🎁 Need help finding a gift they'll love? That's our specialty.

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

A Little Joy Just For You!

Join the Olly-Olly crew! Cute outfits, fun toys, and zero overwhelm — delivered straight to your inbox.

By completing this form, you are signing up to receive our emails and can unsubscribe at any time

Gifts Under $25

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.

4845 Results

Clear filters
Mud Pie Crayon Holder Set - Barn

Mud Pie Crayon Holder Set - Barn

$16.95

Transparent Electric Gears - Helicopter

Transparent Electric Gears - Helicopter

$19.95

The Mad Hatter’s Tea Party Games
The Mad Hatter’s Tea Party Games

The Mad Hatter’s Tea Party Games

$18.95

Stinky Pig Game
Stinky Pig Game

Stinky Pig Game

$16.95

iScream TTYL Eye Mask
iScream TTYL Eye Mask

iScream TTYL Eye Mask

$14.95

Tonies Favorite Children’s Songs- Spanish Playtime Songs

Tonies Favorite Children’s Songs- Spanish Playtime Songs

$22.00

Tonies - CoComelon 2: Getting Ready With JJ

Tonies - CoComelon 2: Getting Ready With JJ

$22.00

Tie Dye Rainbow Top Knot Headband

Tie Dye Rainbow Top Knot Headband

$16.95

Lilliput Little Things Earrings - Marshmallow Bunny

Lilliput Little Things Earrings - Marshmallow Bunny

$12.00

Sticker Chic: Rainbow/Street Chic Footwear Flair
Sticker Chic: Rainbow/Street Chic Footwear Flair

Sticker Chic: Rainbow/Street Chic Footwear Flair

$18.95

Klee Holiday Fragrance and Lip Shimmer Duo

Klee Holiday Fragrance and Lip Shimmer Duo

$19.95

Zubels 5" Santa Claus Bamboo Crochet Rattle (Standing)

Zubels 5" Santa Claus Bamboo Crochet Rattle (Standing)

$23.95

Tonies Naptime: Nature Sounds

Tonies Naptime: Nature Sounds

$22.00

Tonies - National Geographic Horse

Tonies - National Geographic Horse

$22.00

The Polar Express 30th Anniversary Edition

The Polar Express 30th Anniversary Edition

$19.99

TOY TOWER Sandimal Snakes

TOY TOWER Sandimal Snakes

$8.95

Nylon Varsity Pouch - Smiley Face

Nylon Varsity Pouch - Smiley Face

$16.95

Stretcheez Burrito Play Food
Stretcheez Burrito Play Food

Stretcheez Burrito Play Food

$14.00

Three Hearts Louisiana Teether

Three Hearts Louisiana Teether

$18.95

Corduroy Cosmetic Bag
Corduroy Cosmetic Bag

Corduroy Cosmetic Bag

from $22.95

2 colors, 3 sizes
  • Pink
  • Cream
  • Small
  • Medium
  • Large
Knitted Rattle with Wooden Grip (Assorted)
Knitted Rattle with Wooden Grip (Assorted)

Knitted Rattle with Wooden Grip (Assorted)

$16.95

Eyeconic 100Pc Food Shaped Puzzle

Eyeconic 100Pc Food Shaped Puzzle

$12.95

Mighty, Mighty Construction Site

Mighty, Mighty Construction Site

$18.99

Playhouse Magical Dough Jar (Large)
Playhouse Magical Dough Jar (Large)

Playhouse Magical Dough Jar (Large)

$19.95

Twinkle

Twinkle

$18.99

How the Grinch Stole Christmas HC

How the Grinch Stole Christmas HC

$16.99

I Loved You Before You Were Born - A Love Letter from Grandma

I Loved You Before You Were Born - A Love Letter from Grandma

$8.99

Mary Meyer: Puppy's Toy Tale Board Book
Mary Meyer: Puppy's Toy Tale Board Book

Mary Meyer: Puppy's Toy Tale Board Book

$16.95

LED Light Up Unicorn Pens

LED Light Up Unicorn Pens

$5.95

Dinosaur Christmas

Dinosaur Christmas

$16.99

Kindergarten Back to School Wand

Kindergarten Back to School Wand

$14.95

Good Little Citizens
Good Little Citizens

Good Little Citizens

$16.95

Wooden Animal Roller Toys
Wooden Animal Roller Toys

Wooden Animal Roller Toys

$14.95

Jefferies Socks Ripple Edge Turn Cuff Socks

Jefferies Socks Ripple Edge Turn Cuff Socks

$6.95

2 sizes
  • INF (1-4)
  • Toddler (3-7)
Mega Pop Unicorn

Mega Pop Unicorn

$18.95

Rainbow Fairy Shaped 20pc Jigsaw Puzzle
Rainbow Fairy Shaped 20pc Jigsaw Puzzle

Rainbow Fairy Shaped 20pc Jigsaw Puzzle

$22.95

iScream Spooky Scrunchie Set
iScream Spooky Scrunchie Set

iScream Spooky Scrunchie Set

$12.00

Madeline's ABCs Book

Madeline's ABCs Book

$8.99

Rainbow Plastic Spring

Rainbow Plastic Spring

$6.95

Swirly World Liquid Wand Pens

Swirly World Liquid Wand Pens

$12.00

Fuzzy Monster Inflatable Ball

Fuzzy Monster Inflatable Ball

$17.97

3 colors
  • Pink
  • Blue
Tails Touch and Feel Board Book

Tails Touch and Feel Board Book

$18.99

My Fairy Garden Mini Dolls
My Fairy Garden Mini Dolls

My Fairy Garden Mini Dolls

$10.95

A Valentine For Uni The Unicorn

A Valentine For Uni The Unicorn

$8.99

Great Pretenders Tower Princess Hat with Braid
Great Pretenders Tower Princess Hat with Braid

Great Pretenders Tower Princess Hat with Braid

$16.99

The Great Game Classic Sorry!
The Great Game Classic Sorry!

The Great Game Classic Sorry!

$24.95

Don't Tickle the Tiger

Don't Tickle the Tiger

$17.99

That's Not My Plane

That's Not My Plane

$10.99

The Most Special Flower Girl

The Most Special Flower Girl

$10.99

You're A Big Sister

You're A Big Sister

$10.99

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.