🎁 Need help finding a gift they'll love? That's our specialty.

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

A Little Joy Just For You!

Join the Olly-Olly crew! Cute outfits, fun toys, and zero overwhelm — delivered straight to your inbox.

By completing this form, you are signing up to receive our emails and can unsubscribe at any time

Gifts Under $25

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.

4827 Results

Clear filters
Great Pretenders Taylor’s Bestie Bracelet (Assorted)

Great Pretenders Taylor’s Bestie Bracelet (Assorted)

$8.95

Slow Your Roll Freezable Face Roller
Slow Your Roll Freezable Face Roller

Slow Your Roll Freezable Face Roller

$16.99

3 colors
  • Pink
  • Blue
  • White
LEFT RIGHT CENTER! Game
LEFT RIGHT CENTER! Game

LEFT RIGHT CENTER! Game

$7.95

Mermaid Tail Lip Gloss

Mermaid Tail Lip Gloss

$7.95

2 colors
  • Purple
  • Aqua
Ballerina organza scrunchie with pom poms
Ballerina organza scrunchie with pom poms, additional view

Ballerina Scrunchie - Dance Recital Gift

$12.00

2 colors
  • Pink
  • Purple
Pointelle Bow Knee High Socks
Pointelle Bow Knee High Socks

Pointelle Bow Knee High Socks

$12.95

2 colors, 4 sizes
  • White
  • Ivory
  • TD (3-7)
  • XS (6-11)
  • S (9-1)
  • MD (12-6)
Whistle Rocket
Whistle Rocket

Whistle Rocket

$20.00

3 colors
  • Orange
  • Blue
  • Navy
Foodie Fusion 6" Smooshy S'mores Scented Squishy

Foodie Fusion 6" Smooshy S'mores Scented Squishy

$12.00

Squishy Pyramid

Squishy Pyramid

$8.99

Squishable 8" Squishy Corporate Cow

Squishable 8" Squishy Corporate Cow

$8.99

Collection of plush water wigglers with various ice cream and dessert-themed designs.
TOY TOWER - Two Flippin' Plush Cute Water Wigglers (Ice Cream Edition)

TOY TOWER - Two Flippin' Plush Cute Water Wigglers (Ice Cream Edition)

$12.00

Collegiate Initial Charm Necklace
Collegiate Initial Charm Necklace

Collegiate Initial Charm Necklace

$14.95

Jefferies Socks Smooth Toe Simplicity Lace Turn Cuff Socks

Jefferies Socks Smooth Toe Simplicity Lace Turn Cuff Socks

$7.95

5 sizes
  • NB
  • Infant (1-4)
  • Toddler (3-7)
  • XS (6-11)
  • S (9-1)
Moldable Vaseline Fuzzball Squishy

Moldable Vaseline Fuzzball Squishy

$12.00

Mystery Gummy Bearz
Mystery Gummy Bearz

Mystery Gummy Bearz

$8.99

Easy Sqweezy Super Cheese Squishy
Easy Sqweezy Super Cheese Squishy

Easy Sqweezy Super Cheese Squishy

$18.99

Jumbo Squij squishy hot dog

Jumbo Squij Squishy Hot Dog

$18.00

Martinelia Juicy Flavored Lip Gloss

Martinelia Juicy Flavored Lip Gloss

$8.99

Martinelia Royal Scepter Lip Gloss
Martinelia Royal Scepter Lip Gloss

Martinelia Royal Scepter Lip Gloss

$9.99

4 colors
  • Pink
  • Aqua
  • Purple
  • +1 more
Rollerball Lip Potion

Rollerball Lip Potion

$12.00

Palm Pals - Rose Pink Tiger
Palm Pals - Rose Pink Tiger

Palm Pals - Rose Pink Tiger

$12.99

Lilliput Little Things Earrings - Tiger Face

Lilliput Little Things Earrings - Tiger Face

$12.00

Dino Lights Rechargable Flashlight

Dino Lights Rechargable Flashlight

$12.95

3 colors
  • Brown
Ooly Switch-eroo Color Changing Markers -Set of 12
Ooly Switch-eroo Color Changing Markers -Set of 12

