🎁 Need help finding a gift they'll love? That's our specialty.

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

A Little Joy Just For You!

Join the Olly-Olly crew! Cute outfits, fun toys, and zero overwhelm — delivered straight to your inbox.

By completing this form, you are signing up to receive our emails and can unsubscribe at any time

Gifts Under $25

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.

4827 Results

Clear filters
Repositionable Sticker Book - Wild For Animals

Repositionable Sticker Book - Wild For Animals

$10.99

Maya J Tween 3Pk Bracelet Hair Tie
Maya J Tween 3Pk Bracelet Hair Tie

Maya J Tween 3Pk Bracelet Hair Tie

$18.00

4 colors
  • Beige Elastic with Gold Chain Link
  • Beige Elastic with Gold
  • Black Elastic with Gunmetal
  • +1 more
TOY TOWER Fiddle Fidget Cube

TOY TOWER Fiddle Fidget Cube

$6.95

Duck Hunt Board Book

Duck Hunt Board Book

$11.95

Giant Shiny Dinosaur Dominoes
Giant Shiny Dinosaur Dominoes

Giant Shiny Dinosaur Dominoes

$25.00

Garb2Art Milk Bath - Pixie Dust

Garb2Art Milk Bath - Pixie Dust

$14.99

Musee Bath Rudolph the Red Nosed Reindeer Bath Balm
Musee Bath Rudolph the Red Nosed Reindeer Bath Balm

Musee Bath Rudolph the Red Nosed Reindeer Bath Balm

$14.00

Living Nature plush mallard duck
Living Nature plush mallard duck, additional view

Living Nature Plush Mallard

$10.95

Do You Believe in Magic Unicorn Boxed Bath Balm

Do You Believe in Magic Unicorn Boxed Bath Balm

$12.00

Retro Mini Toy Soldier 12pk

Retro Mini Toy Soldier 12pk

$8.95

6Pc Soap Crayons & Foam Holder
6Pc Soap Crayons & Foam Holder

6Pc Soap Crayons & Foam Holder

$12.00

Oh My Glitter 6pc Liquid Neon Highlighters
Oh My Glitter 6pc Liquid Neon Highlighters

Oh My Glitter 6pc Liquid Neon Highlighters

$18.00

Fat Brain Toys Ribbon Ninja
Fat Brain Toys Ribbon Ninja

Fat Brain Toys Ribbon Ninja

$24.95

Petey & Murray Go For A Swim
Petey & Murray Go For A Swim

Petey & Murray Go For A Swim

$16.99

Floss & Rock Water Bottle (Assorted)
Floss & Rock Water Bottle (Assorted)

Floss & Rock Water Bottle (Assorted)

$14.95

Crackling Crunchy Pudding Squishy
Crackling Crunchy Pudding Squishy

Crackling Crunchy Pudding Squishy

$12.99

Coconut Oil Vaseline Mixed Fruit Squishy
Coconut Oil Vaseline Mixed Fruit Squishy

Coconut Oil Vaseline Mixed Fruit Squishy

$12.99

The Big Blob Two-Tone Squishy Ball (assorted)

The Big Blob Two-Tone Squishy Ball (assorted)

$14.99

Sparkle Kitty Squishy

Sparkle Kitty Squishy

$8.99

Glitter Axolotl Squish

Glitter Axolotl Squish

$8.99

Matcha Squish-Tea scented squishy
Matcha Squish-Tea scented squishy, additional view

Matcha Squish-Tea Scented Squishy

$14.99

Jumbo Squishy Pig
Jumbo Squishy Pig

Jumbo Squishy Pig

$18.00

Squishy Taba Fruit- Assorted
Squishy Taba Fruit- Assorted

Squishy Taba Fruit- Assorted

$9.99

Squishy Stretchy Pug Puppy Stress Toy
Squishy Stretchy Pug Puppy Stress Toy

Squishy Stretchy Pug Puppy Stress Toy

$8.99

2Pk Squishi Besties
2Pk Squishi Besties

2Pk Squishi Besties

$9.99

Fluffmellies Cute Sweet Piggy - Ultra Slow-Rise Sweet Bakery Scented Squishy Toy
Fluffmellies Cute Sweet Piggy - Ultra Slow-Rise Sweet Bakery Scented Squishy Toy

