🎁 Need help finding a gift they'll love? That's our specialty.

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

A Little Joy Just For You!

Join the Olly-Olly crew! Cute outfits, fun toys, and zero overwhelm — delivered straight to your inbox.

By completing this form, you are signing up to receive our emails and can unsubscribe at any time

Gifts Under $25

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.

4827 Results

Clear filters
Jefferies Socks Classic White Nylon Knee High Socks
Jefferies Socks Classic White Nylon Knee High Socks

Jefferies Socks Classic White Nylon Knee High Socks

$7.95

2 colors, 6 sizes
  • White
  • NB (0-1)
  • INF (1-4)
  • TD (3-7)
  • XS (6-11)
  • S (9-1)
  • MD (12-6)
Indestructibles: Chew Proof · Rip Proof · Nontoxic · 100% Washable Books
Indestructibles: Chew Proof · Rip Proof · Nontoxic · 100% Washable Books

Indestructibles: Chew Proof · Rip Proof · Nontoxic · 100% Washable Books

$5.99

Assorted Clear Jelly Fish Squishy

Assorted Clear Jelly Fish Squishy

$9.99

Thank Heaven Embroidered Pillow Door Hanger
Thank Heaven Embroidered Pillow Door Hanger

Thank Heaven Embroidered Pillow Door Hanger

$25.00

2 colors
  • Pink
  • Blue
Scrunchems Mystery Dumpling

Scrunchems Mystery Dumpling

$10.00

Swirly Marble Ball

Swirly Marble Ball

$9.99

Mystery Mini Mushy Kinz

Mystery Mini Mushy Kinz

$9.99

Minecraft Jelly Cube Squishy
Minecraft Jelly Cube Squishy

Minecraft Jelly Cube Squishy

$14.00

Jumbo Bread Roll Squishy

Jumbo Bread Roll Squishy

$18.00

Assorted Donut Squishy 3.5”

Assorted Donut Squishy 3.5”

$10.99

Squishy Sugar Duck (Assorted)

Squishy Sugar Duck (Assorted)

$12.99

Sugar Bear Squad Sensory Toys

Sugar Bear Squad Sensory Toys

$10.99

4 colors
  • Yellow
  • Purple
  • +1 more
Fun Doh Mini Squishy Cube 2-Packs
Fun Doh Mini Squishy Cube 2-Packs

Fun Doh Mini Squishy Cube 2-Packs

$9.99

Dough Doughs Squish Balls
Dough Doughs Squish Balls

Dough Doughs Squish Balls

$9.99

Petite Mystery Fun Doh Dumpling
Petite Mystery Fun Doh Dumpling

Petite Mystery Fun Doh Dumpling

$10.00

Glitter Baby Sugar Squishy

Glitter Baby Sugar Squishy

$15.00

4 colors
  • Blue
  • Purple
  • Pink
  • +1 more
Azarhia top knot shimmer headband
Azarhia top knot shimmer headband, additional view

Azarhia Top Knot Shimmer Headband

$16.99

11 colors
  • Purple
  • Gold
  • White
  • +8 more
Iridescent Fluffy Unicorn Pens

Iridescent Fluffy Unicorn Pens

$8.99

5 colors
  • Teal
  • +2 more
Eeboo Playing Cards
Eeboo Playing Cards

Eeboo Playing Cards

$12.99

Giant Glow in the Dark Squishy Stress Ball

Giant Glow in the Dark Squishy Stress Ball

$25.00

Belle Cher Athletic Purple High Low Tank Top
Belle Cher Athletic Purple High Low Tank Top

Belle Cher Athletic Purple High Low Tank Top

$25.00

10 sizes
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
  • 8
  • 10
  • 12
  • 14
Iscream So Slushy Lip Balm

Iscream So Slushy Lip Balm

$7.95

Whoopee Cushion

Whoopee Cushion

$6.99

Dough Dough Squish Dumpling Metallic Mystery

Dough Dough Squish Dumpling Metallic Mystery

$15.00

Neon Pimple Squeeze Jumbo Squishy Ball
Neon Pimple Squeeze Jumbo Squishy Ball

Neon Pimple Squeeze Jumbo Squishy Ball

$12.99

ORB Taba-licious Jumbo Paw squishy
ORB Taba-licious Jumbo Paw squishy, additional view

