🎁 Need help finding a gift they'll love? That's our specialty.

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

A Little Joy Just For You!

Join the Olly-Olly crew! Cute outfits, fun toys, and zero overwhelm — delivered straight to your inbox.

By completing this form, you are signing up to receive our emails and can unsubscribe at any time

Gifts Under $25

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.

4826 Results

Clear filters
Kaloo The Happy Unicorn Activity Book
Kaloo The Happy Unicorn Activity Book

Kaloo The Happy Unicorn Activity Book

$22.00

Wee Ones Medium Dupioni Bow with Whimsy Tails - Navy

$15.00

Wee Ones Medium Sparkle Glimmer Textured Bow - Green

Wee Ones Medium Sparkle Glimmer Textured Bow - Green

$14.99

Kickee Boys Boxer Briefs - Merry Monsters

Kickee Boys Boxer Briefs - Merry Monsters

$15.95

2 sizes
  • 3T-4T
  • 5/6
Acrylic Headband - Halloween Witch w/ Orange Hair

Acrylic Headband - Halloween Witch w/ Orange Hair

$24.00

Green Terry Cloth Cosmetic Bag - Tennis

Green Terry Cloth Cosmetic Bag - Tennis

$24.99

Count To Sleep Dinosaurs

Count To Sleep Dinosaurs

$9.95

Good Night Astronauts

Good Night Astronauts

$9.95

You're Going to be a... BIG SISTER! Book
You're Going to be a... BIG SISTER! Book

You're Going to be a... BIG SISTER! Book

$12.95

Djeco Toucan Silhouette Puzzle
Djeco Toucan Silhouette Puzzle

Djeco Toucan Silhouette Puzzle

$20.00

NellaPima: White Bubble Burp Cloth w/ Pink Trim
NellaPima: White Bubble Burp Cloth w/ Pink Trim

NellaPima: White Bubble Burp Cloth w/ Pink Trim

$18.95

Baby Loren Pima White w/ White Trim Burp Cloth

Baby Loren Pima White w/ White Trim Burp Cloth

$14.95

Little English Light Pink Signature Stripe Bib

$14.99

Londjii Unicorn Temporary Tattoos
Londjii Unicorn Temporary Tattoos

Londjii Unicorn Temporary Tattoos

$8.95

Baby Loren White w/ Blue Trim Bib

Baby Loren White w/ Blue Trim Bib

$14.95

Baby Club Chic Little Farm Blue Printed Bib

Baby Club Chic Little Farm Blue Printed Bib

$14.95

Baby Loren Pima Grey Dot Bib

Baby Loren Pima Grey Dot Bib

$14.95

Nella Pima Toile Burp Cloth

Nella Pima Toile Burp Cloth

$19.95

CHARM IT! Gold Eiffel Tower Charm

CHARM IT! Gold Eiffel Tower Charm

$6.00

Monkeybar Buddies Green Girls Spandex Shorts

Monkeybar Buddies Green Girls Spandex Shorts

$16.95

Crinkle Baby Paper (Assorted)
Crinkle Baby Paper (Assorted)

Crinkle Baby Paper (Assorted)

$6.95

2 colors
  • Yellow
  • Tie Dye

Southern Slumber Red Beans Solid Bamboo Lovey w/ Wooden Ring

$22.95

Farm Hand Socks

Farm Hand Socks

$7.95

Great Pretenders Unicorn BFF Necklace Set

Great Pretenders Unicorn BFF Necklace Set

$12.95

Great Pretenders Dragonfly Spring 2Pc Bracelet Set

Great Pretenders Dragonfly Spring 2Pc Bracelet Set

$8.95

Great Pretenders Spring Bunny 3Pc Ring Set

Great Pretenders Spring Bunny 3Pc Ring Set

$8.95

Great Pretenders Very Merry Strawberry 2Pc Bracelet Set

Great Pretenders Very Merry Strawberry 2Pc Bracelet Set

$7.95

Great Pretenders Woodland Fawn Necklace

Great Pretenders Woodland Fawn Necklace

$10.95

Great Pretenders Fruity Tooty Necklace

Great Pretenders Fruity Tooty Necklace

$10.95

Great Pretenders Rainbow Unicorn BFF Necklaces

Great Pretenders Rainbow Unicorn BFF Necklaces

$12.95

Mermaid Scales Patterned Tumblers

Mermaid Scales Patterned Tumblers

$16.95

Color Changing Sip Sip Tumbler - Happy to Be Here
Color Changing Sip Sip Tumbler - Happy to Be Here

Color Changing Sip Sip Tumbler - Happy to Be Here

$24.95

Cotton Clara Small Embroidery Kit - Donna Wilson
Cotton Clara Small Embroidery Kit - Donna Wilson

Cotton Clara Small Embroidery Kit - Donna Wilson

$16.95

Hot Focus Insulated Rainbow Lunch Bag

Hot Focus Insulated Rainbow Lunch Bag

$22.95

Diamond Dotz Greeting Cards (Assorted)
Diamond Dotz Greeting Cards (Assorted)

Diamond Dotz Greeting Cards (Assorted)

$9.95

Love at First Cuddle 4X6 Ceramic Picture Frame

Love at First Cuddle 4X6 Ceramic Picture Frame

$19.95

Baby Club Chic Sail Boats Printed Bib

Baby Club Chic Sail Boats Printed Bib

$14.95

Galexie Glister - Bewitched

Galexie Glister - Bewitched

$17.00

Magnolia Baby Mini Dot Bib - Gray

Magnolia Baby Mini Dot Bib - Gray

$14.95

Baby Club Chic Watercolor Bib - Floral Pastel

Baby Club Chic Watercolor Bib - Floral Pastel

$14.95

Meiya and Alvin’s New Friends Board Book
Meiya and Alvin’s New Friends Board Book

Meiya and Alvin’s New Friends Board Book

$12.00

Eva's House Baby Hairbrush 9M Baby Blue Polka Dots

Eva's House Baby Hairbrush 9M Baby Blue Polka Dots

$21.95

Eva's House 3Pk Small Grosgrain Bow Soft Nylon Headband

Eva's House 3Pk Small Grosgrain Bow Soft Nylon Headband

$18.95

1 color
  • Pink/Blue/Beige
Glitter Butterfly Cutie Enamel Stud Clip-On Earrings

Glitter Butterfly Cutie Enamel Stud Clip-On Earrings

$20.00

The Ultimate Dinosaur Encyclopedia: Enhanced with Stunning Interactive 3D Models and Videos

The Ultimate Dinosaur Encyclopedia: Enhanced with Stunning Interactive 3D Models and Videos

$24.95

Mean Girls On Wednesdays We Wear Pink Plush Accessory Pouch
Mean Girls On Wednesdays We Wear Pink Plush Accessory Pouch

Mean Girls On Wednesdays We Wear Pink Plush Accessory Pouch

$22.95

Never Follow a Spider
Never Follow a Spider

Never Follow a Spider

$9.99

How the Grinch Stole Christmas! Grow Your Heart 3D Cover Edition

How the Grinch Stole Christmas! Grow Your Heart 3D Cover Edition

$19.99

KINDergarten Where Kindness Matters Every Day

KINDergarten Where Kindness Matters Every Day

$18.99

Insect Lore Wearable Butterfly Wings
Insect Lore Wearable Butterfly Wings

Insect Lore Wearable Butterfly Wings

$12.95

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.