🎁 Need help finding a gift they'll love? That's our specialty.

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

A Little Joy Just For You!

Join the Olly-Olly crew! Cute outfits, fun toys, and zero overwhelm — delivered straight to your inbox.

By completing this form, you are signing up to receive our emails and can unsubscribe at any time

Gifts Under $25

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.

4827 Results

Clear filters
That's Not My Tiger touch-and-feel board book cover

That's Not My Tiger

$10.99

BB Jr My First Soft Car Assortment
BB Jr My First Soft Car Assortment

BB Jr My First Soft Car Assortment

$16.95

My LullaBible for Girls

My LullaBible for Girls

$18.99

Jefferies Socks Misty Ruffle Lace Turn Cuff Socks
Jefferies Socks Misty Ruffle Lace Turn Cuff Socks

Jefferies Socks Misty Ruffle Lace Turn Cuff Socks

$7.95

2 colors, 6 sizes
  • White
  • Navy
  • NB (0-1)
  • INF (1-4)
  • TD (3-7)
  • XS (6-11)
  • S (9-1)
  • MD (12-6)
Tenzi - The World's Fastest Dice Game
Tenzi - The World's Fastest Dice Game

Tenzi - The World's Fastest Dice Game

$22.00

ORB Easy Sqweezy Corn

ORB Easy Sqweezy Corn

$16.00

Fruity Banana Maltose Squishy

Fruity Banana Maltose Squishy

$14.00

Rainbow Mystery Glitter Dumplings Mini

Rainbow Mystery Glitter Dumplings Mini

$15.00

Mystery Tie Dye/Glitter Dumplings 3.5"

Mystery Tie Dye/Glitter Dumplings 3.5"

$15.00

Sparkle Sugar Squishy Pumpkin

Sparkle Sugar Squishy Pumpkin

$9.99

Slow Rise Asorted Chocolate Bars
Slow Rise Asorted Chocolate Bars

Slow Rise Asorted Chocolate Bars

$10.99

3 colors
  • Yellow
  • Pink
  • Brown
Diamond Ice Cube Sparkle Squishy

Diamond Ice Cube Sparkle Squishy

$10.99

4 colors
  • Orange
  • Purple
  • Pink
  • +1 more
Mystery 3.5" Rainbow Tie Dye Dumpling
Mystery 3.5" Rainbow Tie Dye Dumpling

Mystery 3.5" Rainbow Tie Dye Dumpling

$10.00

Slow Rising Hawaiian Bread Rolls (Assorted)

Slow Rising Hawaiian Bread Rolls (Assorted)

$7.99

Hachimi Oreo Cheese Cake Squishy

Hachimi Oreo Cheese Cake Squishy

$9.99

Dough Doughs Multi Bead Ice Cream Cone

Dough Doughs Multi Bead Ice Cream Cone

$8.99

e-newton e girl Hope Unwritten Bracelet
e-newton e girl Hope Unwritten Bracelet

e-newton e girl Hope Unwritten Bracelet

$20.00

Royal Coloring XXL Coloring Book
Royal Coloring XXL Coloring Book

Royal Coloring XXL Coloring Book

$14.99

The Monsters Plush Keychain Accessory
The Monsters Plush Keychain Accessory

The Monsters Plush Keychain Accessory

$16.99

2 colors
  • Fairy Tale
  • Tie-dye
Belle Cher Athletic Neon Pink High Low Tank Top
Belle Cher Athletic Neon Pink High Low Tank Top

Belle Cher Athletic Neon Pink High Low Tank Top

$25.00

10 sizes
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
  • 8
  • 10
  • 12
  • 14
Martinelia Little Unicorn Mini Trio Set
Martinelia Little Unicorn Mini Trio Set

Martinelia Little Unicorn Mini Trio Set

$10.99

Hotlix Scorpion Lick-It Suckers

Hotlix Scorpion Lick-It Suckers

$6.99

Great Pretenders Rainbow Sparkle Headband

Great Pretenders Rainbow Sparkle Headband

$16.95

Spy Invisible Ink Pen - Write and Read Invisible Messages
Spy Invisible Ink Pen - Write and Read Invisible Messages

