🎁 Need help finding a gift they'll love? That's our specialty.

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

A Little Joy Just For You!

Join the Olly-Olly crew! Cute outfits, fun toys, and zero overwhelm — delivered straight to your inbox.

By completing this form, you are signing up to receive our emails and can unsubscribe at any time

Gifts Under $25

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.

4827 Results

Clear filters
TOY TOWER 5" Plush Kitty with Carry Case

TOY TOWER 5" Plush Kitty with Carry Case

$12.99

iScream Beautiful Blossom Nail Polish Set
iScream Beautiful Blossom Nail Polish Set

iScream Beautiful Blossom Nail Polish Set

$12.99

Dope Slimes - Dope Whip
Dope Slimes - Dope Whip

Dope Slimes - Dope Whip

$18.99

Hatley Shark Slide On Sandals - Carrot

Hatley Shark Slide On Sandals - Carrot

$25.00

9 sizes
  • 8
  • 9
  • 10
  • 11
  • 12
  • 13
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
Jane Marie Easter Necklace

Jane Marie Easter Necklace

$16.95

Pickle Everything Card Game - The Sports Deck

Pickle Everything Card Game - The Sports Deck

$10.99

Belle Cher Athletic Pastel Stripe High Low Tank Top

Belle Cher Athletic Pastel Stripe High Low Tank Top

$25.00

10 sizes
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
  • 8
  • 10
  • 12
  • 14
Atomic Ball
Atomic Ball

Atomic Ball

$7.99

Dual Tint Sheer Flower Shaped Lip Balm
Dual Tint Sheer Flower Shaped Lip Balm

Dual Tint Sheer Flower Shaped Lip Balm

$8.99

Pets 2 Love - Assorted
Pets 2 Love - Assorted

Pets 2 Love - Assorted

$12.99

Great Pretenders Furry Friends Mini Journal - Bunny
Great Pretenders Furry Friends Mini Journal - Bunny

Great Pretenders Furry Friends Mini Journal - Bunny

$12.99

Lip Service Gloss- to-Balm Treatment - Pocket Size
Lip Service Gloss- to-Balm Treatment - Pocket Size

Lip Service Gloss- to-Balm Treatment - Pocket Size

$22.95

Palm Pals - Luigi Broccoli
Palm Pals - Luigi Broccoli

Palm Pals - Luigi Broccoli

$12.99

Hotlix Chocolate Covered Insects

Hotlix Chocolate Covered Insects

$6.00

Valentine ponytail streamer with hearts

Valentine Ponytail Streamer

$16.99

e-newton Girl Hope Unwritten Colorful Bracelet (Assorted)
e-newton Girl Hope Unwritten Colorful Bracelet (Assorted)

e-newton Girl Hope Unwritten Colorful Bracelet (Assorted)

$16.00

7 colors
  • Light Blue
  • Blue
  • +4 more
OMG Stretch Wormiez

OMG Stretch Wormiez

$9.95

Dope Slimes - Mermaid Fantasy

Dope Slimes - Mermaid Fantasy

$16.95

Tinsel & Glow Lip Balm Set

Tinsel & Glow Lip Balm Set

$15.99

Little People Big Dreams - Taylor Swift

Little People Big Dreams - Taylor Swift

$15.99

iScream Pink Snow Globe Lip Balm
iScream Pink Snow Globe Lip Balm

iScream Pink Snow Globe Lip Balm

$8.99

iScream Sweet Santa Lip Balm
iScream Sweet Santa Lip Balm

iScream Sweet Santa Lip Balm

$8.99

Floss & Rock Construction learn-to-draw activity set
Floss & Rock Construction learn-to-draw activity set, additional view

Floss & Rock Learn to Draw - Construction

$18.99

Great Pretenders Boutique Chic Lilac Love Necklace
Great Pretenders Boutique Chic Lilac Love Necklace

