🎁 Need help finding a gift they'll love? That's our specialty.

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

A Little Joy Just For You!

Join the Olly-Olly crew! Cute outfits, fun toys, and zero overwhelm — delivered straight to your inbox.

By completing this form, you are signing up to receive our emails and can unsubscribe at any time

Gifts Under $25

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.

4827 Results

Clear filters
Kimmon Mimon

Kimmon Mimon

$25.00

ORB Kawaii Cuties
ORB Kawaii Cuties

ORB Kawaii Cuties

$14.99

Hot Focus Mega Sketching Fun - Strawberry

Hot Focus Mega Sketching Fun - Strawberry

$24.99

Scentco Geladough

Scentco Geladough

$14.99

Transformers Galaxy Version 02 SOS - Wave 2 Mystery Box
Transformers Galaxy Version 02 SOS - Wave 2 Mystery Box

Transformers Galaxy Version 02 SOS - Wave 2 Mystery Box

$9.99

The Elf on the Shelf® Frost Pips Mini Blooms

The Elf on the Shelf® Frost Pips Mini Blooms

$12.00

iScream Beautiful Bows Pink Plush Journal

iScream Beautiful Bows Pink Plush Journal

$16.99

Palm Pals - Sorbet Unicorn
Palm Pals - Sorbet Unicorn

Palm Pals - Sorbet Unicorn

$12.99

Baby Club Chic Hat with Picot Trim
Baby Club Chic Hat with Picot Trim

Baby Club Chic Hat with Picot Trim

$20.00

3 colors, 2 sizes
  • Blue
  • Pink
  • White
  • NB
  • 0-3M
En Route Glass Nail File

En Route Glass Nail File

$6.95

4 colors
  • Black
  • Pink
  • Blue
  • +1 more
Palm Pals - Belle Strawberry Cow
Palm Pals - Belle Strawberry Cow

Palm Pals - Belle Strawberry Cow

$12.99

TOY TOWER Translucent Harmonicas
TOY TOWER Translucent Harmonicas

TOY TOWER Translucent Harmonicas

$7.99

My LullaBible for Boys

My LullaBible for Boys

$18.99

Butter Squishy

Butter Squishy

$12.99

3" Sugar Squeezy Leaf Sheep Squishy

3" Sugar Squeezy Leaf Sheep Squishy

$8.99

Speks Gump Surface - Edge
Speks Gump Surface - Edge

Speks Gump Surface - Edge

$12.00

ORB Sugar Swaps Glitter Duck Squishy (Assorted)

ORB Sugar Swaps Glitter Duck Squishy (Assorted)

$10.00

Bath Fizzer Bubble Wand
Bath Fizzer Bubble Wand

Bath Fizzer Bubble Wand

$12.99

Whack Attack On The Go
Whack Attack On The Go

Whack Attack On The Go

$15.99

iScream Sherbet Swirl Ombre Lip Gloss (Assorted)
iScream Sherbet Swirl Ombre Lip Gloss (Assorted)

iScream Sherbet Swirl Ombre Lip Gloss (Assorted)

$8.99

Palm Pals - Priscilla Princess Kitty
Palm Pals - Priscilla Princess Kitty

Palm Pals - Priscilla Princess Kitty

$12.99

iScream Plush Bunny Pens

iScream Plush Bunny Pens

$5.95

3 colors
  • Pink
  • Blue
  • Purple
Palm Pals - Happy B-Day Cake 5"
Palm Pals - Happy B-Day Cake 5"

Palm Pals - Happy B-Day Cake 5"

$12.99

Play Tab Modular Activity Board Tiles- Sensory Set 2
Play Tab Modular Activity Board Tiles- Sensory Set 2

