🎁 Need help finding a gift they'll love? That's our specialty.

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

A Little Joy Just For You!

Join the Olly-Olly crew! Cute outfits, fun toys, and zero overwhelm — delivered straight to your inbox.

By completing this form, you are signing up to receive our emails and can unsubscribe at any time

Gifts Under $25

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.

4826 Results

Clear filters
Which Tail? Spin and Grin! B/B

Which Tail? Spin and Grin! B/B

$9.99

Circle Overture Key Ring
Circle Overture Key Ring

Circle Overture Key Ring

$25.00

2 colors
  • Bronze
  • Black leopard
Azarhia Knotted Headband - Water Color Bows

Azarhia Knotted Headband - Water Color Bows

$16.95

Azarhia Knotted Headband- Botanical Flowers

Azarhia Knotted Headband- Botanical Flowers

$16.95

Conversation Heart Plush

Conversation Heart Plush

$8.99

3 colors
  • Purple
  • Yellow
  • Light blue
Iscream Frosted Cake Mini Plush Character
Iscream Frosted Cake Mini Plush Character

Iscream Frosted Cake Mini Plush Character

$20.00

Wooden Screen Time Tokens

Wooden Screen Time Tokens

$9.95

Mary Square Oh What Fun Tumbler - Pastel Nutcracker
Mary Square Oh What Fun Tumbler - Pastel Nutcracker

Mary Square Oh What Fun Tumbler - Pastel Nutcracker

$24.95

Tutti Frutti 4Pk Sparkling Fruit Scents Play Dough
Tutti Frutti 4Pk Sparkling Fruit Scents Play Dough

Tutti Frutti 4Pk Sparkling Fruit Scents Play Dough

$14.95

Douglas Plush Sushi Cat Food Macaroon
Douglas Plush Sushi Cat Food Macaroon

Douglas Plush Sushi Cat Food Macaroon

$16.95

Grabease Toothbrush Grey

Grabease Toothbrush Grey

$13.95

Lucky Carpenter Christmas Wrapping Paper - Candy Cane Pink

Lucky Carpenter Christmas Wrapping Paper - Candy Cane Pink

$22.00

Shark’s Teeth

$5.00

Jokes On You! Assorted Pranks

Jokes On You! Assorted Pranks

$4.95

The Night Before Christmas Gift Set

The Night Before Christmas Gift Set

$14.95

Little Miss Zoe Ballet Earrings

Little Miss Zoe Ballet Earrings

$20.00

Great Pretenders Float Like a Butterfly Wand

Great Pretenders Float Like a Butterfly Wand

$8.95

ZhuZhu Aquarium Speed Boat and Dock Set
ZhuZhu Aquarium Speed Boat and Dock Set

ZhuZhu Aquarium Speed Boat and Dock Set

$19.99

King Sequin Overlay Navy Bow

$22.00

Transformers Classic Class - Arcee 07 - Rise of the Beasts
Transformers Classic Class - Arcee 07 - Rise of the Beasts

Transformers Classic Class - Arcee 07 - Rise of the Beasts

$19.99

Baby's First Christmas 4X6/5X7 2024 Ceramic Picture Frame

$18.99

Pony Tail Streamers - Pink Breast Cancer Awareness

Pony Tail Streamers - Pink Breast Cancer Awareness

$16.99

Taylor Swift Swiftie Die Cut Sticker
Taylor Swift Swiftie Die Cut Sticker

Taylor Swift Swiftie Die Cut Sticker

$3.99

The Ghouls Night
The Ghouls Night

The Ghouls Night

$12.99

My First How to Catch a Witch

My First How to Catch a Witch

$7.99

Sounds Like Halloween Board Book

Sounds Like Halloween Board Book

$19.99

Great Pretenders Boutique Chic Golden Rainbow Necklace
Great Pretenders Boutique Chic Golden Rainbow Necklace

Great Pretenders Boutique Chic Golden Rainbow Necklace

$10.95

Great Pretenders Boutique Chic Pink Crystal Bracelet

Great Pretenders Boutique Chic Pink Crystal Bracelet

$8.95

Great Pretenders Boutique Chic 2Pc Tickled Pink Ring Set
Great Pretenders Boutique Chic 2Pc Tickled Pink Ring Set

