🎁 Need help finding a gift they'll love? That's our specialty.

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

A Little Joy Just For You!

Join the Olly-Olly crew! Cute outfits, fun toys, and zero overwhelm — delivered straight to your inbox.

By completing this form, you are signing up to receive our emails and can unsubscribe at any time

Gifts Under $25

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.

4827 Results

Clear filters
Light Up Butterfly Bubble Fan

Light Up Butterfly Bubble Fan

$8.99

3 colors
  • Pink
  • Yellow
  • Lavender
Small Textured Squishy Ball - Sensory Fidget Toy

Small Textured Squishy Ball - Sensory Fidget Toy

$8.99

Squeezy Crystal Ball
Squeezy Crystal Ball

Squeezy Crystal Ball

$8.99

Mini Squishy Sticky Metallic Ducks

Mini Squishy Sticky Metallic Ducks

$6.99

Furry Frens 12” Jumbo Squishy Paw
Furry Frens 12” Jumbo Squishy Paw

Furry Frens 12” Jumbo Squishy Paw

$20.00

Goldzilla - Viral Stretchee Monkee Toy

Goldzilla - Viral Stretchee Monkee Toy

$12.99

Die-Cast Pull-Back Motorcycle With Lights & Sound (Assorted)
Die-Cast Pull-Back Motorcycle With Lights & Sound (Assorted)

Die-Cast Pull-Back Motorcycle With Lights & Sound (Assorted)

$18.99

Great Pretenders Besties Bracelet (Assorted)

Great Pretenders Besties Bracelet (Assorted)

$8.95

Lemon Lavender I Washed Up Like This Super Soft Dryband Set
Lemon Lavender I Washed Up Like This Super Soft Dryband Set

Lemon Lavender I Washed Up Like This Super Soft Dryband Set

$18.00

4 colors
  • Pink
  • Mint
  • Grey
  • +1 more
Play Tab Modular Activity Board Tiles- Sensory Set 1
Play Tab Modular Activity Board Tiles- Sensory Set 1

Play Tab Modular Activity Board Tiles- Sensory Set 1

$24.99

TOY TOWER Squeezable Lizards
TOY TOWER Squeezable Lizards

TOY TOWER Squeezable Lizards

$6.95

Glo Pals Fun Filler Pack (for use with Sensory Jars)
Glo Pals Fun Filler Pack (for use with Sensory Jars)

Glo Pals Fun Filler Pack (for use with Sensory Jars)

$6.95

Little Southern Gentleman
Little Southern Gentleman

Little Southern Gentleman

$22.99

Super Duper Sugar Squisher Plush Sugar Dumplings
Super Duper Sugar Squisher Plush Sugar Dumplings

Super Duper Sugar Squisher Plush Sugar Dumplings

$15.00

The Blob Glow in the Dark Squishy Ball
The Blob Glow in the Dark Squishy Ball

The Blob Glow in the Dark Squishy Ball

$8.99

3 colors
  • Purple
  • Orange
Bread Square Toast Slow Rising Squishy

Bread Square Toast Slow Rising Squishy

$10.99

ORB Easy Sqweezy Triplets Dumplings - Mystery Pack

ORB Easy Sqweezy Triplets Dumplings - Mystery Pack

$15.00

Axolotl Squishy with Babies
Axolotl Squishy with Babies

Axolotl Squishy with Babies

$12.99

Rainbows by Paulette school ribbon strip pony tail streamers
Rainbows by Paulette school ribbon strip pony tail streamers, additional view

School Ribbon Strip Pony Tail Streamer

$16.99

4 colors
  • Black & Gold
  • Navy & White Check
  • +1 more
Polka Dot Glitter Squishy Ball

Polka Dot Glitter Squishy Ball

$10.99

Squidgy Puppy Squishy Toy
Squidgy Puppy Squishy Toy

Squidgy Puppy Squishy Toy

$9.99

Hot Focus Mega Sketching Fun - Tie Dye Butterfly

Hot Focus Mega Sketching Fun - Tie Dye Butterfly

$24.99

Binky Bro Sunglasses - 400 UV Protection
Binky Bro Sunglasses - 400 UV Protection

