🎁 Need help finding a gift they'll love? That's our specialty.

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

A Little Joy Just For You!

Join the Olly-Olly crew! Cute outfits, fun toys, and zero overwhelm — delivered straight to your inbox.

By completing this form, you are signing up to receive our emails and can unsubscribe at any time

Gifts Under $25

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.

4826 Results

Clear filters
Fuzzy Bunny Wind-Ups

Fuzzy Bunny Wind-Ups

$5.00

Oh My Glitter 4pc Gel Pens
Oh My Glitter 4pc Gel Pens

Oh My Glitter 4pc Gel Pens

$12.99

Magical Unicorn Wand

Magical Unicorn Wand

$12.95

Great Pretenders Bejeweled Tiara
Great Pretenders Bejeweled Tiara

Great Pretenders Bejeweled Tiara

$14.95

2 colors
  • Gold
  • lilac
Tonies Paw Patrol Marshall
Tonies Paw Patrol Marshall

Tonies Paw Patrol Marshall

$22.00

Toy Train in a Tin
Toy Train in a Tin

Toy Train in a Tin

$16.95

Madeline Board Book

Madeline Board Book

$9.99

Rubbabu Soft Roller Animals- US Toys
Rubbabu Soft Roller Animals- US Toys

Rubbabu Soft Roller Animals- US Toys

$12.95

Gator - Junior Warmies Microwaveable Plush Animal Lavender Scented

Gator - Junior Warmies Microwaveable Plush Animal Lavender Scented

$19.99

Assorted Pringles Mini Puzzles- 50pcs

Assorted Pringles Mini Puzzles- 50pcs

$7.95

Mini Wooden Pull Back Train
Mini Wooden Pull Back Train

Mini Wooden Pull Back Train

$8.95

4 colors
  • Dark Blue
  • Light Blue/ Red
  • Red/Black
  • +1 more
Maison NOLA Silicone King Gator Teether
Maison NOLA Silicone King Gator Teether

Maison NOLA Silicone King Gator Teether

$20.00

2 colors
  • Green
  • White
Tiger - Junior Warmies Microwaveable Plush Animal Lavender Scented
Tiger - Junior Warmies Microwaveable Plush Animal Lavender Scented

Tiger - Junior Warmies Microwaveable Plush Animal Lavender Scented

$19.99

Jumbo Sidewalk Chalk

Jumbo Sidewalk Chalk

$9.99

Colors for Good Purple/Gold Adjustable Tiger Bracelet
Colors for Good Purple/Gold Adjustable Tiger Bracelet

Colors for Good Purple/Gold Adjustable Tiger Bracelet

$10.95

Acrylic Headband - Princess in Yellow Dress

Acrylic Headband - Princess in Yellow Dress

$24.00

Madeline HC Book

Madeline HC Book

$19.99

Never Touch a Tiger

Never Touch a Tiger

$10.99

Crackling Crunchy Brain Squishy
Crackling Crunchy Brain Squishy

Crackling Crunchy Brain Squishy

$12.99

Vinyl Sensory Fidget Toy Trading Mat
Vinyl Sensory Fidget Toy Trading Mat

Vinyl Sensory Fidget Toy Trading Mat

$25.00

Musky Kinz Mini Jelleez Squishy - Gravity Feed

Musky Kinz Mini Jelleez Squishy - Gravity Feed

$9.99

Slow Rise - Sprinkle Donut Squishy

Slow Rise - Sprinkle Donut Squishy

$12.99

Slow Rise - Pancake Stack Squishy

Slow Rise - Pancake Stack Squishy

$12.99

2-Tone Gummiez kitty squishy

2-Tone Gummiez Kitty Squishy

$8.99

Scrunchems Sugar Controller

Scrunchems Sugar Controller

$8.99

Cloud Nine Squishy

Cloud Nine Squishy

$12.99

Maltose Pineapple Squishy

Maltose Pineapple Squishy

$6.99

FlowArt® - Dot-by-Letter, Strolling through Fall
FlowArt® - Dot-by-Letter, Strolling through Fall

FlowArt® - Dot-by-Letter, Strolling through Fall

$18.00

Disney Princess Core Fashion Doll

Disney Princess Core Fashion Doll

$19.06

Corgi Burger Squishy

Corgi Burger Squishy

$8.99

Marshmello 4X4 Mini Squishy Cube - Glitter

Marshmello 4X4 Mini Squishy Cube - Glitter

$10.99

Netflix: Backpack Clip Blind Bag - KPOP Demon Hunters - 3" Collectible Figure
Netflix: Backpack Clip Blind Bag - KPOP Demon Hunters - 3" Collectible Figure

Netflix: Backpack Clip Blind Bag - KPOP Demon Hunters - 3" Collectible Figure

$12.99

Hot Focus Nail Diva Princess

Hot Focus Nail Diva Princess

$10.99

Whistle Missle Mini
Whistle Missle Mini

Whistle Missle Mini

$7.99

2 colors
  • Red
  • Blue
My Sweet Baby Magic Baby Bottles 2pk

My Sweet Baby Magic Baby Bottles 2pk

$12.99

Purple Bow Football Earrings

Purple Bow Football Earrings

$16.00

Taba-licious Jumbo Cookies Squishies

Taba-licious Jumbo Cookies Squishies

$15.99

Reigning Beauty Pink High Heels (One Size)
Reigning Beauty Pink High Heels (One Size)

Reigning Beauty Pink High Heels (One Size)

$25.00

Lilliput Little Things Earrings - Purple and Gold Cheer Megaphone

Lilliput Little Things Earrings - Purple and Gold Cheer Megaphone

$12.00

Hachimi Baked Bread Slow Rise Squishy

Hachimi Baked Bread Slow Rise Squishy

$14.99

Hot Focus Beauty Game Time
Hot Focus Beauty Game Time, additional style

Hot Focus Beauty Game Time

$15.00

Peachybbies- Dreamcloud Island
Peachybbies- Dreamcloud Island

Peachybbies- Dreamcloud Island

$18.99

Hot Focus Love Nails - Ballerina Beauty
Hot Focus Love Nails - Ballerina Beauty

Hot Focus Love Nails - Ballerina Beauty

$9.99

Dance Your Heart Out Beauty Set

Dance Your Heart Out Beauty Set

$19.99

Jumbo Glitter Mochi Squishy Sensory Fidget Toy
Jumbo Glitter Mochi Squishy Sensory Fidget Toy

Jumbo Glitter Mochi Squishy Sensory Fidget Toy

$6.99

Smart Toys and Games IQ Quub
Smart Toys and Games IQ Quub

Smart Toys and Games IQ Quub

$18.99

Lemon Lavender In the Buff Super Sudsy Soap Sponge
Lemon Lavender In the Buff Super Sudsy Soap Sponge

Lemon Lavender In the Buff Super Sudsy Soap Sponge

$10.99

Floss & Rock Coloring Pencils - Rainbow Fairy

Floss & Rock Coloring Pencils - Rainbow Fairy

$8.99

Floss & Rock Coloring Pencils - Princess

Floss & Rock Coloring Pencils - Princess

$8.99

Floss & Rock Scribble Sniffs Coloring Book - Construction

Floss & Rock Scribble Sniffs Coloring Book - Construction

$8.99

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.