🎁 Need help finding a gift they'll love? That's our specialty.

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

A Little Joy Just For You!

Join the Olly-Olly crew! Cute outfits, fun toys, and zero overwhelm — delivered straight to your inbox.

By completing this form, you are signing up to receive our emails and can unsubscribe at any time

Gifts Under $25

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.

4827 Results

Clear filters
Hot Focus Mega Sketching Fun - Floral

Hot Focus Mega Sketching Fun - Floral

$24.99

Aurora Palm Pals Sparkle Birthday Cupcake plush

Palm Pals - Sparkle Birthday Cupcake

$12.99

Jumbo Bao Buddies Dumplings Sensory Toys
Jumbo Bao Buddies Dumplings Sensory Toys

Jumbo Bao Buddies Dumplings Sensory Toys

$15.99

Peaceable Kingdom Stickers (Assorted)
Peaceable Kingdom Stickers (Assorted)

Peaceable Kingdom Stickers (Assorted)

$4.99

AMOS Peelerz Gummy Orange

AMOS Peelerz Gummy Orange

$8.99

Mystery Tin Bao Bunny Furry Kawaii Plush Keychain
Mystery Tin Bao Bunny Furry Kawaii Plush Keychain

Mystery Tin Bao Bunny Furry Kawaii Plush Keychain

$18.99

Hot Focus Sketching Fun - Critter

Hot Focus Sketching Fun - Critter

$19.99

Fluffmellies Bread - Ultra Slow-Rise Sweet Bakery Scented Squishy Toy

Fluffmellies Bread - Ultra Slow-Rise Sweet Bakery Scented Squishy Toy

$18.00

iScream Dance Lip Balm

iScream Dance Lip Balm

$8.99

Trace-to-Doodle- Style Your Space

Trace-to-Doodle- Style Your Space

$18.00

Laura Kelly Games on the Go - Coastal Dots and Boxes

Laura Kelly Games on the Go - Coastal Dots and Boxes

$10.00

Sweet Beads

Sweet Beads

$6.99

iScream Palm Paradise Lip Balm Set
iScream Palm Paradise Lip Balm Set

iScream Palm Paradise Lip Balm Set

$16.99

Sticky Rainbow Corgi Squishy
Sticky Rainbow Corgi Squishy

Sticky Rainbow Corgi Squishy

$7.99

Wigglitz Punch & Plush Friend 2Pk
Wigglitz Punch & Plush Friend 2Pk

Wigglitz Punch & Plush Friend 2Pk

$9.99

NOVA 3-D Coloring Unicorn
NOVA 3-D Coloring Unicorn

NOVA 3-D Coloring Unicorn

$25.00

18" Ribbon Dancer

18" Ribbon Dancer

$8.99

2 colors
  • Blue
  • Pink
10" Light Up Wiggle Sensory Rainbow Lobster
10" Light Up Wiggle Sensory Rainbow Lobster

10" Light Up Wiggle Sensory Rainbow Lobster

$8.99

Gem Pets - Dig, Decorate & Display
Gem Pets - Dig, Decorate & Display

Gem Pets - Dig, Decorate & Display

$18.99

Wee Ones Printed Princess Bow

Wee Ones Printed Princess Bow

from $13.00

3 sizes
  • Mini
  • Medium
  • King
Fizzles Volcano Bath Bomb
Fizzles Volcano Bath Bomb

Fizzles Volcano Bath Bomb

$8.99

5 colors
  • Blue
  • Purple
  • +2 more
Teleties Hair Brush- Detangler
Teleties Hair Brush- Detangler

Teleties Hair Brush- Detangler

$22.00

2 colors
  • Tortoise
  • Beige
Farm Friends XXL Coloring Book
Farm Friends XXL Coloring Book