Spy Invisible Ink Pen - Write and Read Invisible Messages

$16.99

Jefferies Socks Cluny & Satin Lace Turn Cuff Socks

Jefferies Socks Cluny & Satin Lace Turn Cuff Socks

$9.95

6 sizes
  • NB (0-1)
  • INF (1-4)
  • TD (3-7)
  • XS (6-11)
  • S (9-1)
  • MD (12-6)
Patchology The Good Fight Sheet Mask

Patchology The Good Fight Sheet Mask

$6.95

TOY TOWER - Gravity Magic Groan Tube

TOY TOWER - Gravity Magic Groan Tube

$8.95

Lil Wish Lanterns-Assorted
Lil Wish Lanterns-Assorted

Lil Wish Lanterns-Assorted

$24.95

Knot Today 2pk Detangling Combs (Assorted)
Knot Today 2pk Detangling Combs (Assorted)

Knot Today 2pk Detangling Combs (Assorted)

$9.95

3 colors
  • Pink/Green
  • Aqua/Yellow
  • Purple/Orange

Crystal Grass Pie Slushie Ball

$12.99

3 colors
  • Red
  • Yellow
Taba-licious Glow in the Dark Cubes
Taba-licious Glow in the Dark Cubes

Taba-licious Glow in the Dark Cubes

$8.99

Marshmello Gummy Bear Squishy

Marshmello Gummy Bear Squishy

$8.99

3 colors
  • Blue
  • Pink
  • Purple
Water Magic Activity Book
Water Magic Activity Book

Water Magic Activity Book

$10.00

Mystery Dumpling with Beads

$15.00

Jumbo Bao Buddies Metallic Dumplings Sensory Toys
Jumbo Bao Buddies Metallic Dumplings Sensory Toys

Jumbo Bao Buddies Metallic Dumplings Sensory Toys

$15.00

Squeez Fuzzy Cube

Squeez Fuzzy Cube

$9.99

Squashy Fruit (Assorted)
Squashy Fruit (Assorted)

Squashy Fruit (Assorted)

$7.99

Dough Doughs Multi Bead Banana

Dough Doughs Multi Bead Banana

$8.99

SQUISHI GUMMY CHERRIES CANDY SCENTED

SQUISHI GUMMY CHERRIES CANDY SCENTED

$12.99

Soda Dough
Soda Dough

Soda Dough

$16.99

5 colors
  • +2 more
Wee Ones Satin King Fabric Bow with Twisted Wrap and Whimsy Tails
Wee Ones Satin King Fabric Bow with Twisted Wrap and Whimsy Tails

Wee Ones Satin King Fabric Bow with Twisted Wrap and Whimsy Tails

$18.00

9 colors
  • White
  • Off White
  • +6 more
Beaded Sunshine Bracelets
Beaded Sunshine Bracelets

Beaded Sunshine Bracelets

$14.99

10 colors
  • Summer Resort 6”
  • Summer Surf 6”
  • Citrus Breeze 6”
  • +7 more
Camp Stationery Set - Notes From Camp
Camp Stationery Set - Notes From Camp

Camp Stationery Set - Notes From Camp

$15.99

Beary Bright stackable bear-shaped markers

Beary Bright Stackable Markers

$8.99

Jefferies Socks Classic Cable Knee High

Jefferies Socks Classic Cable Knee High

$8.95

6 sizes
  • NB (0-1)
  • INF (1-4)
  • TD (3-7)
  • XS (6-11)
  • S (9-1)
  • MD (12-6)
Squishmallow Mega Pop Keychains
Squishmallow Mega Pop Keychains

Squishmallow Mega Pop Keychains

$6.00

Fuzzy Dippin' Dots Journal

Fuzzy Dippin' Dots Journal

$16.95

Recycled Newsprint Scribble Pad
Recycled Newsprint Scribble Pad

Recycled Newsprint Scribble Pad

$10.99

Marshmello Squishy Pets

Marshmello Squishy Pets

$8.99

Orb Sugar Swaps Prismatic Cube Squishy
Orb Sugar Swaps Prismatic Cube Squishy

Orb Sugar Swaps Prismatic Cube Squishy

$12.00

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.