Play Tab Modular Activity Board Tiles- Sensory Set 2

$24.99

Lucky Feather New Connection Cuff
Lucky Feather New Connection Cuff

Lucky Feather New Connection Cuff

$22.00

Three Hearts Toy & Pacifier Clip
Three Hearts Toy & Pacifier Clip

Three Hearts Toy & Pacifier Clip

$18.95

19 colors
  • Baby’s Breath
  • Lavender Fog
  • White
  • +16 more
Vaseline Tomato Squishy

Vaseline Tomato Squishy

$12.99

Slushie Bear Squishy
Slushie Bear Squishy

Slushie Bear Squishy

$16.99

Squishy Steamed Bun Mystery Diamond Edition
Squishy Steamed Bun Mystery Diamond Edition

Squishy Steamed Bun Mystery Diamond Edition

$15.00

Axolotl Stretch Sugar Squishy

Axolotl Stretch Sugar Squishy

$7.99

Karen's Creations Purple/Gold Overlay Bows
Karen's Creations Purple/Gold Overlay Bows

Karen's Creations Purple/Gold Overlay Bows

from $15.00

2 sizes
  • Medium
  • Large
Solar Squishers (Assorted)
Solar Squishers (Assorted)

Solar Squishers (Assorted)

$10.99

5 colors
  • Blue
  • Orange
  • +2 more
ORB Easy Sqweezy Jumbo Goose
ORB Easy Sqweezy Jumbo Goose

ORB Easy Sqweezy Jumbo Goose

$20.00

2 colors
  • White
  • Yellow
Fuzzy Pudgiez Pig

Fuzzy Pudgiez Pig

$8.99

Dough Doughs Squishie Slow Rise Butter

Dough Doughs Squishie Slow Rise Butter

$12.99

Light-Up Marble Racers

Light-Up Marble Racers

$16.99

ORB Stretchee Foodz Secret Menu (Assorted) - Sushi/Taco/Pizza
ORB Stretchee Foodz Secret Menu (Assorted) - Sushi/Taco/Pizza

ORB Stretchee Foodz Secret Menu (Assorted) - Sushi/Taco/Pizza

$9.99

Deck the Hairs Hair Clips
Deck the Hairs Hair Clips

Deck the Hairs Hair Clips

$7.99

Dino Claw Grabber
Dino Claw Grabber

Dino Claw Grabber

$12.95

Plus Plus Critter Pack
Plus Plus Critter Pack

Plus Plus Critter Pack

$5.00

Halloween pony tail streamers for girls

Pony Tail Streamers - Halloween

$16.95

Dinosaurs! Matching Game
Dinosaurs! Matching Game

Dinosaurs! Matching Game

$22.99

Great Pretenders 30 Pairs Unicorn Sticker Earrings

Great Pretenders 30 Pairs Unicorn Sticker Earrings

$9.99

Rainbow Mystery Dumpling One Set Squishy

Rainbow Mystery Dumpling One Set Squishy

$15.00

Squeeze Ball Bubble Pyramid

Squeeze Ball Bubble Pyramid

$9.99

3" Sugar Boba Bubble Tea Squishy
3" Sugar Boba Bubble Tea Squishy

3" Sugar Boba Bubble Tea Squishy

$7.99

Hot Focus Mega Sketching Fun cherry sketching set

Hot Focus Mega Sketching Fun - Cherry

$24.99

Waboba Tailball Super Flying Indoor/Outdoor Toy
Waboba Tailball Super Flying Indoor/Outdoor Toy

Waboba Tailball Super Flying Indoor/Outdoor Toy

$18.99

3 colors
  • Green
  • Blue
  • Orange
Cookeez Makery Yum Yumz Surprise Pets Twin Pack
Cookeez Makery Yum Yumz Surprise Pets Twin Pack

Cookeez Makery Yum Yumz Surprise Pets Twin Pack

$18.99

Iscream Glistening Body Mist
Iscream Glistening Body Mist

Iscream Glistening Body Mist

$10.95

Find the perfect gift without overspending! Shop gifts under $25 for kids, including squishies, plush, games, and cozy holiday finds. We ship nationwide for a flat rate of $12.95.