Great Pretenders Boutique Chic 2Pc Tickled Pink Ring Set

$9.95

3 sizes
  • Small
  • Medium
  • Large
Great Pretenders Boutique Chic Diamante Headband
Great Pretenders Boutique Chic Diamante Headband

Great Pretenders Boutique Chic Diamante Headband

$12.95

We're Going on a Sleigh Ride HC

We're Going on a Sleigh Ride HC

$17.99

The Worry Tiger
The Worry Tiger

The Worry Tiger

$18.99

Great Pretenders 3Pk Boutique Chic Snowman Earrings
Great Pretenders 3Pk Boutique Chic Snowman Earrings

Great Pretenders 3Pk Boutique Chic Snowman Earrings

$9.95

Peep & Pop - Tiger, Tiger, What Stripy Fur You Have!

Peep & Pop - Tiger, Tiger, What Stripy Fur You Have!

$8.99

The Cozy Christmas Cookbook: 50 Recipes to Rediscover the Magic of the Season
The Cozy Christmas Cookbook: 50 Recipes to Rediscover the Magic of the Season

The Cozy Christmas Cookbook: 50 Recipes to Rediscover the Magic of the Season

$9.99

Little People Big Dreams - Helen Keller

Little People Big Dreams - Helen Keller

$15.99

Little People Big Dreams - Beyonce

Little People Big Dreams - Beyonce

$15.99

Little Red Hardcover

Little Red Hardcover

$18.99

Mia Sandal -Violette -Cognac
Mia Sandal -Violette -Cognac

Mia Sandal -Violette -Cognac

$24.00

8 sizes
  • 11
  • 12
  • 13
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Kensie Girl Slides- Multi-Color Fuchsia
Kensie Girl Slides- Multi-Color Fuchsia

Kensie Girl Slides- Multi-Color Fuchsia

$22.95

1 color, 16 sizes
  • 2 Child
  • 3 Child
  • 4 Child
  • 5 Child
  • 6 Child
  • 7 Child
  • 8 Child
  • 9 Child
  • 10 Child
  • 11 Youth
  • 12 Youth
  • 13 Youth
  • 1 Youth
  • 2 Youth
  • 3 Youth
  • 4 Youth
Iscream Priscilla Peppermint Screamsicle Mini Plush Character
Iscream Priscilla Peppermint Screamsicle Mini Plush Character

Iscream Priscilla Peppermint Screamsicle Mini Plush Character

$20.00

CHARM IT! Gold Glitter Santa Charm
CHARM IT! Gold Glitter Santa Charm

CHARM IT! Gold Glitter Santa Charm

$6.00

CHARM IT! Gold Glitter Reindeer Charm
CHARM IT! Gold Glitter Reindeer Charm

CHARM IT! Gold Glitter Reindeer Charm

$6.00

Happy Birthday Feeding Bib - Pink

Happy Birthday Feeding Bib - Pink

$24.99

Happy Birthday Feeding Bib - Blue

Happy Birthday Feeding Bib - Blue

$24.99

Great Pretenders Boutique Chic Bubbly Butterfly Necklace
Great Pretenders Boutique Chic Bubbly Butterfly Necklace

Great Pretenders Boutique Chic Bubbly Butterfly Necklace

$10.95

Great Pretenders Boutique Chic Pink Crystal Necklace

Great Pretenders Boutique Chic Pink Crystal Necklace

$10.95

Great Pretenders Boutique Chic Gummy Glam Bracelet
Great Pretenders Boutique Chic Gummy Glam Bracelet

Great Pretenders Boutique Chic Gummy Glam Bracelet

$8.95

Baby Club Chic Watercolor Printed Bib - Little Train Blue

Baby Club Chic Watercolor Printed Bib - Little Train Blue

$14.95

Great Pretenders Boutique Chic 2Pc Sunny Blooms Ring Set

Great Pretenders Boutique Chic 2Pc Sunny Blooms Ring Set

$9.95

3 sizes
  • Small
  • Medium
  • Large

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.