ORB Curiosities Taba-licious Jumbo Paw (Asst)

$16.99

2Pc Purple and Gold Metallic Pom Poms

$23.99

Large Magic Baby Bottles (Choice of Milk or Orange Juice)
Large Magic Baby Bottles (Choice of Milk or Orange Juice)

Large Magic Baby Bottles (Choice of Milk or Orange Juice)

$6.99

Jefferies Socks Smooth Microfiber Tights
Jefferies Socks Smooth Microfiber Tights

Jefferies Socks Smooth Microfiber Tights

$9.95

2 colors, 6 sizes
  • White
  • Ivory
  • 0/6M
  • 6/18M
  • 18/24M
  • 2-4yrs
  • 4-6yrs
  • 6-8yrs
Vintage Flavored Lip Balm
Vintage Flavored Lip Balm

Vintage Flavored Lip Balm

$7.95

Great Pretenders Diamond Gem Fluffy Pens

Great Pretenders Diamond Gem Fluffy Pens

$6.95

4 colors
  • Purple
  • White
  • Blue
  • +1 more
Squishy Bakery Bread Roll
Squishy Bakery Bread Roll

Squishy Bakery Bread Roll

$9.99

Aero Motion Aero Props
Aero Motion Aero Props

Aero Motion Aero Props

$2.99

Squishy Vaseline Toothpaste

Squishy Vaseline Toothpaste

$12.99

Sugar Swaps Twinsies Babies squishy duo
Sugar Swaps Twinsies Babies squishy duo, additional view

Sugar Swaps Twinsies Babies (Assorted)

$10.00

Maltose Gumdrop Squishy

Maltose Gumdrop Squishy

$9.99

Squeeze Diamond Crystal Ball

Squeeze Diamond Crystal Ball

$9.99

Easy Sqweezy Jumbo Brainy Squishy

Easy Sqweezy Jumbo Brainy Squishy

$18.00

Stephen Joseph Wallet - Assorted
Stephen Joseph Wallet - Assorted

Stephen Joseph Wallet - Assorted

$16.00

Plus Plus Tubes - 70pc Building Toy Assorted
Plus Plus Tubes - 70pc Building Toy Assorted

Plus Plus Tubes - 70pc Building Toy Assorted

$8.95

Maltose Star Cube Squishy- Assorted
Maltose Star Cube Squishy- Assorted

Maltose Star Cube Squishy- Assorted

$9.99

Dough Doughs Sugar Squish Popsicle

Dough Doughs Sugar Squish Popsicle

$12.99

Sugar Swaps Metallic Balls
Sugar Swaps Metallic Balls

Sugar Swaps Metallic Balls

$9.99

ORB Curiosities Taba-licious Snack Sticks Ultra (Asst)
ORB Curiosities Taba-licious Snack Sticks Ultra (Asst)

ORB Curiosities Taba-licious Snack Sticks Ultra (Asst)

$10.99

Little Lady Nail Polish (Assorted Colors)
Little Lady Nail Polish (Assorted Colors)

Little Lady Nail Polish (Assorted Colors)

$14.00

10 colors
  • Princess Kisses
  • Rock Star
  • Cutey Queen
  • +7 more
Flat 2 Fast Car - Assorted
Flat 2 Fast Car - Assorted

Flat 2 Fast Car - Assorted

$14.99

Squishy Sports Balls (Assorted)
Squishy Sports Balls (Assorted)

Squishy Sports Balls (Assorted)

$8.99

Jumbo 12" Pickle Scented

Jumbo 12" Pickle Scented

$20.00

Christmas Reindeer Food

Christmas Reindeer Food

$7.95

Girl Nation Lil' Fingers Nail Art Assorted
Girl Nation Lil' Fingers Nail Art Assorted

Girl Nation Lil' Fingers Nail Art Assorted

$7.99

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.