Fluffmellies Cute Sweet Piggy - Ultra Slow-Rise Sweet Bakery Scented Squishy Toy

$12.99

Zuru Pets Alive Swimming Axolotl
Zuru Pets Alive Swimming Axolotl

Zuru Pets Alive Swimming Axolotl

$19.99

Laura Kelly Games on the Go - Bingo

Laura Kelly Games on the Go - Bingo

$10.00

9" Rainbow Bouncy Ball

9" Rainbow Bouncy Ball

$10.99

Yummy Gummy Bear Ring

Yummy Gummy Bear Ring

$4.99

3pk Unicorn Mini Bubble Wands
3pk Unicorn Mini Bubble Wands

3pk Unicorn Mini Bubble Wands

$8.99

Douglas Bright Color Lil' Bitty Bunnies- Assorted

Douglas Bright Color Lil' Bitty Bunnies- Assorted

$14.99

3 colors
  • Pink
  • Purple
  • Teal
Sticker Doll Dress Up Ballet

Sticker Doll Dress Up Ballet

$8.99

Peachybbies- Pastel Cloud Cake

Peachybbies- Pastel Cloud Cake

$18.99

Jefferies ruffle lace and ripple edge turn cuff socks, 2 pair

Jefferies Socks Ruffle Lace and Ripple Edge Turn Cuff Socks - 2 Pair

$12.95

2 colors, 3 sizes
  • NB
  • Infant
  • Toddler
Omy Pro Cozy Art Coloring Book- Kawaii
Omy Pro Cozy Art Coloring Book- Kawaii

Omy Pro Cozy Art Coloring Book- Kawaii

$12.99

Omy Pro Sticker Book- Unicorn
Omy Pro Sticker Book- Unicorn

Omy Pro Sticker Book- Unicorn

$12.99

Medium Wee Ones Splish Splash Vinyl Bow
Medium Wee Ones Splish Splash Vinyl Bow

Medium Wee Ones Splish Splash Vinyl Bow

$18.00

4 colors
  • Shocking Pink
  • Royal Orchid
  • Hot Pink
  • +1 more
Mardi Gras Textured Hair Bows

Mardi Gras Textured Hair Bows

$20.00

Unicorn Cuddles Clip & Cuddle

Unicorn Cuddles Clip & Cuddle

$12.99

King French Satin Bow Tie W/ Long Tails
King French Satin Bow Tie W/ Long Tails

King French Satin Bow Tie W/ Long Tails

$25.00

5 colors
  • Red
  • White
  • Beige
  • +2 more
Sunshine & Glitter- Festival Ready Body Glitter
Sunshine & Glitter- Festival Ready Body Glitter

Sunshine & Glitter- Festival Ready Body Glitter

$15.00

iScream Glitter Lipstick Pens
iScream Glitter Lipstick Pens

iScream Glitter Lipstick Pens

$6.99

Great Pretenders 30 Pairs Frosty Sister Stick On Earrings

Great Pretenders 30 Pairs Frosty Sister Stick On Earrings

$9.99

Musee Pink Santa Bath Balm

Musee Pink Santa Bath Balm

$14.00

Toysmith Neon Slime

Toysmith Neon Slime

$4.99

4 colors
  • Teal
  • +1 more
Fruit Stand Mini Bag and Stationery Set
Fruit Stand Mini Bag and Stationery Set

Fruit Stand Mini Bag and Stationery Set

$12.99

Palm Pals - Serena Mermaid
Palm Pals - Serena Mermaid

Palm Pals - Serena Mermaid

$12.99

Palm Pals - Party Sized 8" Happy B'Day Cake
Palm Pals - Party Sized 8" Happy B'Day Cake

Palm Pals - Party Sized 8" Happy B'Day Cake

$19.99

King Mesh Glitter Grosgrain Overlay Bow
King Mesh Glitter Grosgrain Overlay Bow

King Mesh Glitter Grosgrain Overlay Bow

$25.00

4 colors
  • Gold
  • Red
  • +1 more

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.