🎁 Need help finding a gift they'll love? That's our specialty.

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

A Little Joy Just For You!

Join the Olly-Olly crew! Cute outfits, fun toys, and zero overwhelm — delivered straight to your inbox.

By completing this form, you are signing up to receive our emails and can unsubscribe at any time

Gifts Under $25

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.

4827 Results

Clear filters
Stretchi Dude
Stretchi Dude

Stretchi Dude

$10.00

Pudgiez Fuzzy Hamster
Pudgiez Fuzzy Hamster

Pudgiez Fuzzy Hamster

$8.99

Scrunchems Squishy Sugar Drop

Scrunchems Squishy Sugar Drop

$8.99

Scrunchems Heart Squish Bear

Scrunchems Heart Squish Bear

$8.99

Dough Doughs Squish Super Squeezy Jellyfish
Dough Doughs Squish Super Squeezy Jellyfish

Dough Doughs Squish Super Squeezy Jellyfish

$9.99

The Original Wooly Willy

The Original Wooly Willy

$5.00

Zuru Pets Alive Water Activated Swimming Mermaid
Zuru Pets Alive Water Activated Swimming Mermaid

Zuru Pets Alive Water Activated Swimming Mermaid

$22.99

Brilliant Bling Bedazzle Kit

Brilliant Bling Bedazzle Kit

$25.00

Clementoni DIY Create Your Own Pen
Clementoni DIY Create Your Own Pen

Clementoni DIY Create Your Own Pen

$15.00

Fluffmellies Cute Steamed Buns - Ultra Slow-Rise Sweet Bakery Scented Squishy Toy

Fluffmellies Cute Steamed Buns - Ultra Slow-Rise Sweet Bakery Scented Squishy Toy

$12.99

Fluffmellies Cute Dog - Ultra Slow-Rise Sweet Bakery Scented Squishy Toy

Fluffmellies Cute Dog - Ultra Slow-Rise Sweet Bakery Scented Squishy Toy

$9.99

Laura Kelly Games on the Go - TicTacToe

Laura Kelly Games on the Go - TicTacToe

$10.00

Geo Squish Sugar Ball

Geo Squish Sugar Ball

$10.00

Stretchy Sand Axolotl

Stretchy Sand Axolotl

$5.99

3 colors
  • Pink
  • Purple
  • White
Car Carrier Assortment
Car Carrier Assortment

Car Carrier Assortment

$18.99

2 colors
  • Red
  • Teal
Bari Lynn Crystallized Puffy Bow Cutester Keychain

Bari Lynn Crystallized Puffy Bow Cutester Keychain

$18.99

4 colors
  • ivory
  • +1 more
Blossom Glam Squad Lip Gloss/Perfume Oil Combo
Blossom Glam Squad Lip Gloss/Perfume Oil Combo

Blossom Glam Squad Lip Gloss/Perfume Oil Combo

$15.00

Play Tab Go!
Play Tab Go!

Play Tab Go!

$14.99

Blended Spirit Mardi Gras Stoned Sock Set
Blended Spirit Mardi Gras Stoned Sock Set

Blended Spirit Mardi Gras Stoned Sock Set

$14.99

Fashion Angels Pet Fashion Sticker Stylist

Fashion Angels Pet Fashion Sticker Stylist

$18.99

GP Bling Bling Spinner Fidget Rings (Assorted)

GP Bling Bling Spinner Fidget Rings (Assorted)

$6.99

Deluxe Twinkle Twinkle Star Wands

Deluxe Twinkle Twinkle Star Wands

$10.95

Light-up diamond spinning wand toy
Light-up diamond spinning wand toy, additional view

Light-Up Diamond Spinning Wand

$22.99

2 colors
  • Teal
  • Fairy Tale
Aquoddities Squishimals

Aquoddities Squishimals

$9.99

Colorful Fan Bubble Wand
Colorful Fan Bubble Wand

Colorful Fan Bubble Wand

$8.99

4 colors
  • Pink
  • Blue
  • +1 more
Pink toy makeup set packaging with 'Sweet Kisses' branding on a white background

