🎁 Need help finding a gift they'll love? That's our specialty.

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

A Little Joy Just For You!

Join the Olly-Olly crew! Cute outfits, fun toys, and zero overwhelm — delivered straight to your inbox.

By completing this form, you are signing up to receive our emails and can unsubscribe at any time

Gifts Under $25

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.

4845 Results

Clear filters
Bari Lynn Terry Bow Headband - Gummy Bears
Bari Lynn Terry Bow Headband - Gummy Bears

Bari Lynn Terry Bow Headband - Gummy Bears

$25.00

3 colors
  • White/Neon
  • White/Pastel
  • Pink
Iridescent Diamond Light
Iridescent Diamond Light

Iridescent Diamond Light

$24.95

Klutz Sew Your Own Unicorn Cake Pillow

Klutz Sew Your Own Unicorn Cake Pillow

$22.95

Creagami 3D origami unicorn modular paper folding kit

Creagami 3D Origami Unicorn Kit - Modular Paper Folding

$14.99

Pudus Classic Toddler Socks
Pudus Classic Toddler Socks

Pudus Classic Toddler Socks

$18.00

Halilit Train Whistle
Halilit Train Whistle

Halilit Train Whistle

$12.95

Nylon Varsity Pouch - Pink Daisy Chenille Patch

Nylon Varsity Pouch - Pink Daisy Chenille Patch

$16.95

Reversible Disc with Hot Pink Happy Face and Orange Heart Necklace

Reversible Disc with Hot Pink Happy Face and Orange Heart Necklace

$16.95

Jelly Bean Red Stripe Polo Shirt

Jelly Bean Red Stripe Polo Shirt

$24.99

2 sizes
  • 12M
  • 18M
God Hears When You Pray

God Hears When You Pray

$9.99

CHARM IT! Gold Hot Cocoa Charm

CHARM IT! Gold Hot Cocoa Charm

$6.00

CHARM IT! Silver Lil' Goldfish Charm

CHARM IT! Silver Lil' Goldfish Charm

$6.00

CHARM IT! Disney Gold Swivel Rapunzel Charm

CHARM IT! Disney Gold Swivel Rapunzel Charm

$6.00

CHARM IT! Gold Tooth Fairy Charm

CHARM IT! Gold Tooth Fairy Charm

$6.00

CHARM IT! Gold Barbie Girl Pink Heart Charm

CHARM IT! Gold Barbie Girl Pink Heart Charm

$6.00

Shimmering Mermaid Cosmetic Set
Shimmering Mermaid Cosmetic Set

Shimmering Mermaid Cosmetic Set

$14.95

Tonies Disney - Toy Story Jessie
Tonies Disney - Toy Story Jessie

Tonies Disney - Toy Story Jessie

$22.00

Tonies - Spidey and his Amazing Friends: Black Panther
Tonies - Spidey and his Amazing Friends: Black Panther

Tonies - Spidey and his Amazing Friends: Black Panther

$22.00

Buff & Shine Lip Scrub/Lip Oil Duo - Cupcake

Buff & Shine Lip Scrub/Lip Oil Duo - Cupcake

$20.00

Varsity Tie-Dye Smiley Face Top-Knot Headband
Varsity Tie-Dye Smiley Face Top-Knot Headband

Varsity Tie-Dye Smiley Face Top-Knot Headband

$22.95

Crocodile Creek Rock Pets - Turtle

Crocodile Creek Rock Pets - Turtle

$19.95

Palm Pals - Cordial Cherry
Palm Pals - Cordial Cherry

Palm Pals - Cordial Cherry

$12.99

iScream Smile Every Daisy String Lights
iScream Smile Every Daisy String Lights

iScream Smile Every Daisy String Lights

$19.95

iScream Hippity Hoppity Bead Set
iScream Hippity Hoppity Bead Set

iScream Hippity Hoppity Bead Set

$9.95

Great Pretenders Gold Metallic Love Life Leggings
Great Pretenders Gold Metallic Love Life Leggings