Farm Friends XXL Coloring Book

$14.99

Sticker Doll Dress Up Easter Fun

Sticker Doll Dress Up Easter Fun

$8.99

Tiger Tribe My Diary - Unicorn Rainbows

Tiger Tribe My Diary - Unicorn Rainbows

$14.99

Omy Pro Kids Sticky Earrings- Unicorn
Omy Pro Kids Sticky Earrings- Unicorn

Omy Pro Kids Sticky Earrings- Unicorn

$12.99

Omy Pro Sticker by Number- Bubble Tea
Omy Pro Sticker by Number- Bubble Tea

Omy Pro Sticker by Number- Bubble Tea

$12.99

iScream Make It Shine Makeup Brushes Set
iScream Make It Shine Makeup Brushes Set

iScream Make It Shine Makeup Brushes Set

$15.99

King Wee Ones Splish Splash Vinyl Bow
King Wee Ones Splish Splash Vinyl Bow

King Wee Ones Splish Splash Vinyl Bow

$20.00

4 colors
  • Shocking Pink
  • Royal Orchid
  • Hot Pink
  • +1 more
TOY TOWER Spiky Light up Ball Assorted Colors

TOY TOWER Spiky Light up Ball Assorted Colors

$5.95

iScream Rainbow Heart Bracelet

iScream Rainbow Heart Bracelet

$15.00

Jefferies Socks Chantilly Lace Turn Cuff Socks 1 Pair

Jefferies Socks Chantilly Lace Turn Cuff Socks 1 Pair

$9.95

5 sizes
  • NB (0-1)
  • INFANT (1-4)
  • TODDLER (3-7)
  • XS (6-11)
  • SMALL (9-1)
Bari Lynn Charm and Crystals Snapclip - Cutesters

Bari Lynn Charm and Crystals Snapclip - Cutesters

$16.99

4 colors
  • Purple
  • +1 more
Scratch and Sketch - Ballet

Scratch and Sketch - Ballet

$14.99

Scratch and Sketch - Robots

Scratch and Sketch - Robots

$14.99

Kiss Keeper- Lip Peptide, Phone Case attachment
Kiss Keeper- Lip Peptide, Phone Case attachment

Kiss Keeper- Lip Peptide, Phone Case attachment

$22.99

3 colors
  • Rose
Great Pretenders Boutique Unicorn Daydream Bangle Set, 2pc

Great Pretenders Boutique Unicorn Daydream Bangle Set, 2pc

$10.95

Lifelines Rub & Sniff color pencils 10-pack
Lifelines Rub & Sniff color pencils, additional view

Lifelines Rub & Sniff Color Pencils 10pack

$16.99

Bird Dogs Board Book - Mossy Oak

Bird Dogs Board Book - Mossy Oak

$11.95

Boutique Regal Tiara

Boutique Regal Tiara

$14.99

Princess Doll w/ Slime (Assorted)

Princess Doll w/ Slime (Assorted)

$12.99

Sage & Lilly Scallop Leggings - Red

Sage & Lilly Scallop Leggings - Red

$22.00

5 sizes
  • 3T
  • 4T
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
Light Up Gear Sword Toy
Light Up Gear Sword Toy

Light Up Gear Sword Toy

$22.99

2 colors
  • Orange/Blue
  • Green/Brown
Fluo Peps Classic Glitter Highlighter x4

Fluo Peps Classic Glitter Highlighter x4

$12.99

Fluo Peps Classic Pastel Highlighter x6
Fluo Peps Classic Pastel Highlighter x6

Fluo Peps Classic Pastel Highlighter x6

$12.99

Mobi Gumlii Sensory Teether + Rattle Toy
Mobi Gumlii Sensory Teether + Rattle Toy

Mobi Gumlii Sensory Teether + Rattle Toy

$24.99

Lucky Duck Socks - Flying Pheasant

Lucky Duck Socks - Flying Pheasant

$10.95

4 sizes
  • 2-3
  • 4-6
  • 7-9
  • 10-12
Real Planet realistic stuffed tiger plush

Real Planet Stuffed Tiger

$19.99

Wee Ones Mini Grosgrain Bowtie with Tails
Wee Ones Mini Grosgrain Bowtie with Tails

Wee Ones Mini Grosgrain Bowtie with Tails

$14.00

3 colors
  • White
  • Light Pink
Critter Popz - Unicorn Ball Blaster
Critter Popz - Unicorn Ball Blaster

Critter Popz - Unicorn Ball Blaster

$14.00

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.