🎁 Need help finding a gift they'll love? That's our specialty.

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

A Little Joy Just For You!

Join the Olly-Olly crew! Cute outfits, fun toys, and zero overwhelm — delivered straight to your inbox.

By completing this form, you are signing up to receive our emails and can unsubscribe at any time

Gifts Under $25

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.

4827 Results

Clear filters
JellyRoos Plush Jellies

JellyRoos Plush Jellies

$13.99

e-newton Hope Unwritten Gameday Bracelet (Assorted)
e-newton Hope Unwritten Gameday Bracelet (Assorted)

e-newton Hope Unwritten Gameday Bracelet (Assorted)

$16.00

3 colors
  • Purple
  • Yellow
  • Purple/Gold
ORB Easy Sqweezy Tie Dye Dumpling

ORB Easy Sqweezy Tie Dye Dumpling

$15.00

Endless Bubble Wrap

Endless Bubble Wrap

$19.99

6" Beaded Seaside Bracelet
6" Beaded Seaside Bracelet

6" Beaded Seaside Bracelet

$14.00

11 colors
  • Pink
  • Blue
  • Off White
  • +8 more
Style4Ever Mini Sparkle Spiral Sketch Set
Style4Ever Mini Sparkle Spiral Sketch Set

Style4Ever Mini Sparkle Spiral Sketch Set

$9.99

Classic Dance Tight - Footed
Classic Dance Tight - Footed

Classic Dance Tight - Footed

$12.95

5 sizes
  • XS
  • SM
  • MD
  • LG
  • Xxs
A Pretty Girl is Pretty Inside Book: A Story of Inner Beauty
A Pretty Girl is Pretty Inside Book: A Story of Inner Beauty

A Pretty Girl is Pretty Inside Book: A Story of Inner Beauty

$18.99

Crunchy Ramen Squishy
Crunchy Ramen Squishy

Crunchy Ramen Squishy

$11.99

ASMR Crispy Wax-Covered Chocolate
ASMR Crispy Wax-Covered Chocolate

ASMR Crispy Wax-Covered Chocolate

$8.99

Waboba Dive Tail Diving Toys
Waboba Dive Tail Diving Toys

Waboba Dive Tail Diving Toys

$12.99

Lemon Lavender Sheet Dreams face masks
Lemon Lavender Sheet Dreams face masks, additional view

Lemon Lavender Sheet Dreams Face Masks

$6.99

My Sticker Dress-Up Swifties

My Sticker Dress-Up Swifties

$12.99

CHARM IT! Chain Charm Bracelet
CHARM IT! Chain Charm Bracelet

CHARM IT! Chain Charm Bracelet

$9.00

6 colors
  • Gold
  • Silver
  • Pink
  • +3 more
Sugar Swaps Fat Cats squishy cat toy

Sugar Swaps Fat Cats

$14.99

Mini Sparkle Dumplin'

Mini Sparkle Dumplin'

$10.00

Unicorn Mystery Rainbow Dumpling Squishies

Unicorn Mystery Rainbow Dumpling Squishies

$10.00

Dough Doughs Sugar Squish Glitter Cube

Dough Doughs Sugar Squish Glitter Cube

$12.99

Waboba LED Bounce Back Ball
Waboba LED Bounce Back Ball

Waboba LED Bounce Back Ball

$18.00

4 colors
  • Red
  • Teal
  • Yellow
  • +1 more
Jefferies Socks Eyelet/Turn Cuff/Lace Turn Cuff Socks 3 Pair Pack

Jefferies Socks Eyelet/Turn Cuff/Lace Turn Cuff Socks 3 Pair Pack

$12.95

5 sizes
  • NB (0-1)
  • INF (1-4)
  • TD (3-7)
  • XS (6-11)
  • S (9-1)
Hot Focus All-in-One Sketching Fun Set in Sweet

All-in-One Sketching Fun Set - Sweet

$22.99

Slow Rebound Squishy Cakes

Slow Rebound Squishy Cakes

$16.99

Rainbow Mystery Glitter Squishy Bun

Rainbow Mystery Glitter Squishy Bun

$15.00

MushMeez Taba Squishy
MushMeez Taba Squishy

MushMeez Taba Squishy

$12.99

Great Pretenders Birthstone Heart Locket
Great Pretenders Birthstone Heart Locket

Great Pretenders Birthstone Heart Locket

$12.99

BariLynn BeJeweled Tulle Tail Bow
BariLynn BeJeweled Tulle Tail Bow

BariLynn BeJeweled Tulle Tail Bow

$24.99

12 colors
  • Pink
  • Purple
  • White
  • +9 more
Season to Be Jolly - 24Pc Kids Press On Nails
Season to Be Jolly - 24Pc Kids Press On Nails

