🎁 Need help finding a gift they'll love? That's our specialty.

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

A Little Joy Just For You!

Join the Olly-Olly crew! Cute outfits, fun toys, and zero overwhelm — delivered straight to your inbox.

By completing this form, you are signing up to receive our emails and can unsubscribe at any time

Gifts Under $25

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.

4845 Results

Clear filters
Great Pretenders Boutique Chic 3Pc Heart Star Rhinestone Ring Set
Great Pretenders Boutique Chic 3Pc Heart Star Rhinestone Ring Set

Great Pretenders Boutique Chic 3Pc Heart Star Rhinestone Ring Set

$9.95

PomPom Festive Hat Plush Penguin
PomPom Festive Hat Plush Penguin

PomPom Festive Hat Plush Penguin

$22.00

Palm Pals - Rubi Ornament
Palm Pals - Rubi Ornament

Palm Pals - Rubi Ornament

$12.99

Naughty or Nice - 4Pc Dear Santa Beaded Stretch Bracelets

Naughty or Nice - 4Pc Dear Santa Beaded Stretch Bracelets

$18.95

Haku Yoka Crayons - Acorn
Haku Yoka Crayons - Acorn

Haku Yoka Crayons - Acorn

$14.00

Miss Bella Kitty Cat Heart-Printed Hairbrush
Miss Bella Kitty Cat Heart-Printed Hairbrush

Miss Bella Kitty Cat Heart-Printed Hairbrush

$16.00

Kid's Seamless Knit Chevron Crop Top - Bossy Pink
Kid's Seamless Knit Chevron Crop Top - Bossy Pink

Kid's Seamless Knit Chevron Crop Top - Bossy Pink

$20.00

2 sizes
  • S/M
  • L/XL
Tonies Favorite Children’s Songs - European Songs
Tonies Favorite Children’s Songs - European Songs

Tonies Favorite Children’s Songs - European Songs

$22.00

Wee Ones Medium Sheer Iridescent and Grosgrain Overlay Hair Bow - Pink

Wee Ones Medium Sheer Iridescent and Grosgrain Overlay Hair Bow - Pink

$14.00

Wee Ones Medium Sheer Iridescent and Grosgrain Overlay Hair Bow - Hot Pink

Wee Ones Medium Sheer Iridescent and Grosgrain Overlay Hair Bow - Hot Pink

$14.00

Petit Ami Girl Scalloped Christening Bib

$14.99

Rainbow Checker Key Chain Pouch
Rainbow Checker Key Chain Pouch

Rainbow Checker Key Chain Pouch

$12.99

Nylon Varsity Pouch - Star

Nylon Varsity Pouch - Star

$16.95

Living Royal Ice Cream Socks
Living Royal Ice Cream Socks

Living Royal Ice Cream Socks

$12.99

Living Royal Crystal Pink Socks
Living Royal Crystal Pink Socks

Living Royal Crystal Pink Socks

$8.95

Good Night Aquarium

Good Night Aquarium

$9.95

Cindy Lou Who 12" Plush Doll
Cindy Lou Who 12" Plush Doll

Cindy Lou Who 12" Plush Doll

$24.95

You Are My Baby: A Celebration of Parenthood
You Are My Baby: A Celebration of Parenthood

You Are My Baby: A Celebration of Parenthood

$16.99

Cat Hand Puppet
Cat Hand Puppet

Cat Hand Puppet

$9.95

Nella Pima Toile Burp Cloth Pink
Nella Pima Toile Burp Cloth Pink

Nella Pima Toile Burp Cloth Pink

$18.95

1 color
Bali Freshwater Pearl Silicone Children's Bracelet
Bali Freshwater Pearl Silicone Children's Bracelet

Bali Freshwater Pearl Silicone Children's Bracelet

$15.00

4 colors
  • Navy
  • Mint
  • Yellow
  • +1 more
Baby Club Chic Construction Printed Bib

Baby Club Chic Construction Printed Bib

$14.95

Baby Loren Pima Grey Dots Burp Cloth

Baby Loren Pima Grey Dots Burp Cloth

$14.95

Dream Time Acrylic Snow Globe

Dream Time Acrylic Snow Globe

$21.95

Princess Mermaid Soft Doll Toy w/ Brushable Hair
Princess Mermaid Soft Doll Toy w/ Brushable Hair

Princess Mermaid Soft Doll Toy w/ Brushable Hair

$16.95

CHARM IT! Gold Glitter High Top Sneakers

CHARM IT! Gold Glitter High Top Sneakers

$6.00

Great Pretenders Sweet Heart Necklace

Great Pretenders Sweet Heart Necklace

$10.95

2 colors
  • Pink
  • Purple
Diamond Dotz Starter Kits (Assorted)
Diamond Dotz Starter Kits (Assorted)

Diamond Dotz Starter Kits (Assorted)

$9.95

Diamond Dotz Dotzies 3pk Stickers (Assorted)
Diamond Dotz Dotzies 3pk Stickers (Assorted)

Diamond Dotz Dotzies 3pk Stickers (Assorted)

$12.95

Baby Club Chic Golf Printed Bib

Baby Club Chic Golf Printed Bib

$14.95

Galexie Glister - Cloud Nine

Galexie Glister - Cloud Nine

$17.00

Eva's House XL Ballet Slippers Hairbrush
Eva's House XL Ballet Slippers Hairbrush

Eva's House XL Ballet Slippers Hairbrush

$24.95

ZsaZsa and Lolli White Burp Cloth with Picot Trim

$16.95

Soft Swerve Swirl Cutie Enamel Stud Clip-On Earrings

Soft Swerve Swirl Cutie Enamel Stud Clip-On Earrings

$20.00

Unicorn Dreams Cutie Enamel Stud Clip-On Earrings

Unicorn Dreams Cutie Enamel Stud Clip-On Earrings

$20.00

Strawberry Ice Cream Cone Cutie Enamel Stud Earrings
Strawberry Ice Cream Cone Cutie Enamel Stud Earrings

Strawberry Ice Cream Cone Cutie Enamel Stud Earrings

$20.00

Shiny Tractor Floor Puzzle
Shiny Tractor Floor Puzzle

Shiny Tractor Floor Puzzle

$24.95

Garb2Art Birthday Pink Cat Lip Balm Card

$10.00

Happy Little Elves

Happy Little Elves

$6.99

Royal Pairs Matching Game

Royal Pairs Matching Game

$19.99

Patchology Rose Lip Mask

Patchology Rose Lip Mask

$22.95

How to Catch Santa HC

How to Catch Santa HC

$17.99

Little Me 2Pc Footie Set - Pink Damask Scroll

Little Me 2Pc Footie Set - Pink Damask Scroll

$24.95

2 sizes
  • PREEMIE
  • NB
How to Catch Santa BB

How to Catch Santa BB

$8.99

Lyle, Lyle, Crocodile Plush

Lyle, Lyle, Crocodile Plush

$19.95

Construction Site on Christmas Night

Construction Site on Christmas Night

$16.99

How the Grinch Stole Christmas - Full Color Edition

How the Grinch Stole Christmas - Full Color Edition

$19.99

Dinosaur, Dinosaur It's Christmas

Dinosaur, Dinosaur It's Christmas

$9.99

Roarie Dino Plush

Roarie Dino Plush

$24.95

Kickee Just So Animals Boys’ Boxer Briefs

Kickee Just So Animals Boys’ Boxer Briefs

$15.95

2 sizes
  • 3T/4T
  • XS (5/6)

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.