🎁 Need help finding a gift they'll love? That's our specialty.

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

A Little Joy Just For You!

Join the Olly-Olly crew! Cute outfits, fun toys, and zero overwhelm — delivered straight to your inbox.

By completing this form, you are signing up to receive our emails and can unsubscribe at any time

Gifts Under $25

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.

4827 Results

Clear filters
Squishy Corn Stress Relief Toy
Squishy Corn Stress Relief Toy

Squishy Corn Stress Relief Toy

$8.99

e-newton Hope Unwritten Bracelet
e-newton Hope Unwritten Bracelet

e-newton Hope Unwritten Bracelet

$20.00

Color Changing Mesh Stress Ball

Color Changing Mesh Stress Ball

$6.00

Marble Swirl Chilly Cube

Marble Swirl Chilly Cube

$9.99

Jefferies Socks White Pima Cotton Tights

Jefferies Socks White Pima Cotton Tights

$12.95

6 sizes
  • 0/6M
  • 6/18M
  • 18/24M
  • 2-4yrs
  • 4-6yrs
  • 6-8yrs
Crunchy Potato Squishy

Crunchy Potato Squishy

$12.00

Jumbo cheese-shaped squishy sensory toy

Jumbo Cheese Squishy

$20.00

Sugar Smooshies Ducky Duck Mega Squishy (Assorted)
Sugar Smooshies Ducky Duck Mega Squishy (Assorted)

Sugar Smooshies Ducky Duck Mega Squishy (Assorted)

$8.99

Mega Mystery Dumplinz
Mega Mystery Dumplinz

Mega Mystery Dumplinz

$25.00

Large Pickle Squishy

Large Pickle Squishy

$20.00

Fun Doh Sparkle Squishy Cubes (Viral Assortment)
Fun Doh Sparkle Squishy Cubes (Viral Assortment)

Fun Doh Sparkle Squishy Cubes (Viral Assortment)

$10.00

Globbie Spiky Squeeze Ball
Globbie Spiky Squeeze Ball

Globbie Spiky Squeeze Ball

$9.99

Jumbo 12" Squishy Duck

Jumbo 12" Squishy Duck

$20.00

Sweet Society Pretty Bow Lip Gloss
Sweet Society Pretty Bow Lip Gloss

Sweet Society Pretty Bow Lip Gloss

$10.00

Jeweled Mirror Hair Brush
Jeweled Mirror Hair Brush

Jeweled Mirror Hair Brush

$10.99

3 colors
  • Purple
  • Blue
  • Pink
Madame Alexander 8" Little Cuties Baby Doll - Assorted
A box of Madame Alexander 8" Little Cuties Baby Dolls, featuring multiple dolls with various colorful outfits and hats.

Madame Alexander 8" Little Cuties Baby Doll - Assorted

$16.99

Boba Squish-Tea Squishy
Boba Squish-Tea Squishy

Boba Squish-Tea Squishy

$14.99

Squishy Maltose Glitter Bear Squishy

Squishy Maltose Glitter Bear Squishy

$9.99

Fat Brain PlayTab modular activity board
Fat Brain PlayTab modular activity board, additional view

Fat Brain PlayTab Modular Activity Board

$14.99

Flocked Easter Bunny - Small

Flocked Easter Bunny - Small

$12.95

10 colors
  • Blue
  • Yellow
  • +7 more
Rainbow Surprise Mystery Squishy Dumplings

Rainbow Surprise Mystery Squishy Dumplings

$15.00

Garb2Art Milk Bath - Rainbow
Garb2Art Milk Bath - Rainbow

Garb2Art Milk Bath - Rainbow

$14.99

The Bubble's Day At LSU

The Bubble's Day At LSU

$16.95

Big Squij Jumbo Squishy Dachshund

Big Squij Jumbo Squishy Dachshund

$18.00

Crispy Tri-Colored Wax Covered Ball Squishy

Crispy Tri-Colored Wax Covered Ball Squishy

$10.00

Dough Doughs Sugar Squish Ice Cream Cone

Dough Doughs Sugar Squish Ice Cream Cone

$12.99

3 colors
  • Pink
  • Teal
  • Orange
Rainbow Mystery Slow RIse Squishy Bun

Rainbow Mystery Slow RIse Squishy Bun

$10.00

Snow in Seconds - Looks and Feels Like Real Snow
Snow in Seconds - Looks and Feels Like Real Snow