Great Pretenders Boutique Chic Lilac Love Necklace

$10.95

Hasbro Pound Puppies Newborns
Hasbro Pound Puppies Newborns

Hasbro Pound Puppies Newborns

$12.99

Rubber Duck (Large)

Rubber Duck (Large)

$25.00

Wee Ones King Sheer Iridescent and Grosgrain Overlay Hair Bow - Millenium Blue

Wee Ones King Sheer Iridescent and Grosgrain Overlay Hair Bow - Millenium Blue

$18.00

Medium Holiday Style Pom-Pom Edge Grosgrain Overlay Hair Bow
Medium Holiday Style Pom-Pom Edge Grosgrain Overlay Hair Bow

Medium Holiday Style Pom-Pom Edge Grosgrain Overlay Hair Bow

$18.00

2 colors
  • Red/Green
  • Red/White
Flix Candy Elf On the Shelf Lollipop Pop Ups!

Flix Candy Elf On the Shelf Lollipop Pop Ups!

$10.99

Living Royal Dino Socks
Living Royal Dino Socks

Living Royal Dino Socks

$12.99

Little Golden Book Baby's Christmas

Little Golden Book Baby's Christmas

$4.99

TOY TOWER Professor Puzzle: Go Farm Game
TOY TOWER Professor Puzzle: Go Farm Game

TOY TOWER Professor Puzzle: Go Farm Game

$6.95

Gel Pentastic - Junk Food

Gel Pentastic - Junk Food

$12.95

My Sticker Dress-Up Fashionista

My Sticker Dress-Up Fashionista

$9.99

Surprise Fairy Garden

Surprise Fairy Garden

$14.95

Girls MeMoi 3Pk Panty Pack - Bows/Scattered Dots/Hearts & Stars

Girls MeMoi 3Pk Panty Pack - Bows/Scattered Dots/Hearts & Stars

$16.95

5 sizes
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
10Pc Felt Tip Brush Pen Black Edition Box
10Pc Felt Tip Brush Pen Black Edition Box

10Pc Felt Tip Brush Pen Black Edition Box

$16.95

Beauty Expression - Rainbow

Beauty Expression - Rainbow

$9.95

Calico Critters - Stack and Play Beds
Calico Critters - Stack and Play Beds

Calico Critters - Stack and Play Beds

$16.99

Chiffon Pearl Long Tail Hair Bow
Chiffon Pearl Long Tail Hair Bow

Chiffon Pearl Long Tail Hair Bow

$16.99

3 colors
  • Ivory
  • Pink
  • Black
Palm Pals - Cheerful Carrot
Palm Pals - Cheerful Carrot

Palm Pals - Cheerful Carrot

$12.99

That's Not My T-Rex board book cover

That's Not My T-Rex Board Book

$10.99

Pull String Clown Fish Bath Toy
Pull String Clown Fish Bath Toy

Pull String Clown Fish Bath Toy

$8.95

Collegiate Initial Charm Adjustable Bracelet
Collegiate Initial Charm Adjustable Bracelet

Collegiate Initial Charm Adjustable Bracelet

$14.95

16" Dr. Seuss Plush Max
16" Dr. Seuss Plush Max

16" Dr. Seuss Plush Max

$24.99

Good Luck Fishermen board book cover
Good Luck Fishermen board book, additional view

Good Luck Fishermen Board Book

$11.95

Maison NOLA Hubig's pie silicone teether
Maison NOLA Hubig's pie silicone teether, additional view

Maison NOLA Silicone Hubig's Pie Teether

$20.00

Imperial Yo-Yo (Assorted)
Imperial Yo-Yo (Assorted)

Imperial Yo-Yo (Assorted)

$7.95

Wooden Yo-Yo (Assorted)
Wooden Yo-Yo (Assorted)

Wooden Yo-Yo (Assorted)

$5.99

Match the Hatch Board Book

Match the Hatch Board Book

$11.95

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.