🎁 Need help finding a gift they'll love? That's our specialty.

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

A Little Joy Just For You!

Join the Olly-Olly crew! Cute outfits, fun toys, and zero overwhelm — delivered straight to your inbox.

By completing this form, you are signing up to receive our emails and can unsubscribe at any time

Gifts Under $25

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.

4845 Results

Clear filters
Douglas Mini Grey Cat

Douglas Mini Grey Cat

$14.95

On the First Day of First Grade

On the First Day of First Grade

$12.99

Goodnight, Biscuit

Goodnight, Biscuit

$11.99

Goodnight Moon Padded

Goodnight Moon Padded

$11.99

Sticker Dolly Dressing Dolls

Sticker Dolly Dressing Dolls

$9.99

There There Little Puppy

There There Little Puppy

$12.99

Dope Slimes Level Up Slime Trio
Dope Slimes Level Up Slime Trio

Dope Slimes Level Up Slime Trio

$24.99

Dope Slimes - Mint Chip
Dope Slimes - Mint Chip

Dope Slimes - Mint Chip

$18.99

Fingertrail ABC

Fingertrail ABC

$15.99

That's Not My Fire Truck

That's Not My Fire Truck

$10.99

Wildlife Critter Lanterns
Wildlife Critter Lanterns

Wildlife Critter Lanterns

$16.99

Light Up Ricochet Ball

Light Up Ricochet Ball

$12.99

Baby Club Chic Bib - Noah's Ark Blue

Baby Club Chic Bib - Noah's Ark Blue

$14.95

Baby Club Chic Bib - Rosebuds

Baby Club Chic Bib - Rosebuds

$14.95

Baby Club Chic Bib - Welcome Baby Blue

Baby Club Chic Bib - Welcome Baby Blue

$14.95

Sam and Julia Plush Mouse Ella

Sam and Julia Plush Mouse Ella

$19.95

Stress Breaker Hi-Bouncing Stress Ball
Stress Breaker Hi-Bouncing Stress Ball

Stress Breaker Hi-Bouncing Stress Ball

$8.99

Zeke Puppy Playtivity Rattle

Zeke Puppy Playtivity Rattle

$15.99

Azarhia Girls Knotted Headband - Neon Wave

Azarhia Girls Knotted Headband - Neon Wave

$16.95

Traditional Duck Toy Soap

Traditional Duck Toy Soap

$9.99

TRVL Best Bib Blue Pimlico Stripe
TRVL Best Bib Blue Pimlico Stripe

TRVL Best Bib Blue Pimlico Stripe

$22.00

Kickee Boys Boxer Briefs - Lakeside Stripe

Kickee Boys Boxer Briefs - Lakeside Stripe

$15.95

3 sizes
  • 2T-3T
  • 3T-4T
  • XS 5/6
Kickee Girl's Underwear - Shrinking Violet

Kickee Girl's Underwear - Shrinking Violet

$15.95

3 sizes
  • 2T/3T
  • 3T/4T
  • XS (5/6)
Kickee Girl's Underwear - Natural

Kickee Girl's Underwear - Natural

$15.95

3 sizes
  • 2T/3T
  • 3T/4T
  • XS (5/6)
Living Royal Tiger Socks
Living Royal Tiger Socks

Living Royal Tiger Socks

$12.99

Let's Polka Dot Scrunchie Egg Ornament Set

Let's Polka Dot Scrunchie Egg Ornament Set

$14.95

iScream Vivid Violet Ruffled Skort

iScream Vivid Violet Ruffled Skort

$25.00

3 sizes
  • XS
  • S (6/8)
  • M (10/12)
God Is Kind Board Book

God Is Kind Board Book

$9.99

Pink Fluffy Ball Pens

Pink Fluffy Ball Pens

$4.95

Glitter Grosgrain Overlay Bow - Fuchsia

Glitter Grosgrain Overlay Bow - Fuchsia

from $18.00

2 sizes
  • Medium
  • King
Kickee Boys Boxer Briefs - Jade Cows
Kickee Boys Boxer Briefs - Jade Cows

Kickee Boys Boxer Briefs - Jade Cows

$15.95

3 sizes
  • 2T-3T
  • 3T-4T
  • XS 5/6
Kickee Boys Boxer Briefs - Latte Chickens
Kickee Boys Boxer Briefs - Latte Chickens

Kickee Boys Boxer Briefs - Latte Chickens

$15.95

3 sizes
  • 2T-3T
  • 3T-4T
  • XS 5/6
The Night Before Valentine’s Day Book

The Night Before Valentine’s Day Book

$4.99

6Pc Easter Egg Crayon Set

6Pc Easter Egg Crayon Set

$15.00

Noisy Pig Sensory Toy
Noisy Pig Sensory Toy

Noisy Pig Sensory Toy

$7.99

3 colors
  • Pink
  • Snow White
  • Orange
Huggie Hoop Dangle Earrings-Enchanted Unicorn

Huggie Hoop Dangle Earrings-Enchanted Unicorn

$25.00

4/6 Web Weaver Soft Cape with Mask
4/6 Web Weaver Soft Cape with Mask

4/6 Web Weaver Soft Cape with Mask

$22.99

Hot Focus Bowtiful Puffer Crossbody Bag - Bowtiful

Hot Focus Bowtiful Puffer Crossbody Bag - Bowtiful

$22.99

Hot Focus Bowtiful Puffer Crossbody Bag - Good Day

Hot Focus Bowtiful Puffer Crossbody Bag - Good Day

$22.99

Bella Tunno Wonder Mat
Bella Tunno Wonder Mat

Bella Tunno Wonder Mat

$19.99

Games Controller Sensory Maze
Games Controller Sensory Maze

Games Controller Sensory Maze

$7.99

Not A Spot Gunk-Absorbing Hydrocolloid Dots (48)
Not A Spot Gunk-Absorbing Hydrocolloid Dots (48)

Not A Spot Gunk-Absorbing Hydrocolloid Dots (48)

$16.99

Palm Pals - Bouncy Bunny Egg
Palm Pals - Bouncy Bunny Egg

Palm Pals - Bouncy Bunny Egg

$10.99

Dainty Knit Tote - Bow Tie Pink

Dainty Knit Tote - Bow Tie Pink

$18.99

Love Bug Padded Board Book
Love Bug Padded Board Book

Love Bug Padded Board Book

$9.99

Insect Lore Wearable Butterfly Wings
Insect Lore Wearable Butterfly Wings

Insect Lore Wearable Butterfly Wings

$14.99

3 colors
  • Monarch
  • Pink
  • Purple
Serious Lip Balm
Serious Lip Balm

Serious Lip Balm

$10.95

Animal ABC Flashcards
Animal ABC Flashcards

Animal ABC Flashcards

$14.99

Happy Faces Board Book

Happy Faces Board Book

$9.99

Swiftie Friendship Bracelets Birthday Card
Swiftie Friendship Bracelets Birthday Card

Swiftie Friendship Bracelets Birthday Card

$6.00

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.