia Knotted Headband - Starburst

$16.95

The Crowns Birth Stone Charms
The Crowns Birth Stone Charms

The Crowns Birth Stone Charms

$12.00

Martinelia Let's Be Mermaids Nail Design Kit
Martinelia Let's Be Mermaids Nail Design Kit

Martinelia Let's Be Mermaids Nail Design Kit

$18.99

The Rachel - Crystal 2Pc Chunky Jewelry Set
The Rachel - Crystal 2Pc Chunky Jewelry Set

The Rachel - Crystal 2Pc Chunky Jewelry Set

$19.99

Mud Pie Construction Art Folio

Mud Pie Construction Art Folio

$25.00

Ooly Jelly Gloss Neon Multi Surface Deco. Gel Pens (Set of 6)

Ooly Jelly Gloss Neon Multi Surface Deco. Gel Pens (Set of 6)

$18.99

Starlight Projector Space
Starlight Projector Space

Starlight Projector Space

$14.99

Set of 12 Color Remix Layering Markers

Set of 12 Color Remix Layering Markers

$19.99

Blokees Figures – Transformers Defender Version 01 Mini Model Blind Box
Blokees Figures – Transformers Defender Version 01 Mini Model Blind Box

Blokees Figures – Transformers Defender Version 01 Mini Model Blind Box

$4.00

Build Your Straw - Spelly Straw
Build Your Straw - Spelly Straw

Build Your Straw - Spelly Straw

$16.95

Sunshine & Glitter Body Brush

Sunshine & Glitter Body Brush

$18.00

Where Is Little Tiger?: The lift-the-flap book with a pop-up ending!
Where Is Little Tiger?: The lift-the-flap book with a pop-up ending!

Where Is Little Tiger?: The lift-the-flap book with a pop-up ending!

$8.99

Azarhia Mardi Gras Jeweled Smiley Face Headband

Azarhia Mardi Gras Jeweled Smiley Face Headband

$19.95

Lucky Carpenter Christmas Wrapping Paper - Vintage Santa Pink

Lucky Carpenter Christmas Wrapping Paper - Vintage Santa Pink

$22.00

Toy Tower Pocket Magic Tricks (Assorted)

Toy Tower Pocket Magic Tricks (Assorted)

$6.95

Creamie Girls Leggings - Blue and Pink
Creamie Girls Leggings - Blue and Pink

Creamie Girls Leggings - Blue and Pink

$24.99

2 colors, 7 sizes
  • Blue
  • Pink
  • 12M
  • 18M
  • 2Y
  • 3Y
  • 4Y
  • 5
  • 6
Christmas Tree Claw Clip
Christmas Tree Claw Clip

Christmas Tree Claw Clip

$14.00

Hape Toddler Fruit Basket

Hape Toddler Fruit Basket

$24.99

King Glitter Overlay Light Gold Bow

King Glitter Overlay Light Gold Bow

$22.00

King Metallic Gold Dupioni Bow

King Metallic Gold Dupioni Bow

$22.00

Happy BirthTAY Card

Happy BirthTAY Card

$6.00

Great Pretenders 3Pk Boutique Chic Royal Crown Studded Earrings

Great Pretenders 3Pk Boutique Chic Royal Crown Studded Earrings

$9.95

Great Pretenders Boutique Chic Chunky Gem Headband

Great Pretenders Boutique Chic Chunky Gem Headband

$16.95

Great Pretenders Boutique Chic Rhinestone Heart Headband

Great Pretenders Boutique Chic Rhinestone Heart Headband

$12.95

Tutti Frutti Burgers Trio Kit

Tutti Frutti Burgers Trio Kit

$19.99

Great Pretenders Boutique Chic 2Pc Dreams of Love Spinner Ring Set

Great Pretenders Boutique Chic 2Pc Dreams of Love Spinner Ring Set

$9.95

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.