Hot Focus Sweet Kisses Critters Makeup

$16.99

Snifty Geo Sticks pastel paint sticks

Snifty Geo Sticks - Pastel

$14.99

Belle Cher Athletic Coral High Low Tank Top
Belle Cher Athletic Coral High Low Tank Top

Belle Cher Athletic Coral High Low Tank Top

$25.00

10 sizes
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
  • 8
  • 10
  • 12
  • 14
LED Illuminating Bubble Wand Blower
LED Illuminating Bubble Wand Blower

LED Illuminating Bubble Wand Blower

$18.99

Stretch and Mold Bunny Cupcakes and Cartwheels
Stretch and Mold Bunny Cupcakes and Cartwheels

Stretch and Mold Bunny Cupcakes and Cartwheels

$7.99

Lindo Face Wash Bow Headband
Lindo Face Wash Bow Headband

Lindo Face Wash Bow Headband

$9.99

Classic Valentine Heart Lollipop

Classic Valentine Heart Lollipop

$6.00

Confetti Circle Overture Key Ring
Confetti Circle Overture Key Ring

Confetti Circle Overture Key Ring

$25.00

7 colors
  • Purple
  • Hot Pink
  • Blue
  • +4 more

RBP Ruffle Edge Satin Long Tail Bow

$16.95

5 colors
  • White
  • Red
  • Pink
  • +2 more
Dope Slimes - Christmas Mallow Puff

Dope Slimes - Christmas Mallow Puff

$18.99

Baby's First Christmas 2024 Ceramic Photo Ornament
Baby's First Christmas 2024 Ceramic Photo Ornament

Baby's First Christmas 2024 Ceramic Photo Ornament

$14.99

Great Pretenders 3Pk Boutique Chic Cheerful Studded Earrings

Great Pretenders 3Pk Boutique Chic Cheerful Studded Earrings

$9.95

Christmas Light-Up Rubber Duckie
Christmas Light-Up Rubber Duckie

Christmas Light-Up Rubber Duckie

$7.95

TOY TOWER Dog Hand Puppet
TOY TOWER Dog Hand Puppet

TOY TOWER Dog Hand Puppet

$8.95

Table Top Bowling Game
Table Top Bowling Game

Table Top Bowling Game

$22.99

Friendly Chime Rattle - Pink Bunny
Friendly Chime Rattle - Pink Bunny

Friendly Chime Rattle - Pink Bunny

$19.99

Djeco Ballerina Silhouette Puzzle
Djeco Ballerina Silhouette Puzzle

Djeco Ballerina Silhouette Puzzle

$22.99

LSU Tigers Enamel Silicone Bali Bracelet
LSU Tigers Enamel Silicone Bali Bracelet

LSU Tigers Enamel Silicone Bali Bracelet

$20.00

2 colors
  • Gold
  • Purple
Artist Easel Watercolor Pad
Artist Easel Watercolor Pad

Artist Easel Watercolor Pad

$18.99

Girls MeMoi 3Pk Panty Pack - Ditsy/Gingham/Stripe

Girls MeMoi 3Pk Panty Pack - Ditsy/Gingham/Stripe

$16.95

5 sizes
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
Love Your Locks Wet & Dry Scalp Massager
Love Your Locks Wet & Dry Scalp Massager

Love Your Locks Wet & Dry Scalp Massager

$8.95

3 colors
  • Pink
  • Lavender
  • Aqua
Macaron + Me Boxy Knit Tee - Turquoise
Macaron + Me Boxy Knit Tee - Turquoise

Macaron + Me Boxy Knit Tee - Turquoise

$25.00

3 sizes
  • 6/8
  • 10/12
  • 14/16
Crocodile Creek Soft Football - Dinosaurs

Crocodile Creek Soft Football - Dinosaurs

$18.99

BB Jr Splash & Play Fireboat
BB Jr Splash & Play Fireboat

BB Jr Splash & Play Fireboat

$24.95

Palm Pals - Brittany Avocado Toast
Palm Pals - Brittany Avocado Toast

Palm Pals - Brittany Avocado Toast

$10.99

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.