🎁 Need help finding a gift they'll love? That's our specialty.

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

A Little Joy Just For You!

Join the Olly-Olly crew! Cute outfits, fun toys, and zero overwhelm — delivered straight to your inbox.

By completing this form, you are signing up to receive our emails and can unsubscribe at any time

Gifts Under $25

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.

4827 Results

Clear filters
Jefferies Socks Knee High Ruffle Trim Socks

Jefferies Socks Knee High Ruffle Trim Socks

$9.95

6 sizes
  • NB (0-1)
  • INF (1-4)
  • TD (3-7)
  • XS (6-11)
  • S (9-1)
  • MD (12-6)
Pretty Woman Nail Polish - Neon Valley Collection
Pretty Woman Nail Polish - Neon Valley Collection

Pretty Woman Nail Polish - Neon Valley Collection

$9.95

3 colors
  • Ultra Violet
  • Optic Orange
  • Electric Glow
Water Works Makeup Removing Towel
Water Works Makeup Removing Towel

Water Works Makeup Removing Towel

$8.95

4 colors
  • Aqua
  • Pink
  • Purple
  • +1 more
Take a Bow Plush Spa Headband
Take a Bow Plush Spa Headband

Take a Bow Plush Spa Headband

$14.95

3 colors
  • Pink
  • Blue
  • Grey
Eva's House Big Grosgrain Bow Soft Nylon Headband
Eva's House Big Grosgrain Bow Soft Nylon Headband

Eva's House Big Grosgrain Bow Soft Nylon Headband

$18.95

5 colors
  • Light Pink
  • Light blue
  • Lavender
  • +2 more
12pc Color Brush - Watercolor Pencil & Paintbrush in One
12pc Color Brush - Watercolor Pencil & Paintbrush in One

12pc Color Brush - Watercolor Pencil & Paintbrush in One

$24.99

Beads & Jewelry: Jewelry Making Kit
Beads & Jewelry: Jewelry Making Kit

Beads & Jewelry: Jewelry Making Kit

$18.95

Koo Koo Cluckin Chicken Candy Dispenser

Koo Koo Cluckin Chicken Candy Dispenser

$14.99

Mardi Gras Tinsel Headband

Mardi Gras Tinsel Headband

$18.95

Ruby Ballet Skirt
Ruby Ballet Skirt

Ruby Ballet Skirt

$19.95

2 colors, 6 sizes
  • Black
  • Pink
  • XXS
  • XS
  • SM
  • MD
  • LG
  • XL
Waboba Water Color Changing Football
Waboba Water Color Changing Football

Waboba Water Color Changing Football

$22.99

Scrunchems Galaxy Light Up Squish Ball Sensory Stress Toy

Scrunchems Galaxy Light Up Squish Ball Sensory Stress Toy

$9.50

Marshmello Snowflake squishy cube

Marshmello Snowflake Squishy Cube

$8.99

Ocean Ice Maltose Squishy

Ocean Ice Maltose Squishy

$9.99

Scrunchems Textured Sugar Cube

Scrunchems Textured Sugar Cube

$8.99

Sugar Squishy Mini Cat

Sugar Squishy Mini Cat

$12.99

Tabalicious Big Bellies Squishy
Tabalicious Big Bellies Squishy

Tabalicious Big Bellies Squishy

$10.99

Hachimi Pastries and Snacks Squishy Surprise Box
Hachimi Pastries and Snacks Squishy Surprise Box

Hachimi Pastries and Snacks Squishy Surprise Box

$12.99

Dough Doughs 3Pk Squish Neon Balls

Dough Doughs 3Pk Squish Neon Balls

$12.00

Rainbow Squirmiez

Rainbow Squirmiez

$9.99

After Shock Gummy Fruity Fries

After Shock Gummy Fruity Fries

$6.99

London Bridge Animal Tails Cloth Book
London Bridge Animal Tails Cloth Book

London Bridge Animal Tails Cloth Book

$16.99

Silly Tube Cube
Silly Tube Cube

Silly Tube Cube

$22.99

Doodleface Wipe Away Crayons

Doodleface Wipe Away Crayons

$9.99

Light Up Easter Egg Pen
Light Up Easter Egg Pen

Light Up Easter Egg Pen

$15.00

Waboba Mini Land Cracket with Mini Moon Ball
Waboba Mini Land Cracket with Mini Moon Ball