Ooly Switch-eroo Color Changing Markers -Set of 12

$15.95

ORB Smushers squishy toy with swappable faces
ORB Smushers squishy toy with swappable faces, additional view

ORB Smushers Sensory Toy Squishies w/ Interchangeable Faces

$16.00

5 colors
  • Pink
  • Yellow
  • Teal
  • +2 more
Highland Cow Maltose Squishy

Highland Cow Maltose Squishy

$9.99

Mystery Squishy Dumplin Palz

Mystery Squishy Dumplin Palz

$15.00

J'adore Gum Droppable Squishy
J'adore Gum Droppable Squishy

J'adore Gum Droppable Squishy

$12.99

Chill Cubez Sensory Toy
Chill Cubez Sensory Toy

Chill Cubez Sensory Toy

$8.99

Squishy Fuzzy Stretchi Blob
Squishy Fuzzy Stretchi Blob

Squishy Fuzzy Stretchi Blob

$8.99

Fun Doh Jumbo Sparkle Squishy Cubes (Viral Assortment)
Fun Doh Jumbo Sparkle Squishy Cubes (Viral Assortment)

Fun Doh Jumbo Sparkle Squishy Cubes (Viral Assortment)

$18.00

Rainbow Mystery Crystal Water Squishy Bun

Rainbow Mystery Crystal Water Squishy Bun

$15.00

Dough Doughs Squish Dumpling Blind Bag
Dough Doughs Squish Dumpling Blind Bag

Dough Doughs Squish Dumpling Blind Bag

$8.99

Bubble Lick Flavored Bubbles - Bubbles You Can Lick
Bubble Lick Flavored Bubbles - Bubbles You Can Lick

Bubble Lick Flavored Bubbles - Bubbles You Can Lick

$8.99

Cookeez Makery Pop-Tarts scented plush

Cookeez Makery Pop Tart Scented Plush

$22.99

Transformers Galaxy Version 01 Roll Out - Wave 2 Mystery Box
Transformers Galaxy Version 01 Roll Out - Wave 2 Mystery Box

Transformers Galaxy Version 01 Roll Out - Wave 2 Mystery Box

$9.99

Great Pretenders Boutique Chic Swiftie Pink Gem Bracelet
Great Pretenders Boutique Chic Swiftie Pink Gem Bracelet

Great Pretenders Boutique Chic Swiftie Pink Gem Bracelet

$10.99

Light-Up Monster Truck Push 'N Go Set - Orange/White

Light-Up Monster Truck Push 'N Go Set - Orange/White

$24.99

Wee Ones Mini Double Ruffle Bowtie with Tails

$12.99

5 colors
  • White
  • Red
  • +2 more
GP Gem of My Heart Spinner Rings (Assorted)

GP Gem of My Heart Spinner Rings (Assorted)

$6.95

Handy Famm Kids STEM Tape Measure
Handy Famm Kids STEM Tape Measure

Handy Famm Kids STEM Tape Measure

$20.00

Belle Cher Athletic White High Low Tank Top

Belle Cher Athletic White High Low Tank Top

$25.00

8 sizes
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
  • 8
  • 10
  • 12
  • 14
Great Pretenders Long Sword (Assorted)

Great Pretenders Long Sword (Assorted)

$20.00

Coconut Squishy Ball

Coconut Squishy Ball

$8.99

Crispy Wax-Covered Butter Squishy

Crispy Wax-Covered Butter Squishy

$16.99

Plush Yellow Chirpin' Chicks

Plush Yellow Chirpin' Chicks

$10.99

Hot Focus Stylish Writer - Bowtiful

Hot Focus Stylish Writer - Bowtiful

$18.99

Green Replacement Boot Tassel

Green Replacement Boot Tassel

$9.95

John Deere Johnny Tractor Flashlight
John Deere Johnny Tractor Flashlight

John Deere Johnny Tractor Flashlight

$19.99

Garb2Art Glitter Perfume (Assorted)
Garb2Art Glitter Perfume (Assorted)

Garb2Art Glitter Perfume (Assorted)

$14.95

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.