🎁 Need help finding a gift they'll love? That's our specialty.

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

A Little Joy Just For You!

Join the Olly-Olly crew! Cute outfits, fun toys, and zero overwhelm — delivered straight to your inbox.

By completing this form, you are signing up to receive our emails and can unsubscribe at any time

Gifts Under $25

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.

4826 Results

Clear filters
2-Tone Gummiez pig squishy

2-Tone Gummiez Pig Squishy

$8.99

IScream Unicorn Kisses Squeeze Toy
IScream Unicorn Kisses Squeeze Toy

IScream Unicorn Kisses Squeeze Toy

$8.99

Suzette High Neck Ribbed Seamless Tanktop
Suzette High Neck Ribbed Seamless Tanktop

Suzette High Neck Ribbed Seamless Tanktop

$22.00

4 colors, 2 sizes
  • Aqua
  • Lavender
  • +1 more
  • S/M
  • M/L
Fluffmellies Bichon Pups - Ultra Slow-Rise Squishy

Fluffmellies Bichon Pups - Ultra Slow-Rise Squishy

$12.99

IScream Mini Haribo Gummy Bear Plush

IScream Mini Haribo Gummy Bear Plush

$14.00

Scurunchems Sugar Unicorn

Scurunchems Sugar Unicorn

$8.99

Scrunchems Sugar Sensory Shapes

Scrunchems Sugar Sensory Shapes

$8.99

Scrunchems Sugar Squishy Bears- 3pk

Scrunchems Sugar Squishy Bears- 3pk

$10.99

Wee Ones Sheer Glitter/Grosgrain Overlay Bow

from $18.00

4 colors, 2 sizes
  • White
  • Pink
  • Lavender
  • +1 more
  • Small
  • King
Beauty in Bloom Makeup Palette

Beauty in Bloom Makeup Palette

$16.00

iScream Blue Floral Journal
iScream Blue Floral Journal

iScream Blue Floral Journal

$16.99

American Jewel Diagonal Pearl Headband

American Jewel Diagonal Pearl Headband

$20.00

2 colors
  • Purple
  • Pink
Color Me Comfy Coloring Book

Color Me Comfy Coloring Book

$6.99

Bodacious Besties Tear and Share Necklace

Bodacious Besties Tear and Share Necklace

$12.99

J'adore Fun Cube Squishy

J'adore Fun Cube Squishy

$12.99

Shaggy Unicorn Squishy

Shaggy Unicorn Squishy

$8.99

Cozy Friends Coloring Book

Cozy Friends Coloring Book

$9.99

Girl Moments Coloring Book

Girl Moments Coloring Book

$9.99

Hot Focus Travel Beauty Bowtiful

Hot Focus Travel Beauty Bowtiful

$24.99

Stainless Steel Water Bottle - Bowtiful

Stainless Steel Water Bottle - Bowtiful

$25.00

Dickie Micro Builder Truck

Dickie Micro Builder Truck

$18.99

Doctor Squish Putty Buddies

Doctor Squish Putty Buddies

$12.99

Omy Freckles Tattoo- Shine Bright
Omy Freckles Tattoo- Shine Bright

Omy Freckles Tattoo- Shine Bright

$12.00

Super-Cute Coloring Pad

Super-Cute Coloring Pad

$5.99

Purple Shimmer Sparkle Pop Bag Charm

Purple Shimmer Sparkle Pop Bag Charm

$16.99

Rose Pink Gloss Boss

Rose Pink Gloss Boss

$16.99

Fairyland Fun XXL Coloring Book
Fairyland Fun XXL Coloring Book

Fairyland Fun XXL Coloring Book

$14.99

Magna-Tiles MicroMags Cubes
Magna-Tiles MicroMags Cubes

Magna-Tiles MicroMags Cubes

$25.00

USA Hacky Sack

USA Hacky Sack

$9.99

Reigning Beauty Gold High Heels (One Size)
Reigning Beauty Gold High Heels (One Size)

Reigning Beauty Gold High Heels (One Size)

$25.00

7 in 1 Fidget Tool
7 in 1 Fidget Tool

7 in 1 Fidget Tool

$8.99

Foosbots Rivals International Assortment
Foosbots Rivals International Assortment

Foosbots Rivals International Assortment

$14.99

Play Tab Modular Activity Board Tiles- Sensory Set 6

Play Tab Modular Activity Board Tiles- Sensory Set 6

$24.99

Sticker Dolly Dressing Movie Star

Sticker Dolly Dressing Movie Star

$9.99

Mermazing Mermaid Braid Headband

Mermazing Mermaid Braid Headband

$24.99

Farm Fresh Barnyard Squishy Cat
Farm Fresh Barnyard Squishy Cat

Farm Fresh Barnyard Squishy Cat

$8.99

Retch Slime Puking Monsters

Retch Slime Puking Monsters

$8.99

Kaleidoscope Sketchbook - Bright

Kaleidoscope Sketchbook - Bright

$14.99

Spot On Pom Pom Pencils
Spot On Pom Pom Pencils

Spot On Pom Pom Pencils

$4.99

Top Racing Power Sports Car Tube

Top Racing Power Sports Car Tube

$12.99

Blokees Marvel SAGA - Champion - Iron Man

Blokees Marvel SAGA - Champion - Iron Man

$25.00

Lemon Lavender Pedi-Cure All Hydrating Foot Mask
Lemon Lavender Pedi-Cure All Hydrating Foot Mask

Lemon Lavender Pedi-Cure All Hydrating Foot Mask

$9.99

8" Cat in Bed Plush
8" Cat in Bed Plush

8" Cat in Bed Plush

$9.99

2 colors
iScream Bright Butterflies Journal

iScream Bright Butterflies Journal

$16.99

NOVA 3-D Coloring Mermaid
NOVA 3-D Coloring Mermaid

NOVA 3-D Coloring Mermaid

$25.00

EGKD Axolotl Mini Play Pack

EGKD Axolotl Mini Play Pack

$12.00

Easter Bunny Tail Bath Bomb

Easter Bunny Tail Bath Bomb

$12.99

Glitter Water Baton (Assorted)

Glitter Water Baton (Assorted)

$4.99

Yummy Gummy Bear Charm Bracelet

Yummy Gummy Bear Charm Bracelet

$6.99

Wee Ones 5pk Tiny Bow Multi Pack

Wee Ones 5pk Tiny Bow Multi Pack

$18.99

2 colors

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.