🎁 Need help finding a gift they'll love? That's our specialty.

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

A Little Joy Just For You!

Join the Olly-Olly crew! Cute outfits, fun toys, and zero overwhelm — delivered straight to your inbox.

By completing this form, you are signing up to receive our emails and can unsubscribe at any time

Gifts Under $25

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.

4827 Results

Clear filters
Nice Buns Cinnamon Roll Squishy
Nice Buns Cinnamon Roll Squishy

Nice Buns Cinnamon Roll Squishy

$14.99

Medium Scattered Rhinstone Headband
Medium Scattered Rhinstone Headband

Medium Scattered Rhinstone Headband

$20.00

5 colors
  • Pink
  • Aqua
  • +2 more
Diamond Glitter Brilliant Ball Squishy

Diamond Glitter Brilliant Ball Squishy

$10.99

4 colors
  • Orange
  • Purple
  • +1 more
Slow Rise Strawberry Squishy
Slow Rise Strawberry Squishy

Slow Rise Strawberry Squishy

$14.00

Tasty Sounds - Watermelon Lollipop, K-pop Music

Tasty Sounds - Watermelon Lollipop, K-pop Music

$12.00

LCD Doodle Board & Magnetic Activity Fun - Critters

LCD Doodle Board & Magnetic Activity Fun - Critters

$24.99

Boo-Boo Buddies bandages packaging with Santa and Snowman designs on a blue background
Boo-Boo Buddies bandages packaging with Christmas tree and elf design on a white background

Boo Boo Buddies 24pc Bandages - Assorted

$7.95

Flip Pro Spin Bikes

Flip Pro Spin Bikes

$12.99

Dancing Diva Pink High Heels (One Size)
Dancing Diva Pink High Heels (One Size)

Dancing Diva Pink High Heels (One Size)

$25.00

Musee Bath Cowgirl Bath Balm
Musee Bath Cowgirl Bath Balm

Musee Bath Cowgirl Bath Balm

$12.00

Palm Pals - Vibrant Vivi Rainbow
Palm Pals - Vibrant Vivi Rainbow

Palm Pals - Vibrant Vivi Rainbow

$12.99

Christmas 2 Piece Hair Clips
Christmas 2 Piece Hair Clips

Christmas 2 Piece Hair Clips

$14.99

6 colors
  • Red Reindeer
  • Red Santa
  • Silver Tree
  • +3 more
Lilliput Little Things Earrings - Happy Daisy
Lilliput Little Things Earrings - Happy Daisy

Lilliput Little Things Earrings - Happy Daisy

$12.00

3 colors
  • Snow White
  • Pink
  • Purple
My Sticker Dress-Up Dancers

My Sticker Dress-Up Dancers

$9.99

Jefferies uniform cotton cable knee high socks

Jefferies Socks Uniform Cotton Cable Knee High Socks - 1600

$12.95

5 sizes
  • NB (0-1)
  • INF (1-4)
  • TD (3-7)
  • XS (6-11)
  • S (9-1)
Baubles Belle Light Up Christmas Headband
Baubles Belle Light Up Christmas Headband

Baubles Belle Light Up Christmas Headband

$14.99

Satin Heatless Hair Curlers
Satin Heatless Hair Curlers

Satin Heatless Hair Curlers

$14.95

2 colors
  • Pink
  • Gold
My Sticker Dress-Up Princesses sticker book

My Sticker Dress-Up Princesses

$9.99

6Pc - 2.25" Egg Sidewalk Chalk
6Pc - 2.25" Egg Sidewalk Chalk

6Pc - 2.25" Egg Sidewalk Chalk

$10.99

Mermaid Jewelry Twisted Bracelet

Mermaid Jewelry Twisted Bracelet

$5.95

Musee Bath Santa Claus is Coming to Town Bath Balm
Musee Bath Santa Claus is Coming to Town Bath Balm

Musee Bath Santa Claus is Coming to Town Bath Balm

$14.00

Crocodile Creek 7" Playball
Crocodile Creek 7" Playball

Crocodile Creek 7" Playball

$18.99

26 colors
  • Blue Unicorn
  • Mermaid
  • Butterflies
  • +23 more
Smooth Toe Capri Liner Socks 2Pr

