🎁 Need help finding a gift they'll love? That's our specialty.

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

A Little Joy Just For You!

Join the Olly-Olly crew! Cute outfits, fun toys, and zero overwhelm — delivered straight to your inbox.

By completing this form, you are signing up to receive our emails and can unsubscribe at any time

Gifts Under $25

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.

4827 Results

Clear filters
Super Duper Sugar Squisher - Mini Duck 2Pk

Super Duper Sugar Squisher - Mini Duck 2Pk

$12.99

Squishtible Scented Stretchy Duck Squishy, 5 Inch
Squishtible Scented Stretchy Duck Squishy, 5 Inch

Squishtible Scented Stretchy Duck Squishy, 5 Inch

$9.99

Rainbow Mystery Dumpling 3.5"

Rainbow Mystery Dumpling 3.5"

$15.00

Big Squij Jumbo Squishy Turkey

Big Squij Jumbo Squishy Turkey

$20.00

Sugar Swaps Cool Cube Shimmers (Assorted)
Sugar Swaps Cool Cube Shimmers (Assorted)

Sugar Swaps Cool Cube Shimmers (Assorted)

$8.99

Scrunchems Squishy Sushi
Scrunchems Squishy Sushi

Scrunchems Squishy Sushi

$12.99

Scrunchems Giant Sugar Cube
Scrunchems Giant Sugar Cube

Scrunchems Giant Sugar Cube

$15.00

Sugar Swaps Onesies Dragon Eggs
Sugar Swaps Onesies Dragon Eggs

Sugar Swaps Onesies Dragon Eggs

$10.99

Sugar Swaps Building Blocks

Sugar Swaps Building Blocks

$11.99

Great Pretenders Rainbow Bright Bracelet Set Assorted

Great Pretenders Rainbow Bright Bracelet Set Assorted

$12.95

Rubber Duckie Water Toy Cupcakes and Cartwheels

Rubber Duckie Water Toy Cupcakes and Cartwheels

$7.99

3 colors
  • Yellow
  • Pink
ORB Curiosities Taba-licious Sunshine Surprise Pets (Asst)

ORB Curiosities Taba-licious Sunshine Surprise Pets (Asst)

$10.99

iScream Rhinestone Pen
iScream Rhinestone Pen

iScream Rhinestone Pen

$8.99

Jellystone Rainbow Stacker Teether & Toy
Jellystone Rainbow Stacker Teether & Toy

Jellystone Rainbow Stacker Teether & Toy

$24.99

2 colors
  • Pastel
  • Rainbow
Mobi Little Whale bath fizzy
Mobi Little Whale bath fizzy, additional view

Mobi Little Whale Bath Co. Bath Fizzies - Single

$6.99

6 colors
  • Purple
  • Light Blue
  • Green
  • +3 more
Sweet Bandit Sour Ooze Liquid Candy
Sweet Bandit Sour Ooze Liquid Candy

Sweet Bandit Sour Ooze Liquid Candy

$4.99

Wee Ones Medium Scalloped Grosgrain Long Tail Bow
Wee Ones Medium Scalloped Grosgrain Long Tail Bow

Wee Ones Medium Scalloped Grosgrain Long Tail Bow

$15.00

7 colors
  • White
  • +4 more
My First Big Book of Dinosaurs Coloring Book

My First Big Book of Dinosaurs Coloring Book

$9.99

Musee Bath Daisy bath balm
Musee Bath Daisy bath balm, additional view

Musee Bath Daisy Bath Balm

$12.00

My Easter Sticktivity Book
My Easter Sticktivity Book

My Easter Sticktivity Book

$12.99

Shine Accessories - Sweet

Shine Accessories - Sweet

$24.99

AMOS Peelerz mango gummy candy bag

AMOS Peelerz Gummy Mango

$7.99

Pudgiez Marble Duck Squishy
Pudgiez Marble Duck Squishy

Pudgiez Marble Duck Squishy

$18.00

4 colors
  • Pink
  • Red
  • Blue
  • +1 more
Bluey Plush
Bluey Plush

Bluey Plush

$18.95

Quilted Mini Puff Bag Keychain
Quilted Mini Puff Bag Keychain

Quilted Mini Puff Bag Keychain

$14.99

7 colors
  • Lavender
  • +4 more
Mighty Racers

Mighty Racers

$7.99

Kid's Seamless Knit Chevron Crop Top - White
Kid's Seamless Knit Chevron Crop Top - White