Binky Bro Sunglasses - 400 UV Protection

$22.00

Watchitude Spin Cube
Watchitude Spin Cube

Watchitude Spin Cube

$14.99

Waboba Mini Water Cracket with Zag Ball

Waboba Mini Water Cracket with Zag Ball

$24.99

3 colors
  • Teal
  • Orange
  • Yellow
AMOS Peelerz Gummy Peach

AMOS Peelerz Gummy Peach

$7.99

CHARM IT! Charm Birthstones
CHARM IT! Charm Birthstones

CHARM IT! Charm Birthstones

$6.00

12 colors
  • January
  • February
  • March
  • +9 more
Palm Pals - Indy Tiger
Palm Pals - Indy Tiger

Palm Pals - Indy Tiger

$12.99

Sequin Mardi Gras Velvet Top Knot Headband

Sequin Mardi Gras Velvet Top Knot Headband

$25.00

Toxic Waste Original Yellow Drum Sour Candy

Toxic Waste Original Yellow Drum Sour Candy

$3.99

Lemon Lavender You Had Me at Aloe Socks
Lemon Lavender You Had Me at Aloe Socks

Lemon Lavender You Had Me at Aloe Socks

$8.95

3 colors
  • Sage Green
  • Baby Pink
  • Aqua Blue
Original Weefarers Sunglasses
Original Weefarers Sunglasses

Original Weefarers Sunglasses

$25.00

5 colors, 3 sizes
  • Black
  • Tortoiseshell Brown
  • White
  • +2 more
  • Ages 0-1
  • Ages 2-3
  • Ages 4-6
Takumo glitter scented dumpling squishy

Takumo Glitter Scented Dumpling Squishy

$15.00

1.75" MINI 3 PACK ANIMAL SQUISHIES SURPRISE DUMPLING

$15.00

Sugar Squishy Gold Fish (Assorted)
Sugar Squishy Gold Fish (Assorted)

Sugar Squishy Gold Fish (Assorted)

$9.99

Sea Sheep Squishy
Sea Sheep Squishy

Sea Sheep Squishy

$8.99

Jumbo squishy duck

Jumbo Squishy Duck

$18.00

Wee Ones King Grosgrain Bowtie with Tails

$18.99

5 colors
  • White
  • +2 more
Cupcakes and Cartwheels Sparkles Headband
Cupcakes and Cartwheels Sparkles Headband

Cupcakes and Cartwheels Sparkles Headband

$18.99

4 colors
  • Pink
  • Purple
  • +1 more
Iridescent Wing Butterfly Claw Clips
Iridescent Wing Butterfly Claw Clips

Iridescent Wing Butterfly Claw Clips

$10.99

4 colors
  • Pink
  • Teal
  • +1 more
Garb 2 Art Flavored Lip Oil

Garb 2 Art Flavored Lip Oil

$9.99

Peeps Pop Up Lollipop

Peeps Pop Up Lollipop

$8.99

Wee Ones Medium French Satin Long Tail Bow
Wee Ones Medium French Satin Long Tail Bow

Wee Ones Medium French Satin Long Tail Bow

$18.00

6 colors
  • White
  • Navy
  • +3 more
Lather Me Up Silicone Body Scrubber
Lather Me Up Silicone Body Scrubber

Lather Me Up Silicone Body Scrubber

$10.95

4 colors
  • Pink
  • Green
  • Blue
  • +1 more
Assorted Water Snakes
Assorted Water Snakes

Assorted Water Snakes

$7.99

Lil' Watercolor Paint Pods- Set of 36

Lil' Watercolor Paint Pods- Set of 36

$16.99

Garb2Art Pop Rocks

Garb2Art Pop Rocks

$12.95

Scrunchems Neon Diddy Squish Balls- 3PK

Scrunchems Neon Diddy Squish Balls- 3PK

$12.99

Axolotl Squishy Snacks

Axolotl Squishy Snacks

$12.00

Jelly Bear LED Light Pen

Jelly Bear LED Light Pen

$6.99

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.