Great Pretenders Gold Metallic Love Life Leggings

$24.95

3 sizes
  • 3/4
  • 5/6
  • 7/8
Montessori Tactile Flashcards
Montessori Tactile Flashcards

Montessori Tactile Flashcards

$18.95

Play Dough Mini Jar - 4.8oz. Valentine's Candy Hearts Dough
Play Dough Mini Jar - 4.8oz. Valentine's Candy Hearts Dough

Play Dough Mini Jar - 4.8oz. Valentine's Candy Hearts Dough

$12.95

How to Catch A Reindeer

How to Catch A Reindeer

$10.99

Tonies - PJ Masks Catboy
Tonies - PJ Masks Catboy

Tonies - PJ Masks Catboy

$22.00

Breyer Horse Corral
Breyer Horse Corral

Breyer Horse Corral

$10.95

Grinch Plush Socks with Pom Poms
Grinch Plush Socks with Pom Poms

Grinch Plush Socks with Pom Poms

$14.95

iScream 4Pk Gummy Bear Rings

iScream 4Pk Gummy Bear Rings

$16.95

Hello Mello Cotton Candy Puff Slippers - Cloud
Hello Mello Cotton Candy Puff Slippers - Cloud

Hello Mello Cotton Candy Puff Slippers - Cloud

$19.95

3 sizes
  • S/M
  • M/L
  • L/XL
You're Getting a Baby Sister

You're Getting a Baby Sister

$8.99

Nutcracker Crunch Board Book

Nutcracker Crunch Board Book

$9.99

iScream Iridescent Organza Scrunchie Set
iScream Iridescent Organza Scrunchie Set

iScream Iridescent Organza Scrunchie Set

$14.95

Sparkle Red Velvet Headband
Sparkle Red Velvet Headband

Sparkle Red Velvet Headband

$16.95

Halloween Nail Polish Kit - Jack o Lantern
Halloween Nail Polish Kit - Jack o Lantern

Halloween Nail Polish Kit - Jack o Lantern

$19.95

Sounds Like Christmas Board Book
Sounds Like Christmas Board Book

Sounds Like Christmas Board Book

$23.00

Kids Clear Acrylic Keychain with Tassel
Kids Clear Acrylic Keychain with Tassel

Kids Clear Acrylic Keychain with Tassel

$14.95

Step Into the Nutcracker
Step Into the Nutcracker

Step Into the Nutcracker

$12.95

Great Pretenders Sting Sword
Great Pretenders Sting Sword

Great Pretenders Sting Sword

$18.95

Little Chefs in the Kitchen Board Book
Little Chefs in the Kitchen Board Book

Little Chefs in the Kitchen Board Book

$16.95

Madmia Crazy Socks - Shark (Ages 6-99)
Madmia Crazy Socks - Shark (Ages 6-99)

Madmia Crazy Socks - Shark (Ages 6-99)

$25.00

Tonies Paw Patrol Zuma

Tonies Paw Patrol Zuma

$22.00

Where's Waldo? Deluxe Edition

Where's Waldo? Deluxe Edition

$17.99

Acrylic Hair Clips - Notebook & Pencil

Acrylic Hair Clips - Notebook & Pencil

$20.00

Tattoo a Frenchie Ceramic Bank
Tattoo a Frenchie Ceramic Bank

Tattoo a Frenchie Ceramic Bank

$19.95

Petite Hailey Ssanso Tutu Skirt

Petite Hailey Ssanso Tutu Skirt

$25.00

3 colors, 4 sizes
  • Ivory
  • 1/2
  • 3/4
  • 5/6
  • 7/8
Replica Furry Tiger Skin Cap with Tail

Replica Furry Tiger Skin Cap with Tail

$18.99

3 sizes
  • small
  • medium
  • large

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.