Kid's Seamless Knit Chevron Crop Top - White

$25.00

2 sizes
  • S/M
  • L/XL
Reindeer Vanilla Marshmallow Scented Lip Balm

Reindeer Vanilla Marshmallow Scented Lip Balm

$7.95

Spider Oooze Putty
Spider Oooze Putty

Spider Oooze Putty

$6.95

4 colors
  • Pink
  • Yellow
  • Blue
  • +1 more
Scented Dual Fun Markers - Sweet

Scented Dual Fun Markers - Sweet

$14.99

Hair Flair Color Gel Sticks - Metallic

Hair Flair Color Gel Sticks - Metallic

$22.99

Deluxe Sparkle Star Wand

Deluxe Sparkle Star Wand

$10.95

Jefferies Socks Smooth Toe Ruffle Ripple Edge Sport Quarter Socks

Jefferies Socks Smooth Toe Ruffle Ripple Edge Sport Quarter Socks

$7.95

4 sizes
  • X-SMALL (6-11)
  • SMALL (9-1)
  • MEDIUM (12-6)
  • LARGE (6-9)
Ooly Yummy Scented Gel Glitter Pens

Ooly Yummy Scented Gel Glitter Pens

$14.99

Spin Copter Cosmic Car
Spin Copter Cosmic Car

Spin Copter Cosmic Car

$14.95

The Big Squij Penguin

The Big Squij Penguin

$18.00

Stretchi Balloon Dogs
Stretchi Balloon Dogs

Stretchi Balloon Dogs

$7.99

Secret Squishy Dumplin

Secret Squishy Dumplin

$15.00

Sugar Squish Glitter Peanut

Sugar Squish Glitter Peanut

$12.99

Glow-in-the-Dark Sparkle Gummy Bear Squishy

Glow-in-the-Dark Sparkle Gummy Bear Squishy

$11.99

4 colors
  • Pink
  • Purple
  • +1 more
Cube Squeeze Bubble Bead Ball

Cube Squeeze Bubble Bead Ball

$10.99

Water Pets Squishy
Water Pets Squishy

Water Pets Squishy

$9.99

Hot Focus princess LCD doodle board

LCD Doodle Board & Magnetic Activity Fun - Princess

$24.99

Medium Crepe Satin with Grosgrain Underlay Hair Bow
Medium Crepe Satin with Grosgrain Underlay Hair Bow

Medium Crepe Satin with Grosgrain Underlay Hair Bow

from $15.00

5 colors, 2 sizes
  • White
  • Antique White
  • Light Pink
  • +2 more
  • Medium
  • King
ORB Curiosities Taba-licious Flowers (Asst)
ORB Curiosities Taba-licious Flowers (Asst)

ORB Curiosities Taba-licious Flowers (Asst)

$10.99

Wee Ones mini scalloped grosgrain long tail hair bow
Wee Ones mini scalloped grosgrain long tail hair bow, additional view

Wee Ones Mini Scalloped Grosgrain Long Tail Bow

$14.00

9 colors
  • White
  • Navy
  • +6 more
Sensory Surprise Vending Machine
Sensory Surprise Vending Machine

Sensory Surprise Vending Machine

$18.99

Aurora Palm Pals Lady Spaniel plush
Aurora Palm Pals Lady Spaniel plush, additional view

Palm Pals - Lady Spaniel

$12.99

Jefferies Socks Ripple Edge Smooth Toe Turn Cuff Socks 2 Pair Pack - Pink/White

Jefferies Socks Ripple Edge Smooth Toe Turn Cuff Socks 2 Pair Pack - Pink/White

$9.95

5 sizes
  • NB (0-1)
  • INFANT (1-4)
  • TODDLER (3-7)
  • XS (6-11)
  • SMALL (9-1)
iScream Pink Disco Ball Party Pen

iScream Pink Disco Ball Party Pen

$6.99

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.