Smooth Toe Capri Liner Socks 2Pr

$10.95

4 sizes
  • TD (3-7)
  • XS (6-11)
  • S (9-1)
  • MD (12-6)
Ballet Magic Coloring Set
Ballet Magic Coloring Set

Ballet Magic Coloring Set

$14.95

Great Pretenders 30 Pairs Mermaid Sticker Earrings

Great Pretenders 30 Pairs Mermaid Sticker Earrings

$9.99

Big Squij jumbo chili pepper squishy
Big Squij jumbo chili pepper squishy, additional view

Big Squij Jumbo Squishy Chili

$18.00

Jumbo Sugar Glitter Ball Squishy

Jumbo Sugar Glitter Ball Squishy

$14.00

Bunny Ice Cream Squishy

Bunny Ice Cream Squishy

$8.99

Squishy Gemz Mystery Bag
Squishy Gemz Mystery Bag

Squishy Gemz Mystery Bag

$8.99

MushMeez Scented Squish Berries
MushMeez Scented Squish Berries

MushMeez Scented Squish Berries

$12.99

4 colors
  • Yellow
  • Pink
  • +1 more
Sugar Swap 3Pc Mind Benders (Assorted)
Sugar Swap 3Pc Mind Benders (Assorted)

Sugar Swap 3Pc Mind Benders (Assorted)

$12.99

Cute Animal Squishies (Assorted)
Cute Animal Squishies (Assorted)

Cute Animal Squishies (Assorted)

$9.99

Peeling Banana Squishy Toy
Peeling Banana Squishy Toy

Peeling Banana Squishy Toy

$12.00

Cube Squeeze Neon Splatter Squishy
Cube Squeeze Neon Splatter Squishy

Cube Squeeze Neon Splatter Squishy

$9.99

Crunch & Squish Stress Ball Fidget Toy
Crunch & Squish Stress Ball Fidget Toy

Crunch & Squish Stress Ball Fidget Toy

$14.99

Monster In a Package - Assorted Capsule Toy

Monster In a Package - Assorted Capsule Toy

$5.99

Marble Squish Stretch Ball

Marble Squish Stretch Ball

$8.99

Dough Doughs Stretchie Octopus Rainbow
Dough Doughs Stretchie Octopus Rainbow

Dough Doughs Stretchie Octopus Rainbow

$8.99

Stretch N' Smash Grumpy Duck
Stretch N' Smash Grumpy Duck

Stretch N' Smash Grumpy Duck

$14.99

Ballet Shoe Bath Bomb with Surprise Coin Inside
Ballet Shoe Bath Bomb with Surprise Coin Inside

Ballet Shoe Bath Bomb with Surprise Coin Inside

$10.00

2.5" Squeezy Sugar Pastel Easter Eggs
2.5" Squeezy Sugar Pastel Easter Eggs

2.5" Squeezy Sugar Pastel Easter Eggs

$6.99

Duncan's Original Yo-Yo's (Assorted)

Duncan's Original Yo-Yo's (Assorted)

$9.99

Jumbo Squishy Pop Tart Squij
Jumbo Squishy Pop Tart Squij

Jumbo Squishy Pop Tart Squij

$18.00

Sticky Slug
Sticky Slug

Sticky Slug

$6.99

Die-Cast Car With Lights & Sound (Assorted)
Die-Cast Car With Lights & Sound (Assorted)

Die-Cast Car With Lights & Sound (Assorted)

$14.99

Easter Bunny Marshmallow Candy

Easter Bunny Marshmallow Candy

$15.00

iScream Smocked Racerback Tank Top - Rose

iScream Smocked Racerback Tank Top - Rose

$24.00

2 sizes
  • Small/Medium (7-10)
  • Medium/Large (10-14)
ORB Taba-licious Charmlets (Asst)

ORB Taba-licious Charmlets (Asst)

$7.95

ORB Snarkies Bubble Charmlets (Asst)

ORB Snarkies Bubble Charmlets (Asst)

$10.99

Great Pretenders Wish Upon a Rainbow Star Necklace & Bracelet Set, 2pc

Great Pretenders Wish Upon a Rainbow Star Necklace & Bracelet Set, 2pc

$12.99

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.