🎁 Need help finding a gift they'll love? That's our specialty.

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

A Little Joy Just For You!

Join the Olly-Olly crew! Cute outfits, fun toys, and zero overwhelm — delivered straight to your inbox.

By completing this form, you are signing up to receive our emails and can unsubscribe at any time

Gifts Under $25

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.

4845 Results

Clear filters
Azarhia Girls Mardi Gras - Rhinestone Bow Headband

Azarhia Girls Mardi Gras - Rhinestone Bow Headband

$20.00

Pink/Blue Pastel Textured Hair Bows

Pink/Blue Pastel Textured Hair Bows

$20.00

My Beauty Space - Tie Dye Butterfly

My Beauty Space - Tie Dye Butterfly

$22.99

White/Light Pink Christmas Tree Embroidered Bow

$20.00

White/Light Pink Christmas Embroidered Nutcracker Bow

$20.00

Scratch and Sketch - Bugs

Scratch and Sketch - Bugs

$14.99

Spy Labs: Motion Detector Alarm

Spy Labs: Motion Detector Alarm

$25.00

Pen Diffuser - Cotton Candy

Pen Diffuser - Cotton Candy

$12.99

Taylor's Besties Tear & Share Necklaces

Taylor's Besties Tear & Share Necklaces

$12.99

Great Pretenders Smitten Kitten tear and share necklaces

Great Pretenders Smitten Kitten Tear & Share Necklace

$12.99

Giant Marshmallow w/ Holly Confetti & Chocolate
Giant Marshmallow w/ Holly Confetti & Chocolate

Giant Marshmallow w/ Holly Confetti & Chocolate

$6.99

Lovely Little Bukowski Plush Teddy Bear
Lovely Little Bukowski Plush Teddy Bear

Lovely Little Bukowski Plush Teddy Bear

$24.99

Animal Wind Up Toys
Animal Wind Up Toys

Animal Wind Up Toys

$8.99

Unicorn Hot Cocoa Butter Slime

Unicorn Hot Cocoa Butter Slime

$18.00

The Nativity Touchy Feely Board Book

The Nativity Touchy Feely Board Book

$14.99

Medium Metallic Sparkle Lurex with Grosgrain Underlay Hair Bow
Medium Metallic Sparkle Lurex with Grosgrain Underlay Hair Bow

Medium Metallic Sparkle Lurex with Grosgrain Underlay Hair Bow

$16.00

3 colors
  • Pearl (Pink)
  • Lemonade (Gold)
  • Gray (Silver)
Little Golden Book Walt Disney's- Santa's Toy Shop

Little Golden Book Walt Disney's- Santa's Toy Shop

$5.99

Douglas Merrie Mouse With Red Hat & Candy Cane

Douglas Merrie Mouse With Red Hat & Candy Cane

$16.99

Douglas TIM Tan Large Plush Muzzle Dog

Douglas TIM Tan Large Plush Muzzle Dog

$20.99

Ravensburger 35Pc Playful Purr Babies Puzzle
Ravensburger 35Pc Playful Purr Babies Puzzle

Ravensburger 35Pc Playful Purr Babies Puzzle

$18.99

BRIO World Clever Crane Wagon
BRIO World Clever Crane Wagon

BRIO World Clever Crane Wagon

$25.00

Palm Pals - Cliff Travel Cup
Palm Pals - Cliff Travel Cup

Palm Pals - Cliff Travel Cup

$12.99

Fruit Bracelet

Fruit Bracelet

$5.99

Critter Sandimals

Critter Sandimals

$9.99

Jolly Green Shiraleah Fuzzy Socks

Jolly Green Shiraleah Fuzzy Socks

$15.00

Creamie Girls Leggings - Light Pink and Maroon

$24.99

2 colors, 7 sizes
  • Maroon
  • 12M
  • 18M
  • 2Y
  • 3Y
  • 4Y
  • 5
  • 6
Wiggly Jiggly Pens

Wiggly Jiggly Pens

$6.95

Hatley Big Hearts Pink Fuzzy Fleece Slippers
Hatley Big Hearts Pink Fuzzy Fleece Slippers

Hatley Big Hearts Pink Fuzzy Fleece Slippers

$25.00

4 sizes
  • Small (5-7)
  • Medium (8-10)
  • Large (11-13)
  • X-Large (1-2)
Santa Rechargable Flashlight

Santa Rechargable Flashlight

$12.95

Creative Heart Art Set
Creative Heart Art Set

Creative Heart Art Set

$18.99

Peachybbies- Fox Fur Slime

Peachybbies- Fox Fur Slime

$18.99

Shark Pirate Boat
Shark Pirate Boat

Shark Pirate Boat

$18.99

EGKD Pie KidDough Play Kit
EGKD Pie KidDough Play Kit

EGKD Pie KidDough Play Kit

$24.99

Azarhia Girls Knotted Headband - Bright Leopard

Azarhia Girls Knotted Headband - Bright Leopard

$16.95

CHARM IT! Gold & Pink Cowboy Boot Charm

CHARM IT! Gold & Pink Cowboy Boot Charm

$7.00

CHARM IT! Gold Glitter Fairy Charm

CHARM IT! Gold Glitter Fairy Charm

$7.00

CHARM IT! Gold Bicycle Charm
CHARM IT! Gold Bicycle Charm

CHARM IT! Gold Bicycle Charm

$7.00

CHARM IT! Gold Purple Star Stretch Bead Bracelet

CHARM IT! Gold Purple Star Stretch Bead Bracelet

$14.00

CHARM IT! Gold Pastel Multi Heart Stretch Bead Bracelet
CHARM IT! Gold Pastel Multi Heart Stretch Bead Bracelet

CHARM IT! Gold Pastel Multi Heart Stretch Bead Bracelet

$14.00

Bow Applique Basic Bib - Pink

Bow Applique Basic Bib - Pink

$22.00

Tea Collection Solid Purple Leggings
Tea Collection Solid Purple Leggings

Tea Collection Solid Purple Leggings

$24.00

5 sizes
  • 2T
  • 3T
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
Hello Lucky Dino Roar Matching Game

Hello Lucky Dino Roar Matching Game

$18.99

Shark Chasey - Catch A Fish
Shark Chasey - Catch A Fish

Shark Chasey - Catch A Fish

$24.99

Happy Bingo

Happy Bingo

$19.99

Bible Stories with Felt Teeth

Bible Stories with Felt Teeth

$9.99

Never Touch a Dinosaur Pop-Up Book
Never Touch a Dinosaur Pop-Up Book

Never Touch a Dinosaur Pop-Up Book

$14.99

D is for Dump Truck: An ABC of Busy Little Journeys

D is for Dump Truck: An ABC of Busy Little Journeys

$14.99

Bella Tunno Teether Buddy - Freddie the Frog
Bella Tunno Teether Buddy - Freddie the Frog

Bella Tunno Teether Buddy - Freddie the Frog

$22.99

Bella Tunno Teether Buddy - Charlotte the Cat
Bella Tunno Teether Buddy - Charlotte the Cat

Bella Tunno Teether Buddy - Charlotte the Cat

$22.99

10Pc Insect Playset

10Pc Insect Playset

$18.99

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.