Waboba Mini Land Cracket with Mini Moon Ball

$24.99

Wiggle Worms
Wiggle Worms

Wiggle Worms

$24.99

Makeup Your Mind Blending Sponge

Makeup Your Mind Blending Sponge

$8.95

4 colors
  • Mint
  • Yellow
  • pink
  • +1 more
Great Pretenders Rainbow Smiles 3Pc Bracelet Set

Great Pretenders Rainbow Smiles 3Pc Bracelet Set

$10.95

iScream Sprinkle Sparkle Heart-Shaped Mirror
iScream Sprinkle Sparkle Heart-Shaped Mirror

iScream Sprinkle Sparkle Heart-Shaped Mirror

$19.99

Jefferies Socks Smooth Toe Eyelet Lace/Ripple/Bubble Quarter Ankle Socks 3Pk

Jefferies Socks Smooth Toe Eyelet Lace/Ripple/Bubble Quarter Ankle Socks 3Pk

$12.99

5 sizes
  • NB
  • Infant (1-4)
  • Toddler (3-7)
  • XS (6-11)
  • S (9-1)
TOY TOWER - Party Animals

TOY TOWER - Party Animals

$7.95

Wee Ones Add-A-Bow Elastic Baby Bands - Two Pack - White/Light Pink

Wee Ones Add-A-Bow Elastic Baby Bands - Two Pack - White/Light Pink

$10.99

2 sizes
  • Newborn (0-6 Months)
  • Infant (6-24 Months)
Jefferies Socks 2Pc NB Bubble Booties - White
Jefferies Socks 2Pc NB Bubble Booties - White

Jefferies Socks 2Pc NB Bubble Booties - White

$9.95

2 sizes
  • Newborn
  • Infant
Magnolia Baby Light Blue Baby Joy Embroidered Bib

Magnolia Baby Light Blue Baby Joy Embroidered Bib

$14.95

Girl Nation Ring on the Fun Enamel Ring
Girl Nation Ring on the Fun Enamel Ring

Girl Nation Ring on the Fun Enamel Ring

$12.95

Ooly 12Pc Color Appeel Crayon Sticks
Ooly 12Pc Color Appeel Crayon Sticks

Ooly 12Pc Color Appeel Crayon Sticks

$14.99

Palm Pals - Pisces Shooting Star

Palm Pals - Pisces Shooting Star

$10.99

JV Charm Club - Dance Bracelet

JV Charm Club - Dance Bracelet

$15.00

3 colors
Maya J Kids 3Pk Bracelet Hair Tie
Maya J Kids 3Pk Bracelet Hair Tie

Maya J Kids 3Pk Bracelet Hair Tie

$18.00

4 colors
  • Pink
  • Purple
  • Blue
  • +1 more
Ooly Double Up! 6Pc Double Ended Markers
Ooly Double Up! 6Pc Double Ended Markers

Ooly Double Up! 6Pc Double Ended Markers

$12.00

Ooly Very Berry Scented Gel Pens
Ooly Very Berry Scented Gel Pens

Ooly Very Berry Scented Gel Pens

$12.99

Fantasy Creatures Rechargeable Flashlight
Fantasy Creatures Rechargeable Flashlight

Fantasy Creatures Rechargeable Flashlight

$12.95

3 colors
  • Mermaid
  • Unicorn
  • Fairy
Lucky Duck Socks- Mardi Gras Camo

Lucky Duck Socks- Mardi Gras Camo

$10.99

4 sizes
  • 2-3
  • 4-6
  • 7-9
  • 10-12
Lil Wish Lanterns Mystery Pack

Lil Wish Lanterns Mystery Pack

$5.00

TOY TOWER Stretchable Dinos
TOY TOWER Stretchable Dinos

TOY TOWER Stretchable Dinos

$6.95

Dance Elastic Hair Ties

Dance Elastic Hair Ties

$8.99

Tonies - The Laurie Berkner Band
Tonies - The Laurie Berkner Band

Tonies - The Laurie Berkner Band

$22.00

Dragon Bite Hand Puppet
Dragon Bite Hand Puppet

Dragon Bite Hand Puppet

$8.95

3 colors
  • Purple
  • Blue
  • Green
Lucky Duck Socks- Antlers
Lucky Duck Socks- Antlers

Lucky Duck Socks- Antlers

$10.95

4 sizes
  • 2-3
  • 4-6
  • 7-9
  • 10-12

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.