🎁 Need help finding a gift they'll love? That's our specialty.

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

A Little Joy Just For You!

Join the Olly-Olly crew! Cute outfits, fun toys, and zero overwhelm — delivered straight to your inbox.

By completing this form, you are signing up to receive our emails and can unsubscribe at any time

Gifts Under $25

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.

4827 Results

Clear filters
TOY TOWER Puffy Colorful Caterpillars
TOY TOWER Puffy Colorful Caterpillars

TOY TOWER Puffy Colorful Caterpillars

$7.95

Klee Tinted Lip Gloss - Assorted
Klee Tinted Lip Gloss - Assorted

Klee Tinted Lip Gloss - Assorted

$12.95

4 colors
  • Aspen Rhythm
  • Napa Sonata
  • Hudson Vibe
  • +1 more
Kid Made Modern Giant Crazy Crayon
Kid Made Modern Giant Crazy Crayon

Kid Made Modern Giant Crazy Crayon

$12.95

3 colors
  • Bright
  • Neon
  • Classic
Yummy Yummy Scented Twist Up Crayons - Set of 10

Yummy Yummy Scented Twist Up Crayons - Set of 10

$12.99

Sticker Dolly Dressing Unicorns
Sticker Dolly Dressing Unicorns

Sticker Dolly Dressing Unicorns

$9.99

Ooly Do-Overs Erasable Highlighters - Set of 6
Ooly Do-Overs Erasable Highlighters - Set of 6

Ooly Do-Overs Erasable Highlighters - Set of 6

$14.95

Unicorn 5Pc Ring Set w/ Display Box

Unicorn 5Pc Ring Set w/ Display Box

$12.95

Bit'O Cupcake Squishy (Assorted)

Bit'O Cupcake Squishy (Assorted)

$8.99

The Pits - Grumpy Fruit 2 Pack Sensory Squishy

The Pits - Grumpy Fruit 2 Pack Sensory Squishy

$12.00

ORB Easy Sqweezy Babies Blind Box

ORB Easy Sqweezy Babies Blind Box

$12.99

Marshmello 4X4 Mini Squishy Cube
Marshmello 4X4 Mini Squishy Cube

Marshmello 4X4 Mini Squishy Cube

$10.99

Capy Squeeze Sensory Toy- Assorted
Capy Squeeze Sensory Toy- Assorted

Capy Squeeze Sensory Toy- Assorted

$8.99

Waboba Gradient Bounceback Moonball
Waboba Gradient Bounceback Moonball

Waboba Gradient Bounceback Moonball

$14.99

3 colors
  • Orange
  • Green
  • Purple
Fluffmellies Booty Baozi - Ultra Slow-Rise Sweet Bakery Scented Squishy Toy

Fluffmellies Booty Baozi - Ultra Slow-Rise Sweet Bakery Scented Squishy Toy

$14.99

Crank Pop Candy

Crank Pop Candy

$6.99

3pk Dinosaur Mini Bubble Wands
3pk Dinosaur Mini Bubble Wands

3pk Dinosaur Mini Bubble Wands

$8.99

Malarkey Kids Chew Cube
Malarkey Kids Chew Cube

Malarkey Kids Chew Cube

$18.99

3 colors
  • Steel Blue
  • Mint Green Triangles
  • Pink Daisies
Great Pretenders Bling Bling Spinner Bracelet - Assorted

Great Pretenders Bling Bling Spinner Bracelet - Assorted

$8.99

Super Stretchy Snake

Super Stretchy Snake

$7.99

Lucky Duck Socks - Trout

Lucky Duck Socks - Trout

$10.95

4 sizes
  • 2-3
  • 4-6
  • 7-9
  • 10-12
Creative Knitwear LSU Eyelet Panty

Creative Knitwear LSU Eyelet Panty

from $20.00

7 sizes
  • 0-3m
  • 3-6m
  • 6-9m
  • 12m
  • 18m
  • 24m
  • 2T
Dancing Diva Blue High Heels (One Size)
Dancing Diva Blue High Heels (One Size)

Dancing Diva Blue High Heels (One Size)

$25.00

For Keeps Pink Bottle Rattle and Pacifier
For Keeps Pink Bottle Rattle and Pacifier