Season to Be Jolly - 24Pc Kids Press On Nails

$9.99

Jefferies Socks Smooth Toe Turn Cuff Socks 3 Pair Pack

Jefferies Socks Smooth Toe Turn Cuff Socks 3 Pair Pack

$12.95

5 sizes
  • NB (0-1)
  • INFANT (1-4)
  • TODDLER (3-7)
  • XS (6-11)
  • SMALL (9-1)
Sequin Velvet Top Knot Headband (Assorted)

Sequin Velvet Top Knot Headband (Assorted)

$16.95

3 colors
  • Purple
  • Gold
Unicorn Boxed Bath Balm

Unicorn Boxed Bath Balm

$12.00

Scrunchems Marshmallow Squishy
Scrunchems Marshmallow Squishy

Scrunchems Marshmallow Squishy

$12.00

Big-Mouth Rabbit Maltose Squishy
Big-Mouth Rabbit Maltose Squishy

Big-Mouth Rabbit Maltose Squishy

$5.00

2 colors
  • Yellow
  • Pink
iScream Ice Cream Stackable Markers
iScream Ice Cream Stackable Markers

iScream Ice Cream Stackable Markers

$8.99

Gold/Silver Mixed Cube & Round Bracelet Assortment
Gold/Silver Mixed Cube & Round Bracelet Assortment

Gold/Silver Mixed Cube & Round Bracelet Assortment

$9.00

18 colors
  • Gold Cube Bracelet 3MM
  • Silver & Gold Cube Bracelet 3MM
  • Silver Cube Bead Bracelet 3MM
  • +15 more
Large Doughy White Strawberry Squishy (Color Changing)

Large Doughy White Strawberry Squishy (Color Changing)

$14.00

Sugar Squeeze Pointy Cube Squishy

Sugar Squeeze Pointy Cube Squishy

$9.99

Mini Fun Cheese Squishy
Mini Fun Cheese Squishy

Mini Fun Cheese Squishy

$10.99

Colorful Hacky Sack Kick Ball

Colorful Hacky Sack Kick Ball

$7.99

Guppy Squishy Glitter Fish Sensory Toy

Guppy Squishy Glitter Fish Sensory Toy

$7.99

3 colors
  • Pink
  • Orange
  • Blue
Star Charm Silicone Slip-On Bracelet
Star Charm Silicone Slip-On Bracelet

Star Charm Silicone Slip-On Bracelet

$9.99

7 colors
  • Hot Pink
  • Blue
  • Turquoise
  • +4 more
Dough Doughs Dumpling Squishy Rainbow Mystery

Dough Doughs Dumpling Squishy Rainbow Mystery

$10.00

Jefferies Socks Smooth Toe Sport Low Cut Socks 3 Pair Pack

Jefferies Socks Smooth Toe Sport Low Cut Socks 3 Pair Pack

$10.95

6 sizes
  • NB (0-1)
  • INFANT (1-4)
  • TODDLER (3-7)
  • X-SMALL (6-11)
  • SMALL (9-1)
  • MEDIUM (12-6)
Butterfly Boxed Bath Balm

Butterfly Boxed Bath Balm

$12.00

Dough Doughs Dumpling Squish Rainbow Unicorn

Dough Doughs Dumpling Squish Rainbow Unicorn

$10.00

MushyKinz Jelleez Squishy Maltose Base
MushyKinz Jelleez Squishy Maltose Base

MushyKinz Jelleez Squishy Maltose Base

$12.00

Squeezy Capybara squishy toy

Squeezy Capybara

$8.99

Birthday Gift Set - Confetti Tumbler with Lid/Straw & 10 Crown Hair Clips

Birthday Gift Set - Confetti Tumbler with Lid/Straw & 10 Crown Hair Clips

$18.99

2 colors
  • Lavender
Toxic Waste Slime Licker sour liquid candy tube

Toxic Waste Slime Licker Liquid Squeeze Sour Candy

$4.99

Jefferies Socks Smooth Toe Turn Cuff Socks - 1 Pair
Jefferies Socks Smooth Toe Turn Cuff Socks - 1 Pair

Jefferies Socks Smooth Toe Turn Cuff Socks - 1 Pair

$6.95

2 colors, 6 sizes
  • White
  • Navy
  • NB (0-1)
  • INFANT (1-4)
  • TD (3-7)
  • XS (6-11)
  • SM (9-1)
  • MD (12-6)
Jefferies Socks Ripple Edge Smooth Toe Turn Cuff Socks 2 Pair Pack - White/White

Jefferies Socks Ripple Edge Smooth Toe Turn Cuff Socks 2 Pair Pack - White/White

$9.95

5 sizes
  • NB (0-1)
  • INFANT (1-4)
  • TODDLER (3-7)
  • XS (6-11)
  • SMALL (9-1)

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.