🎁 Need help finding a gift they'll love? That's our specialty.

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

A Little Joy Just For You!

Join the Olly-Olly crew! Cute outfits, fun toys, and zero overwhelm — delivered straight to your inbox.

By completing this form, you are signing up to receive our emails and can unsubscribe at any time

Gifts Under $25

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.

4826 Results

Clear filters
Bumpas Infinity Flipper
Bumpas Infinity Flipper

Bumpas Infinity Flipper

$12.95

Original Koosh Classic 3" Ball

Original Koosh Classic 3" Ball

$9.95

The Elf on the Shelf® and Elf Pets® Minis (Series 4)
The Elf on the Shelf® and Elf Pets® Minis (Series 4)

The Elf on the Shelf® and Elf Pets® Minis (Series 4)

$8.00

Mad Libs - Diva Girl

Mad Libs - Diva Girl

$6.99

Douglas Biscuit Cavapoo Plush Puppy
Douglas Biscuit Cavapoo Plush Puppy

Douglas Biscuit Cavapoo Plush Puppy

$16.95

Palm Pals - Dot Wreath
Palm Pals - Dot Wreath

Palm Pals - Dot Wreath

$10.99

Floating Color Motion Drops
Floating Color Motion Drops

Floating Color Motion Drops

$16.95

3 colors
  • Pink
  • Blue
  • Purple
Lunch Notes: Being Yourself
Lunch Notes: Being Yourself

Lunch Notes: Being Yourself

$9.95

Great Pretenders Pink Princess Tiara

Great Pretenders Pink Princess Tiara

$14.99

Great Pretenders Captain Skully Pirate Sword
Great Pretenders Captain Skully Pirate Sword

Great Pretenders Captain Skully Pirate Sword

$19.99

Assorted Mini Playing Card Games

Assorted Mini Playing Card Games

$3.95

Little Bunny

Little Bunny

$8.99

Mini Telescope: 5x30 Magnification

Mini Telescope: 5x30 Magnification

$12.95

Scratch & Sniff Fart Book

Scratch & Sniff Fart Book

$9.99

Some Bunny Loves Me MIFFY Lip Gloss
Some Bunny Loves Me MIFFY Lip Gloss

Some Bunny Loves Me MIFFY Lip Gloss

$7.95

Lots of Love Nail Polish & Ring Set

Lots of Love Nail Polish & Ring Set

$12.95

Maison NOLA Silicone Mardi Gras Crown Teether

Maison NOLA Silicone Mardi Gras Crown Teether

$20.00

Stephen Joseph Dino Umbrella

Stephen Joseph Dino Umbrella

$18.00

Heart to Heart Stacking Crayons
Heart to Heart Stacking Crayons

Heart to Heart Stacking Crayons

$6.95

Acrylic Hair Clips - Nutcrackers

Acrylic Hair Clips - Nutcrackers

$24.00

Survival Compass
Survival Compass

Survival Compass

$7.95

3 colors
  • Red
  • Blue
12" Glitter Water Baton
12" Glitter Water Baton

12" Glitter Water Baton

$6.95

3 colors
  • Purple
  • Pink
  • Blue
TOY TOWER Tiger Hand Puppet

TOY TOWER Tiger Hand Puppet

$9.95

Great Pretenders Pink Beauty Princess Tiara

Great Pretenders Pink Beauty Princess Tiara

$14.99

TOY TOWER Stretch Dinosaur
TOY TOWER Stretch Dinosaur

TOY TOWER Stretch Dinosaur

$7.95

Little Blue Truck's Christmas with Twinkle Lights

Little Blue Truck's Christmas with Twinkle Lights

$18.99

Comet Teether
Comet Teether

Comet Teether

$24.95

Good Night Christmas - Board Book

Good Night Christmas - Board Book

$9.95

How Many Sleeps Til Christmas Board Book

How Many Sleeps Til Christmas Board Book

$8.95

Jefferies Socks Smooth Toe Pom Pom Low Cut Socks

Jefferies Socks Smooth Toe Pom Pom Low Cut Socks

$6.95

4 sizes
  • TODDLER (3-7)
  • X-SMALL (6-11)
  • SMALL (9-1)
  • MEDiUM (12-6)
Starlux Bath Buddy
Starlux Bath Buddy

Starlux Bath Buddy

$12.95

Garb2Art Bath Bubbly Salts

Garb2Art Bath Bubbly Salts

$14.95

2 colors
Christina Debut Shorts
Christina Debut Shorts

Christina Debut Shorts

$21.95

6 sizes
  • XXS
  • XS
  • SM
  • MD
  • LG
  • XL
Hatch 'Ems Dinosaur Egg

Hatch 'Ems Dinosaur Egg

$6.95

Bebe the Bunny Board Book

Bebe the Bunny Board Book

$17.00

Waboba Wingman 6" Silicone Disc (Assorted)
Waboba Wingman 6" Silicone Disc (Assorted)

Waboba Wingman 6" Silicone Disc (Assorted)

$8.95

Great Pretenders 30 Pairs Heart Sticker Earrings

Great Pretenders 30 Pairs Heart Sticker Earrings

$9.95

Good Night Fire Engines Board Book

Good Night Fire Engines Board Book

$9.95

Green Toys Watering Can with Spout

Green Toys Watering Can with Spout

$18.00

Charlotte Dance Leotard
Charlotte Dance Leotard

Charlotte Dance Leotard

$22.95

2 colors, 4 sizes
  • Black
  • Pink
  • XXS
  • XS
  • SM
  • MD
Maison NOLA Silicone Po'Boy Teether
Maison NOLA Silicone Po'Boy Teether

Maison NOLA Silicone Po'Boy Teether

$20.00

Pink Poppy Unicorn Letters & Charm Bracelet

Pink Poppy Unicorn Letters & Charm Bracelet

$8.95

32 Pair Girl Nation Cutie Stick-On Earrings: Sweets & Treats
32 Pair Girl Nation Cutie Stick-On Earrings: Sweets & Treats

32 Pair Girl Nation Cutie Stick-On Earrings: Sweets & Treats

$8.00

Mudpuppy 100pc Glow in the Dark Puzzle - Moonlight Ballet
Mudpuppy 100pc Glow in the Dark Puzzle - Moonlight Ballet

Mudpuppy 100pc Glow in the Dark Puzzle - Moonlight Ballet

$16.99

Bud Silly Buddy Blue Bunny Paci Clip
Bud Silly Buddy Blue Bunny Paci Clip

Bud Silly Buddy Blue Bunny Paci Clip

$22.99

Squishy Pink Pumpkin Toy
Squishy Pink Pumpkin Toy

Squishy Pink Pumpkin Toy

$8.99

Golden Girls Squeeze toy

Golden Girls Squeeze toy

$9.99

iScream Pearl Fidget Squeeze Toy

iScream Pearl Fidget Squeeze Toy

$9.99

Hot Focus Pop Nail Glitz Glow Mode nail kit

Hot Focus Pop Nail Glitz - Glow Mode

$10.99

Mushykins Holiday 2 Pack
Mushykins Holiday 2 Pack

Mushykins Holiday 2 Pack

$9.99

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.