For Keeps Pink Bottle Rattle and Pacifier

$12.99

Fluffy Faux Fur Bunny Rabbit Keychains

Fluffy Faux Fur Bunny Rabbit Keychains

$14.00

11 colors
  • White
  • Lavender
  • +8 more
Wee Ones Mini French Satin Long Tail Bow
Wee Ones Mini French Satin Long Tail Bow

Wee Ones Mini French Satin Long Tail Bow

$14.00

7 colors
  • White
  • Navy
  • +4 more
Tutti Frutti Scented Modeling Dough 3.5oz Tub
Tutti Frutti Scented Modeling Dough 3.5oz Tub

Tutti Frutti Scented Modeling Dough 3.5oz Tub

$3.00

Two's Company Christmas Light Up Ring
Two's Company Christmas Light Up Ring

Two's Company Christmas Light Up Ring

$5.00

Musee Bath Sugar Plum Fairy Bath Balm

Musee Bath Sugar Plum Fairy Bath Balm

$14.00

Great Pretenders Boutique Chic Bumpy Bead Bracelet
Great Pretenders Boutique Chic Bumpy Bead Bracelet

Great Pretenders Boutique Chic Bumpy Bead Bracelet

$8.95

Great Pretenders Boutique Chic 2Pc With All My Heart Bracelet
Great Pretenders Boutique Chic 2Pc With All My Heart Bracelet

Great Pretenders Boutique Chic 2Pc With All My Heart Bracelet

$10.95

Holiday Poppers (Assorted)
Holiday Poppers (Assorted)

Holiday Poppers (Assorted)

$15.00

Color Stack to Go Erasable Crayons - Believe in Magic
Color Stack to Go Erasable Crayons - Believe in Magic

Color Stack to Go Erasable Crayons - Believe in Magic

$6.95

Taylor Swift 1989 Pouch

Taylor Swift 1989 Pouch

$24.99

Streamline rainbow sticky notepad
Streamline rainbow sticky notepad, additional view

Rainbow Sticky Notepad

$7.95

Black Paper Sketch Pad
Black Paper Sketch Pad

Black Paper Sketch Pad

$8.95

Mystery Ballerz Remote Control Car
Mystery Ballerz Remote Control Car

Mystery Ballerz Remote Control Car

$24.95

Excavator Boxed Bath Balm

Excavator Boxed Bath Balm

$12.00

Lilliput Little Things Earrings - King Cake

Lilliput Little Things Earrings - King Cake

$12.00

Lucky Duck Socks- Vintage Camo

Lucky Duck Socks- Vintage Camo

$10.95

4 sizes
  • 2-3
  • 4-6
  • 7-9
  • 10-12
Little People Big Dreams - Queen Elizabeth II

Little People Big Dreams - Queen Elizabeth II

$15.99

Azarhia Jeweled Rhinestone Gameday Tiger Face Headband

Azarhia Jeweled Rhinestone Gameday Tiger Face Headband

$25.00

Fat Brain Dimpl Clutch
Fat Brain Dimpl Clutch

Fat Brain Dimpl Clutch

$16.95

Jefferies Socks Smooth Toe Tatted Edge Turn Cuff Socks - 1 Pair

Jefferies Socks Smooth Toe Tatted Edge Turn Cuff Socks - 1 Pair

$6.95

6 sizes
  • NB (0-1)
  • INF (1-4)
  • TD (3-7)
  • XS (6-11)
  • S (9-1)
  • MD (12-6)
Bug Lights Rechargeable Flashlight

Bug Lights Rechargeable Flashlight

$12.95

Lilliput Little Things Earrings - Marching Boots

Lilliput Little Things Earrings - Marching Boots

$12.00

Robot Claw Grabber
Robot Claw Grabber

Robot Claw Grabber

$12.95

Floss & Rock Color Changing Umbrella - Dinosaurs
Floss & Rock Color Changing Umbrella - Dinosaurs

Floss & Rock Color Changing Umbrella - Dinosaurs

$24.99

Night-Night Louisiana Board Book

Night-Night Louisiana Board Book

$9.99

Fizzles - 3 Pack Colorful Bath Magic For Kids
Fizzles - 3 Pack Colorful Bath Magic For Kids

Fizzles - 3 Pack Colorful Bath Magic For Kids

$19.95

2 colors
  • Blue/Green/Red
  • Purple/Pink/Orange
Crackling Crunchy Dragon Fruit Squishy
Crackling Crunchy Dragon Fruit Squishy

Crackling Crunchy Dragon Fruit Squishy

$12.99

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.