Snow in Seconds - Looks and Feels Like Real Snow

$9.99

Squishtible 12” Duckie Jumbo Squishy
Squishtible 12” Duckie Jumbo Squishy

Squishtible 12” Duckie Jumbo Squishy

$20.00

4 colors
  • Blue
  • +1 more
Squishy Maltose Swirl Bear Squishy

Squishy Maltose Swirl Bear Squishy

$9.99

Maltose Sparkle Cube Squishy

Maltose Sparkle Cube Squishy

$9.99

Maltose Polygonal Squishy

Maltose Polygonal Squishy

$9.99

Squishtible 12" Jumbo Scented Squeezy Strawberry

Squishtible 12" Jumbo Scented Squeezy Strawberry

$20.00

Blossom Soap Infused Sponge
Blossom Soap Infused Sponge

Blossom Soap Infused Sponge

$15.00

Purple & Gold Replacement Boot Tassel
Purple & Gold Replacement Boot Tassel

Purple & Gold Replacement Boot Tassel

$9.95

4 sizes
  • Infant (Crib Size 1-4)
  • Toddler (Size 5-13)
  • Big Kid (Youth Size 1-4)
  • Adult
Fun Doh Swirl Squishy Cubes Viral Assortment
Fun Doh Swirl Squishy Cubes Viral Assortment

Fun Doh Swirl Squishy Cubes Viral Assortment

$10.00

Squishy Banana

Squishy Banana

$9.99

Inkerz Dinosaur Paint Sensory Toy Squishy
Inkerz Dinosaur Paint Sensory Toy Squishy

Inkerz Dinosaur Paint Sensory Toy Squishy

$9.99

Lucky Bao Mystery Squishy Dumpling collectible toy

Lucky Bao Mystery Dumpling

$15.00

Zorbles Fidget Toy
Zorbles Fidget Toy

Zorbles Fidget Toy

$5.99

Great Pretenders Rising Star Chunky Gem Bracelet (Assorted)
Great Pretenders Rising Star Chunky Gem Bracelet (Assorted)

Great Pretenders Rising Star Chunky Gem Bracelet (Assorted)

$8.95

Lemon Lavender It's a Vibe Sonic Cleanser Brush

Lemon Lavender It's a Vibe Sonic Cleanser Brush

$14.99

4 colors
  • Pink
  • Blue
  • +1 more
Jefferies Socks Eyelet Lace Turn Cuff Socks - 1 Pair

Jefferies Socks Eyelet Lace Turn Cuff Socks - 1 Pair

$6.95

5 sizes
  • NB (0-1)
  • INF (1-4)
  • TD (3-7)
  • XS (6-11)
  • S (9-1)
Toysmith Skwishy Pet Dogs squishy toys

Skwishy Pet Dogs

$12.99

ORB Curiosities Taba-licious Yummies Mega
ORB Curiosities Taba-licious Yummies Mega

ORB Curiosities Taba-licious Yummies Mega

$9.99

Squishy Fuzzy Stretchi Blob - Maltose
Squishy Fuzzy Stretchi Blob - Maltose

Squishy Fuzzy Stretchi Blob - Maltose

$8.99

Scrunchems Mini Sugar Dumpling

Scrunchems Mini Sugar Dumpling

$10.00

Maltose Squeeze Crystal Cube Squishy

Maltose Squeeze Crystal Cube Squishy

$9.99

Gui Gui Single Pack
Gui Gui Single Pack

Gui Gui Single Pack

$20.00

Mood Rings
Mood Rings

Mood Rings

$10.00

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.